Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Turn Your Loved Ones Into Diamonds!


Recommended Posts

Posted

Question: Does the Roman Catholic church allow organ donation?


Yes so long as it is done for the right reasons, and in the case of heart, it is done with complete confidence that the donor is really dead.
Posted

I think I've reached a problematic point when I read your post and the first thing that comes to mind is "Quidditch Through the Ages".

I have that book lying around somewhere. :hehe:

Mary+Immaculate<3
Posted (edited)

They say diamonds are a girl's best friend. That surely doesn't mean I want a diamond to be my best friend though. :cry:  That's sad to even think about for me to even think about! What would I do without my best friends?!

Edited by Mary+Immaculate<3
Posted

I would like them to cremate me and then send my remains into space :alien:

Posted

The idea of cutting and shaping the diamond makes me think no it would not be okay. The remains of the diamond that are cut off would be disposed of I'm guessing, which in my mind would be the equivalent of throwing half of your cremated remains in a garbage can.

 

Also, if your remains were made into a diamond it would still have to be buried, or placed in a columbarium, or another permanent resting place rather than adorned as a piece of jewelry.

Posted

The idea of cutting and shaping the diamond makes me think no it would not be okay. The remains of the diamond that are cut off would be disposed of I'm guessing, which in my mind would be the equivalent of throwing half of your cremated remains in a garbage can.

 

Also, if your remains were made into a diamond it would still have to be buried, or placed in a columbarium, or another permanent resting place rather than adorned as a piece of jewelry.

That is a good point. When you think about it, turning a body into a diamond sounds rather suspiciously like a pervasive objectification of the person's remains. Same goes for all those different 'weird' things people want to do with cremated remains.

Posted

That is a good point. When you think about it, turning a body into a diamond sounds rather suspiciously like a pervasive objectification of the person's remains. Same goes for all those different 'weird' things people want to do with cremated remains.

I think hypothetically it would be permissible if the remains were simply made into a diamond for the sake of conserving space for example. I doubt humanity could ever get to the point that we're so low on space for burial that we have to resort shrinking cremated remains into something even smaller. Your entire extended family could fit into a single urn if they were all made into diamonds!

Posted

I think hypothetically it would be permissible if the remains were simply made into a diamond for the sake of conserving space for example. I doubt humanity could ever get to the point that we're so low on space for burial that we have to resort shrinking cremated remains into something even smaller. Your entire extended family could fit into a single urn if they were all made into diamonds!

Hypothetically, yes. I agree. I will even admit that the mental image this creates is oddly appealing to me. :hehe:

But I will continue to believe that traditional burial is more of one mind with the Church. :P

Posted (edited)

I just had my sisters read this article and they want to be made into diamonds. They love sparkles!!!

:princess:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited for spelling

Edited by cartermia
Not The Philosopher
Posted

Rarity_sees_the_three_small_diamonds_S2E

Ash Wednesday
Posted

One benefit (if I could call it that...) :| of respectful burial and giving someone a final resting place is that I think helps give the grieving some closure. I always felt that having someone with you as a diamond or in a urn in your house, prevents the grieving from truly letting them go. People may find it comforting to think that they are "with them" but it contradicts the idea that earth really isn't our final place of rest and we should be praying for souls entering heaven.

 

My mother had a viewing and mass in a simple casket but was cremated afterwards. Honestly I don't remember a lot because I didn't know my butt from my elbow at the time because of the shock, but I did know she wanted cremation for her final burial, but the priest recommended having the body present for the wake and funeral itself. Knowing my mom she would have followed the priest's suggestion but it also respected her last wishes.

 

Always an interesting discussion....putting the FUN in FUNeral... hey hey hey.

 

Posted

In the Victorian era, people took dead people's hair and wove them into jewelry.

Posted (edited)

I can't imagine wanting to do this! It just strikes me as so odd!

 

I mean, you would esentially be turning your loved one into a piece of bling.  I just think of cases like when people lose an engagement ring or wedding ring, which can be devastating enough. Can you imagine wearing your friend/relative on a chain or ring and it breaks or you otherwise lose it? There would be absolutely no reminder of that person at all, and you'd have to live with having lost a person's remains down the shower drain or somewhere equally awful. Or being robbed or having the diamond found by someone else after losing it and your loved one ending  up in a pawn shop or on ebay.  Awful and creepy.

Edited by YHZRosko

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...