Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

My favorite book is the Book Thief and I seemed to have made it some other peoples favorite book so let us discuss it!

 

The movie just came out also. I haven't seen it but I don't think I will like after watching the previews for it. Any thought one people who have seen it and read the book?

Posted

I am still reading the book--just at the part where he is making the book for her from the pages of Mein Kampf.  I am just struck by the narration; how death is holding it all together but you forget really, because you get so into the story.  Then, boom. death comes back in.  I am still deciding what to make of the colors.  Maybe I will know at the end?  Don't tell me!!!!  I hope to finish it tonight.  I did not know that a movie had been made.  It would be hard to make a movie and not mess it up, I think.  

 

 

Posted

The first time I read it was in 6th grade (three years ago), and I could not figure out who the narrator was. I was reading it for a book club so I read it again it I suddenly knew who the narrator was. I will watch the movie but I will not like it.

 

 

Posted

Yeah, with this one I don't see how it could possibly be as good as the book.  I will try to finish it tonight and hopefully can talk more intelligently then LOL. 

 

So, you are interested in the Benedictines?  I use a prayerbook called the Monastic Diurnal used by St. Michael's Abbey in England.  It was approved for them to use and it has the Psalms arranged according to the order that Benedict made.  One column is English; one is Latin.  You go through them all in a week!  

Posted

I love Benedictines!!!! I might have to look into that prayer book. :think: Now I better go do my homework before school tomorrow... :cry:

Posted

I read that book for the first time around 6th or 7th grade, also. I remember some of the book and my impressions of it (That it was a good read and well written) but honestly I think I only remember about half of the plot. I guess it is time that I should read it again!

Posted

I read that book for the first time around 6th or 7th grade, also. I remember some of the book and my impressions of it (That it was a good read and well written) but honestly I think I only remember about half of the plot. I guess it is time that I should read it again!

 

Yeah, please do.  I can't believe I had never heard of it.  I've almost got it finished.  

Posted

Everyone on earth should read this book! I have declared this book as my favorite book of all time. My number two is In This House of Brede. Go and read this book people! Godspeed!

Posted

I have not read book.... yet.... so I have skipped over all above this to just let you know why I am not participating....yet.     :)   I am not boycotting your thread!  :)

Posted

You suggested a book for me now I have suggested a book for you. I read your now you read mine. I think it sounds fair! :p

Posted

yes it does... but i have to get to a library!

Posted

I finished it last night.  Wow.  The end, except for L., was bad.

Posted

I thought it was very fitting for the book but I wished he had written a sequel to it showing what life was like for L. after the war.

Posted

I thought it was very fitting for the book but I wished he had written a sequel to it showing what life was like for L. after the war.

 

Yeah, that would have been good.  It just kind of jumped and you had to assume a whole lot.  Although maybe that might have been the point.  

Posted

I don't know but I think his other books are good. You should give them a try. They are a little riska though.

Posted

Cartermia and those in this thread.... the main Book Club is down to selecting finalists on the February book, and one of the options may be The Book Thief.   Kind of creates a dilemma whether we could have 2 threads discussing the same book at the same time...would be very confusing.

 

IF you want to discuss this with the other Phatmassers, you may want to think about voting on the Book Club thread and indicating how you wouldl want this handled if Book Thief becomes the Feb book.   Do you want to merge the two threads?   Prefer the Book club select a different book?

 

Trying to be respectful to everyone... be sure your votes are counted!

Posted

I voted for the Book Club and have been trying to keep comments here kind of non-revealing while at the same time not ignoring Carter's thread!  Maybe we should just suspend discussion until the final vote is in.  Anyhow, that is my thought.  

Posted

I vote for ze Club! I just thought people would like this thread, with the movie just coming out and all.

Posted (edited)

Carter, would you put that comment into to the book club thread (if you haven't already done so) so people will be clear there is no conflict?  

 

Because voting goes on until Sunday, but people may be selecting a different book not wanting to dis your thread.  

 

Found myself there, in fact....

 

:)  :heart: :bible:

Edited by AnneLine
  • 6 months later...
Posted

I just finished this book last night. Cried at pretty much every chapter in part 10. Thanks for the recommendations jerks

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...