Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Ok, so here's a question for you. I deal with a fair amount of specialized labor in my profession. In my experience, people of a certain nationality (and yes, occasionally race) are  typically unreliable and at their worst, dishonest and sketchy. I have lost a significant amount of money (in the thousands) because of my dealings with these groups. This perception has been reinforced several times and with multiple individuals/contractors within my particular area.

 

As a result of this, I have a hard time committing to employing the labor or consultation of these groups. It's not that I am dedicated to the idea that these groups as a whole are inherently untrustworthy, but in matters of business I filter them out as options. Would you consider this a matter of understandable discretion or is it bigotry? I'm undoubtedly passing judgment, but is it warranted?

 

To be transparent about this, the particular groups I'm speaking of are the Greeks and the Colombians.

Posted

if you don't want to be a racist, you can't refuse to consider people for employment based on their race.

surely there are metrics you could use to eliminate untrustworthy potential employees.

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

Race metrics! Vroom Vroom!!!

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

Additional references, start with the references that are a different nationality?

PhuturePriest
Posted

If you ask yourself the question, "Am I a bigot?", the answer is apparent.

Posted

To clarify: when I say "employment," I don't mean actual employees. We don't have any employees besides myself and my business partner. I'm more talking about patronizing businesses owned by these groups. So I actually mean using their services.

 

The references in my industry are very vague, and as we are a young startup in a new-to-us market/area, we did not have a firm grasp of the ley of the land when we made early business decisions. But the question pops up in this context again: if, as I've learned now, these businesses have a known reputation for subpar work and dishonesty, is discriminating against their services a bigoted thing to do?

Posted

If you ask yourself the question, "Am I a bigot?", the answer is apparent.

 

Avenue Q: Everyone's a little bit racist.

Posted

If you ask yourself the question, "Am I a bigot?", the answer is apparent.


I disagree. It's so easy for people to find prejudice where it doesn't exist that we're often worried that we might be crossing that line when in fact we're not. I'm not saying you should deny employment or services to people of specific backgrounds because you've had bad experiences in that area, but it might be wise to have a better screening process. This isn't being bigoted, merely exercising caution.
CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

If you ask yourself the question, "Am I a bigot?", the answer is apparent.

 

I just tried. It didn't work. #fail

Posted

@FuturePriest, I think that's being a bit too dismissive. In my experience, I cannot trust these shops or businesses to provide quality services. This is based on dozens of interactions and perhaps half as many actual transactions. On what basis should I continue to provide them the benefit of the doubt?

Posted (edited)

To clarify: when I say "employment," I don't mean actual employees. We don't have any employees besides myself and my business partner. I'm more talking about patronizing businesses owned by these groups. So I actually mean using their services.

 

The references in my industry are very vague, and as we are a young startup in a new-to-us market/area, we did not have a firm grasp of the ley of the land when we made early business decisions. But the question pops up in this context again: if, as I've learned now, these businesses have a known reputation for subpar work and dishonesty, is discriminating against their services a bigoted thing to do?

 

Is it more like a particular organization has a bad reputation or more like the group as a whole? If it is particular organizations, then I understand that. If it is a group as a whole and you don't have a history with them, then doing a little more background checking on the individuals might not be a bad idea. History of past performance should say more than just classes or grouping that don't tell you specifically about their work.

Edited by Light and Truth
CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

True, but he has stated that it's hard to get a background on these individuals. He's basically shooting ducks in the dark.

Posted

True, but he has stated that it's hard to get a background on these individuals. He's basically shooting ducks in the dark.

 

Some service business that serve organizations and business will offer references when asked. It's not a lot, but it is something. Also, joining a networking or industry group might be of value to talk to people who are more in the know about the business landscape.

Posted

Is it more like a particular organization has a bad reputation or more like the group as a whole? If it is particular organizations, then I understand that. If it is a group as a whole and you don't have a history with them, then doing a little more background checking on the individuals might not be a bad idea. History of past performance should say more than just classes or grouping that don't tell you specifically about their work.

 

The common consensus among other businesses that have provided me satisfactory service is that the distrust typically extends to the group as a whole. And this comes from a wide range of nationalities; Germans, Japanese, rednecks (duh), etc. Then again, I've also found a substantially greater amount of discrimination in other cultures than in the standard American business field; maybe this is a sign that you're correct in saying that it's more of a case-by-case screening issue than anythhing else.

PhuturePriest
Posted

It was a joke, people.

Posted

Another thing I've learned is that references can be very easily fabricated, especially within a tightly-knit niche market like mine. Knowing who to trust is a bit of a gamble, which is a major factor in why this question of bigotry arose.

Posted

The term is "societal trust".  Cultures with less of it will be more likely to screw you over.  So... if you are doing a risk assessment, culture could be a part of it without you being a bigot.

Posted

Your experience is your experience - good, bad, or indifferent. It's only racist when you apply individual experiences to all people of the group, as in, "I know an Irish guy who's a drunk; all Irish guys are drunks."

 

The only time, IMHO, it's permissible to generalize is when you're talking about a cultural trait. So if you're dealing with Muslims and they're never on the job on Friday afternoon, you need to figure out that it has to do with their holy day (the same with Jews on Saturdays or Catholics on Sundays)..

 

Other than that kind of cultural basis for action, about the only thing you can do is tighten up your screening process. And when you find someone you can trust to do an good job (not an easy accomplishment in ANY profession), send all your work their way.

GeorgiiMichael
Posted

I've found rednecks to be incredibly knowledgeable and reliable in the areas where I'm using their services. This, despite their uncouth demeanor.

Posted

I learned in mediation training that everyone has biases, the important thing is to recognize what your biases are, and not let them affect your decisions.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...