Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I've heard people say a few things, that they don't have souls and there are no animals in heaven <--- which I disagree.  That there is a place called Rainbow Ridge where it's animal heaven and you can visit them whenever (after you've left earth this of course).  That animals have simple souls <--- I tend to concur with this as they are similar (dogs as an example) in a lot of ways yet they have their own unique personality.

 

What are your thoughts and beliefs?

 

PhuturePriest
Posted

Simple theological answer: In Heaven, you have everything you need in order to be happy. If you are literally incapable of being perfectly happy without your boa constrictor you named Fluffy, then he will be in heaven.

Posted

I'd like to hear from a Thomist on this one for "intellectual accuracy", but regardless of the what the Summa says, I personally love our family cats and dogs and don't see why they wouldn't be in heaven.    

Not The Philosopher
Posted

As far as I can remember, the Thomist response is that animals do have souls, but mortal ones. Since the immortal part of the soul is the rational part, which animals lack.

 

 

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

In the new Heaven and new Earth there will be animals, or so the Holy Scriptures seem to tell us. Isaiah 11:6 for example... 

Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted

I'd like to hear from a Thomist on this one for "intellectual accuracy", but regardless of the what the Summa says, I personally love our family cats and dogs and don't see why they wouldn't be in heaven.    

 

I don't believe the Summa asserts one way or another whether animals will be in heaven, it merely makes the distinction between immortal and mortal souls, which as was pointed out already, refers more to rationality and free will than whether they survive past death. The translation into immortal and mortal is a little gimpy in that regard.

God the Father
Posted

Yes they do and everytime you eat one they shed a few silent tears and make a face like the dogs and cats in ASPCA commercials and think "why are you eatin my body"

Posted

^^^

God gave us cattle and other animals for a reason. Why aren't some lions vegetarians? Because God created prey for them to eat.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

The only thing we know for sure is that human souls are different from any soul an animal may or may not have. 

 

There is theological support for a new Heaven and new Earth after the final judgement. I had one professor once say that the natural "evils" in the world (disasters, disease, death, etc) are all a result of original sin. That sin has an effect that radiates into the natural world in some way, and that Christ's passion and death opens the door for salvation for us humans, but also for transformation of the natural world as well. It's just one opinion, but I think it's interesting. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

^^^

God gave us cattle and other animals for a reason. Why aren't some lions vegetarians? Because God created prey for them to eat.

 

God gave us cows to distract the main population from eating superior meat like chicken, thus granting the select few who know chicken is superior (Such as myself) more meat to consume.

Posted

Simple theological answer: In Heaven, you have everything you need in order to be happy. If you are literally incapable of being perfectly happy without your boa constrictor you named Fluffy, then he will be in heaven.

Would such an extreme attachment not perhaps imply some issues in need of purgation?
PhuturePriest
Posted

Would such an extreme attachment not perhaps imply some issues in need of purgation?

 

That's just a theological answer I was told to give kids when they ask about a dead pet being in heaven. Usually, they grow out of it and realize they don't require their pet to be happy, their pets simply assist them in being happy in this life. I would love to fulfill my life's ambition of snuggling with a lion and playing with lion cubs, but I know the overwhelming happiness and ecstasy of heaven is far greater than anything we can experience on earth, and thus I know I won't need cuddly lions in heaven.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

God gave us cows to distract the main population from eating superior meat like chicken, thus granting the select few who know chicken is superior (Such as myself) more meat to consume.

 

You've never had slow-roasted prime rib from a steer that was raised by one of your local 4H kids, have you? That stuff is perfection. 

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

The old NAB bible i used to have with a church theology section in the back said something like this ' that animals have a soul but it is not an intellectual soul ' whatever that means, so the NAB says that the church says animals have a soul, so the answer is 'YES' animals do have a soul just not an intellectual soul whatever that means.

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted

I spent hundreds of hours working with apes--gorillas, chimpanzees, and organutans, as well as with lesser (basically smaller) apes such as gibbons. I'd like see a well-thought out. well researched paper by someone who BOTH had worked closely with apes and also REALLY knew their theology argue that these animals do not have intellecutual souls. Just because humans are too stupid to understand everything these animals are able to communicate and feel, doesn't mean the animals don't have intellectual souls.

 

I expect to see beloved animals in heaven. And, if by chance they are not there, since heaven promises happiness and understanding, I assume I will understand why and be satisfied with that.

Posted

If it has a concept of its mortality, yet acts in a manner to benefit or damage creation in a lasting manner, it seems a matter of divine justice for there to be an afterlife.

Posted

This is an argument I heard before, I don't really know how accurate this is, but it was something along the lines of: The Bible says: And God said, "Let the waters bring forth swarms of living creatures, and let birds fly above the earth across the dome of the sky." SoGod created the great sea monsters and every living creature that moves, of every kind, with which the waters swarm, and every winged bird of every kind. And God saw that it was good. God blessed them, saying, "Be fruitful ad multiply and and fill the waters in the seas, and let birds multiply on earth. " (Genesis 1:20-22) This argument basically states that one definition of the word "blessed" is something along the lines of "to breathe divine spirit upon". So basically, the person arguing this stated that if you replace the part of that passage that says "God blessed them," with "God breathed His divine spirit upon them", you have the answer to the question "Do animals have souls?" (Note: This isn't necessarily my belief, this is just an argument that I heard. I just posted it because it seemed relevant. Again, I don't know how accurate this really is.)

Posted

OH and that Scriptural passage came from the NSRV (New Revised Standard Version: Catholic Edition) translation/version of the Bible.

Posted

As far as I can remember, the Thomist response is that animals do have souls, but mortal ones. Since the immortal part of the soul is the rational part, which animals lack.

 

Exactly! Animals and plants have a soul. A principle of life that animates them. However they do not have rational powers of the soul. 

 

Catechism of the Summa Theologica: http://archive.org/stream/catechismsumma00peguuoft#page/22/mode/2up

Powers of the soul: http://www.lifeissues.net/writers/mcm/ph/ph_01philosophyyouth13.html

Posted

Simple theological answer: In Heaven, you have everything you need in order to be happy. If you are literally incapable of being perfectly happy without your boa constrictor you named Fluffy, then he will be in heaven.

 

But of course only God is necessary for our happiness.  Affection for one's boa constrictor named Fluffy is merely a natural and earthly attachment.  The supernatural happiness of heaven will abolish such concupiscence.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...