Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

After several years I've realized that, unlike most ex mo's, I don't want to throw God out of my life because my ancestors fell for a con. Various church visits later I've had the brilliant idea to check out the original Christian church largely because Mother Mary got me through my son's deployment to Iraq after my best friend (who shares her name) told me I could pray to her to intervene for my son. Sharing with another suffering mother meant more to me than any prayer.

Since RCIA began in October, I'm too late for that, study suggestions? I've started with the Ignatius Bible for Catholics, but Mass is very confusing when I go.

Posted

If you feel your theology is at a pretty basic level, Scott Hahn might be a good start. I think his book Supper of the Lamb would likely have a decent introduction to the theology of the Mass. If you feel that your theology is pretty strong to start out, then Spirit of the Liturgy by Josef Cardinal Ratzinger / Pope Benedict XVI is an excellent book on the Liturgy. If you are somewhere in between, and perhaps more on the devotional side, Dom Prosper Gueranger did great work on understanding the liturgical season and the Mass parts as a whole, although he did have some antiquarianist and Latin-imperialist bias. More a product of his time than any ill-will on his part. Good source overall.

Posted

Catholicism for Dummies by Fr. John Trijillo (spelled wrong, I know) is a great book. above books though, pray. try out different forms of prayer to see what is most comfortable: rosary, Lectio Divina, Liturgy of the Hours, etc or a combination of prayer. 

Posted

After several years I've realized that, unlike most ex mo's, I don't want to throw God out of my life because my ancestors fell for a con. Various church visits later I've had the brilliant idea to check out the original Christian church largely because Mother Mary got me through my son's deployment to Iraq after my best friend (who shares her name) told me I could pray to her to intervene for my son. Sharing with another suffering mother meant more to me than any prayer.

Since RCIA began in October, I'm too late for that, study suggestions? I've started with the Ignatius Bible for Catholics, but Mass is very confusing when I go.

 

 

Have you spoken to your priest about the Mass being confusing to you? He might have a spare missal he could lend you. I have had some that explain step by step what is happening and who says what and when. If you have money, buy yourself one, but why not ask him for help as well? He might have other suggestions to help you. I was fortunate to come into the Church before RCIA so I had private instruction with a priest and then was baptized and confirmed within a few months. It does seem too bad that you have wait until October before you can begin instruction, but then things are done differently these days.

 

Welcome to the Church and to phatmass. :)

Posted

Thanks to all, I remember how confused I got when I went through the temple at age 21. Oddly enough, I have not once yet felt an urge to giggle uncontrollably at Mass. And how I love all the statuary. I never saw a representation of Christ in a church until I attended a summer Methodist program at age 9, fell in love with the kindness in His face.

Posted

Wow, great story.  Interesting, because the other thread got me google searching about mormons and I found this thread at a different site and most of the ex-mormon's there turned atheist.  You are saying that's what you've usually seen happen in others who have left?  They become atheists?

 

I really have no idea about your background, knowledge level, or tastes, so I can't give recommendations, but there are no shortage of books (from many different centuries) that you could choose from.

 

Do you have any Catholic friends locally or are you on your own?

Posted

Wow, great story.  Interesting, because the other thread got me google searching about mormons and I found this thread at a different site and most of the ex-mormon's there turned atheist.  You are saying that's what you've usually seen happen in others who have left?  They become atheists?

 

I really have no idea about your background, knowledge level, or tastes, so I can't give recommendations, but there are no shortage of books (from many different centuries) that you could choose from.

 

Do you have any Catholic friends locally or are you on your own?

 

Oh yes, most former LDS become atheist/agnostic. I considered myself agnostic for several years and wanted absolutely nothing to do with any religion period. :p Most of the ex-mormon friends/relatives I have think my joining the Catholic church is akin to Jumping from the frying pan into the fire. :p
 

Posted

Oh yes, most former LDS become atheist/agnostic. I considered myself agnostic for several years and wanted absolutely nothing to do with any religion period. :P Most of the ex-mormon friends/relatives I have think my joining the Catholic church is akin to Jumping from the frying pan into the fire. :P
 

 

What are the biggest differences between the two for you? Not necessarily with the doctrine, but with your experience?
 

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Does your church have books in the pews with the readings? Has anyone ever shown you them? Because in the front of each of those is usually an "order of mass" that could help you follow along, if that's part of what you mean by mass being confusing. Otherwise the recommendations in this thread are all great. 

 

If you want something kind of basic, you could check out C.S. Lewis' Mere Christianity. He's Anglican, but pretty much everything in there is in line with what the Catholic Church teaches, and it really helped one of my friends when she was debating between LDS and the Catholic Church. If you've only been exposed to the LDS way of doing theology, it might be a helpful read. 

 

Also, if you haven't already, I'd recommend emailing or talking to your local parish priest or director of religious education or whoever runs RCIA and ask them for recommendations, too. 

 

And welcome to Phatmass. :)  I hope you stick around! 

Posted

If you want something kind of basic, you could check out C.S. Lewis' Mere Christianity. He's Anglican, but pretty much everything in there is in line with what the Catholic Church teaches,

 

^^^ That's a good idea.  It's basic enough to read if you are new, but it's still deep. 
 

Posted

Contact your parish about RCIA. There are some parishes out there that run year round inquiry/ RCIA sessions (my parish does this). At the very least they can help you figure out the order of Mass a bit better. 

I went through RCIA myeself and now help out as a sponsor/general morale support. PM me if you have any questions (even ones that seem "silly").

ToJesusMyHeart
Posted

Not about the Mass, but since you said that Mother Mary led you to the Church, you will likely enjoy this by Fulton Sheen.

 

"Mary: The Woman I Love."

 

 

http://youtu.be/TG5-RSevDBI

Posted

Ploomf routinely grills me about Catholic stuff as she's going through RCIA. She says it's helped her a lot, so if you get stuck, just start asking questions. :)

Posted (edited)

What are the biggest differences between the two for you? Not necessarily with the doctrine, but with your experience?

 

I'm only in RCIA so my experience is limited of course but so far there are several pretty big differences, some good, some I don't like so much. The best difference is that questioning is allowed and encouraged and they don't rush you into joining. As arfink said, I've grilled him pretty hard about Catholic doctrine and history, he was always very patient and never avoided answering or told me I was questioning too much. In the LDS church they really discourage this kind of questioning, just read the Book of Mormon, pray to get your testimony, and ignore anything that isn't faith promoting, it's all probably anti mormon lies anyway. Also, I've never felt rushed or pressured into joining the Catholic church and I really appreciate that, if I'd shown half the interest in the LDS church as I have the Catholic church they'd have had me dunked a dozen times over already. :P

 

Also there is less pressure to conform to a certain image the church wants to present to the world. The LDS church wants its members to be act and look a certain way and the culture can be brutal if you don't conform. No piercings (girls are allowed to pierce their ears once but no other piercings are allowed), no tattoos, neat appearance, very modest clothing, no facial hair or long hair for guys, no unnaturally colored hair, girls wear skirts and guys wear white shirts, ties, and black slacks to church. People will definitely question your faithfulness if you break any of these rules. At least in Idaho and Utah they will. I've heard from multiple people that Mormons outside of these two states are less uptight about this kind of stuff. :P

 

One thing I’ve loved since I’ve begun looking into the Catholic church is how many female role models there are. They are very few role models for women in the LDS church, it’s a very male dominated church. I’ve loved learning about all the female saints there are in the Catholic church.

 

The one thing I miss about the LDS church that I haven’t found in the Catholic church is a sense of community. Parishes are really large and can feel kind of impersonal. In the LDS church you were assigned a ward, so you went to church at the same place and the same time every week and you saw the same people every week. Wards tend to be very close and the members watch out for each other, if someone in the ward has something happen and needs help, you can bet just about all the members of the ward will hear about it before the day is out and you will have more help than you know what to do with. There are exceptions to this of course but this was my experience across several different wards over my active years. Also, the LDS church has a lay leadership for the most part, leaders are chosen from the local congregation and serve for several years and then are released and someone else is called to that position. While this has many draw backs, I found it did give you a sense of ownership and sweat equity in the church.

Edited by ploomf
GeorgiiMichael
Posted

And there's always the Catechism of the Catholic Church. It's certainly not a "sit down and read it" kind of book, but it's got the answer to almost any question you might have about what the Catholic Church believes and why. It's a good resource to have just to look up questions you have, if there isn't anyone around you can ask.

Of course, I do know some converts who decided that before they'd decide to convert, they'd just sit down and read through the whole thing, but they are definitely outliers in that regard.

Posted (edited)

One of the best books that teaches what it means to live a Catholic life, while simultaneously catechizing in the deepest possible way, is Christ, the Life of the Soul, by Blessed Columba Marmion.

 

If I were you, I would do the following:

 

1.  Pray at regular times every day.

 

2.  Read one chapter of the Gospels daily; eventually, learn the method of lectio divina.

 

3.  Read the [url=http://www.vatican.va/archive/compendium_ccc/documents/archive_2005_compendium-ccc_en.html]Compendium of the Catechism of the Catholic Church[/url].

 

4.  Go to Mass every Sunday.

 

5.  Read Christ, the Life of the Soul, a little at a time.

 

6.  Let the pastor of your local parish know that you are interested in becoming Catholic.  You might also find a priest who is willing to teach you privately.

 

7,  Make some good Catholic friends.

Edited by Clare Brigid
Posted
The one thing I miss about the LDS church that I haven’t found in the Catholic church is a sense of community. Parishes are really large and can feel kind of impersonal. In the LDS church you were assigned a ward, so you went to church at the same place and the same time every week and you saw the same people every week. Wards tend to be very close and the members watch out for each other, if someone in the ward has something happen and needs help, you can bet just about all the members of the ward will hear about it before the day is out and you will have more help than you know what to do with.

 

Thank you for sharing your experience.  I find all this really fascinating.

 

I get what you are saying about community.  I grew up in small eastern rite parishes where everyone went to the same mass on Sunday, each person knew everybody else, and kids grew up and played together.  One of those parishes is still going strong, but one is dying off (eg. no more russian immigrant community.)

 

I'm not sure how the roman rite used to be.  I imagine it used to be different and there was more community when everyone's kids went to the same local parochial school.  I still think you can find some level of community, but you have to work for it - it's not automatic, that's for sure.  It's not always at the parish level either.  A lot of times a youth, young professionals, or young couples group will be at the diocesan level.

 

I hope you and arfink can find some nice groups to be a part of!

Posted

Welcome EILISH, I only hope the Catholic nation does not discourage you from Catholicism, we are living in interesting times, to say the least.

 

I'd recommend Frank Sheed's Theology and Sanity, Newadvent.com has excellent resources on the writings of the Church Fathers. This Tremendous Lover by Fr Boylan is a modern spiritual masterpiece that I highly recommend.

Posted

The one thing I miss about the LDS church that I haven’t found in the Catholic church is a sense of community.

 

I found this missing as well, especially in most Novus Ordo parishes. My background as some of you know was as a Muslim, and the sense of brotherhood among the Muslims is very strong. Even between complete strangers there is a sense of filiality. What happened to our Christian charity and sense of brotherhood? Our Lord said we will know each other by our love.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...