Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Semper Catholic
Posted

I missed the most important part. So we can assume the sex is consensual even though the pair where drunk and the women has reported it as rape because she doesn't remember going home with the dude. So it could have been rape but why is she at his home, i assume she is at his home or dorm or her dorm or someone elses dorm. Although not very modest more than likely not rape, just a stupid mistake which we can boil down to the consumption of alcoholic beverages or excess consumption of such beverages.

Jesus is LORD


Nice you pulled off the s.lut shaming and victim blaming combo. Impressive
Posted

Just to clarify, without going into lengthy debates, and without diminishing the seriousness of rape, my point is sometimes the victim is an innocent guy that is falsely accused. Incidentally, most victims of rape are men in a prison setting.

Semper Catholic
Posted

Just to clarify, without going into lengthy debates, and without diminishing the seriousness of rape, my point is sometimes the victim is an innocent guy that is falsely accused. Incidentally, most victims of rape are men in a prison setting.


The last sentence is incorrect.

These topics are brought up like falsely accused rapists are an everyday occurrence. I've never seen a topic made about all the rapes that go unreported, which is a much more statistically significant number.
TheLordsSouljah
Posted (edited)

This makes me so mad I could spit. 

 

The idea that there all are these women out there trying to ruin the lives of men with false cries of rape is a disgusting myth perpetrated by people who have bought into the delusion that women are the sole arbiters of whether or not sex is happening and that men are nothing more that lust-crazed animals. 

 

Women who are actually raped and have the courage to bring their case to trial are almost always painted as conniving silly sallies who are just experiencing morning-after remorse.  The fact is that a raped woman is treated this way by the courts means that a false cry of rape is incredibly likely to fall through anyway. So what's the point of bringing this up at all? All it does is reinforce the idea that real rape victims will not be listened to. 

 

It's a pointless article that perpetuates ideas that do far more harm than good. 

Totally agree with you gal....  I know far too many women who have been through this horror and can tell you that only about five percent actually report it. And reporting it was hell for those that did, tests and photos and all kinds of other horrible memory jerking things. The rest all just curl up in a ball and don't say a word because they either think it was their fault or are simply too scared.

 

 

 

 

 

 

But here's my two cents for the article in general....

Men are defs not always the people with the problems though... I've actually had a video pop up once about a drunk girl who pretty much tried to rape a drunk guy... and she slapped and kicked the heck out of him for refusing. I must say I really. really. hate. it. when people keep going on about the 'uncontrollable sex drives' of men. This is NOT TRUE in all cases. 

And to be brutally honest, there are a few girls who DO JUST ASK FOR IT in some form or another. Okay, so I totally agree that men should certainly have control over themselves. That is indisputable. But seriously, would you leave a diamond necklace on a table without being locked away in at least a glass case without expecting someone to steal it? Yes, the stealing is bad and has to be punished. But why the heck would someone give them any greater a temptation? Why do prostitutes dress the way they do?? This reeeealy annoys me, and I'm a gal.

 

I do think the point of the article was aimed at girls to have 'consented' in one way or another to having sex to stop crying rape when it wasn't really rape. Okay, so there's a grey fuzzy line. Yet clearly there are some girls who really should know better and it is aimed at them. But seriously, are those girls gonna put themselves in that category, or read something like this anyway? I think it's a bit of a pointless article, expressing an opinion though it may, because it's gonna create that fuzzy line in all those girls' minds, minutely guilty themselves or not.

But that's just my two cents.

Edited by TheLordsSouljah
Posted

Basilae, my friend had consensual sex with a girl that later accused him of rape. It's a borrowing experience because you soon discover in the case of rape you're guilty until proven innocent. Fortunately this girl later admitted it was a false accusation, and she also blamed him for giving her herpes to which he tested negative for. The whole event deeply traumatized him. What disturbs me is that many statistics show a high rate of false accusations of rape (eg 70% in some studies) and the legal system is clearly overtly balanced to favor the woman's side. Now I understand this may have been intended to protect women and many feminists defend it, but what it's not doing is protecting the innocent. And believe me, when you're that innocent guy facing the possibility of jail time it's the biggest nightmare of your life.

 

Rape has the lowest reporting and the lowest conviction rate of any violent crime. According to the FBI's own statistics, the false reporting rate in the USA is about 6%. Also according to the FBI's statistics, only 10% rapes result in an arrest and 4% in a conviction. The Department of Justice confirms that of all rapists, only 3% will ever serve any time in prison at all.

 

If the legal system were "clearly overtly biased to favour the woman's side", these figures would look a lot better than they do. One in five women will be sexually assaulted at some point in her adult lifetime, which is a horrific figure - but the vast majority of those women are never going to do or say anything about it, partly because the knee-jerk reaction is, "My friend got falsely accused. It was so traumatising for him. What about the men??? We have to protect the innocent!" Statistically it is extremely unlikely for a man to be falsely accused of rape...but far more likely for a woman to actually be raped. Yet the myth of false accusations still gets centre stage in the discussion.

 

SemperCatholic is right - everyone on this board will know someone who has been raped or assaulted, or will have been raped or assaulted themselves, and here we have people talking as though it's a get-out-of-jail-free-card that those drunk women use to excuse 'bad choices' and traumatise poor men, as though it's a rare thing. This is why reporting rape is such a very hard thing for victims to find the courage to do - the blame, the shame, and the fact that and the fact that the treatment you get from police and the justice system during questioning is not guaranteed to be kind, let alone just, and is often a fresh ordeal for someone who is already badly frightened to go through.

Posted

That's the thing though they dont. Google rape culture and do some research. There's a reason these numbers are so high. Society encourages a certain mindset from males and in most circles this mindset is cultivated and grown.

everyone knows the scary back alley rape is wrong. The biggest issue is the no means no sexual assaults which are perpetrated by all American Johnnies in every American town

 

 

Pop psychology excrement used to deny the fact that people are predators. This is why predators succeed frequently: Because morons pretend it's ignorance.

 

I'm willing to entertain the notion that thoughtlessness is a cause of some evil actions.

 

"Rape culture" is another fuzzy term used to sell courses to the naive. When people realize they can't get away with a behavior, they pretend to have not understood that said behavior was unacceptable. And the idiots then declare that we educated the evil out of someone. It's possible that turning a mirror on a person and letting them see what they are ends the delusion, but that's merely the knowledge they already possessed overwhelming their capacity for self-deception.

 

I remember in school a couple of guys in class saying that the way some women dressed was "asking for it". I challenged them. After class, one of them asked why I was "fronting" him. After a few minutes of not backing down and mocking the stupid term "fronting" in addition to his excuses for his behavior, he backed down. Know why he was angry? Because he knew he was lying when he said what he said. He knew it was BS. He didn't believe a word of it, and being confronted with it challenged the crap he'd built up around him. He was a predator, he knew it, and he didn't like it being exposed. If there is a rape culture, it is not comparable to some veil of ignorance, but more so to a duck blind. It is camouflage. 

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

I'm not debating that rape doesn't happen, I'm not debating the seriousness of rape, I'm not debating that many rapes go un reported for whatever reasons. Aren't we debating the o.p which i read as to many women clogging up the system in universities claiming they where raped after a night out on the grog when it was actually consent although perhaps coerced in whatever manner, and how that doesn't constitute as rape and the people crying wolf before there is actually a wolf can shut down peoples eyes and ears as to a real cry of wolf when there is an actual wolf. Something like that anyhow. :)

 

Jesus iz LORD.

Edited by Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Semper Catholic
Posted

I'm not debating that rape doesn't happen, I'm not debating the seriousness of rape, I'm not debating that many rapes go un reported for whatever reasons. Aren't we debating the o.p which i read as to many women clogging up the system in universities claiming they where raped after a night out on the grog when it was actually consent although perhaps coerced in whatever manner, and how that doesn't constitute as rape and the people crying wolf before there is actually a wolf can shut down peoples eyes and ears as to a real cry of wolf when there is an actual wolf. Something like that anyhow. :)

Jesus iz LORD.


I was unaware of all the false rape cases clogging up university systems. Must be a big problem.

It's definitely not the other way around though. Cops always take rape cases extremely seriously, and the victims are always handled appropriately. Always.
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

I was unaware of all the false rape cases clogging up university systems. Must be a big problem.

It's definitely not the other way around though. Cops always take rape cases extremely seriously, and the victims are always handled appropriately. Always.

 

I said that also about the cops dealing with all alleged rape cases seriously. And if the police don't then that is sad and needs a big public protest.

Edited by Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

Fyi above article was written by a feminist, and she admits false accusations are common. Up to 25% accusations are false, and that's a conservative number, could be up to 40%. Now if your an innocent man accused of this crime you're pretty much screwed.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

I wonder if there has been an increase of this crime since the popularisation of pornography and sexual advertising and other sexualised media and if most cases are lets say offender and offended under the age of 26, in both the case of actual rape and falsified rape and as to whether the falsified rape is a pecking order pop underground thing to see how many people you can get into trouble that have done nothing wrong. Very sad anyway if that persons stat of 1 in 6 adult women in the states have encountered being raped at least once, or is that a world wide average and not a stat on the states. And stats kind of lie anyhow, a real stat of the states would need at lest one tenth of the population to take a census on the matter and the stats coming from all walks of life and states.

Edited by Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

 It would probably be a 100 million dollar project and that is why no one does it perhaps to get a real significant statistic. Though the smaller stat gatherings are ok there not really good though and can be misleading, that's my opinion anyway.

Posted

Now if your an innocent man accused of this crime you're pretty much screwed.


That also goes for an innocent man in a domestic violence case or a priest in a child abuse case. They all have to prove their innocence, and still would be considered guilty.
Posted

We've got a guy attacking women in a rich neighborhood here. A cop being interviewed on tv said that women shouldn't be walking down the alleys. Instead of being thanked for informing the public there is a nut loose attacking women walking alone in alleys, he was attacked for blaming the victims. He wasn't saying if you walk down dark alleys you deserve to be attacked, he was trying to tell women how to be safe.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

That also goes for an innocent man in a domestic violence case or a priest in a child abuse case. They all have to prove their innocence, and still would be considered guilty.

 

I think mort is serious also about the gravity of this matter and he is not saying lets let everyone off scot free for the sake of the innocent men who have been falsely accused. This is an exercise in public opinion about the recognition that not everyone is guilty of a crime they are accused of and possible recognition that there is such a thing as a minority report that gets bogged down with the majorities stampede.

Posted

Just for the record, if consent is in any way impaired, say by the consumption of alcohol, an individual is incapable of giving proper consent and therefore, technically, intercourse is rape.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Just for the record, if consent is in any way impaired, say by the consumption of alcohol, an individual is incapable of giving proper consent and therefore, technically, intercourse is rape.

 

Of course. It's different if both people are equally drunk (The girl being hammered and the guy being slightly tipsy is obviously way different than both of them being tipsy or hammered), but I don't think anyone would disagree the situation which you describe (An unfortunately all-too-common situation) is rape.

Posted

If you do not have consent, if she does not say yes 100%, it is rape. If she says yes and then in the middle says no, and you keep going, it is rape.

 

Why is that such a difficult concept?

 

If you take advantage of a drunk girl, it's rape

 

If at any time the girl says no, and he doesn't listen, IT. IS RAPE.

 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...