ChristinaTherese Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 So, I'm not sure what I'm supposed to do when I see others in the Catholic Cadre on campus here eating just before Mass, and probably intending to receive the Eucharist. I mean, they were presumably taught that they're supposed to fast for an hour before Mass, but they don't seem to care. Or at least not all of them do. Should I say something? I doubt it would do much to change anything, and I don't really want to go being obnoxious/judgmental, but ought I to say something just in case? And if so, what would I even say? These people were raised Catholic but at least the one who made me think of this today is more nominal. She knows she's supposed to go to Mass every Sunday too, I'm sure, but doesn't. What would you guys do in my shoes? (What I did was just sit there and think maybe I should say something but I didn't know what so I just stayed quiet.) (And an aside about the cadre: We're going to have next to nobody in the fall, because we have quite a few seniors graduating, and the two of us who will be a junior and a senior want to study abroad. There might be sophomores and freshmen... I sure hope there are. But we'll come back from Europe to a different group. Oh, and the grad student and prof will be around when they can. And we have a few profs who show up for Mass. But anyway, that's not what I'm asking about.)
NotreDame Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 They totally did this at one school I went to... I mentioned it to one person... "hey, how do you fit in lunch with a mass at noon and still maintain the fast?" They said "I try to eat quickly before, I think God understands." I tried not to look shocked and just moved on. I sympathize with the priests that have to deal with this.... Glad I'm just a layperson when dealing with this subject.
blazeingstar Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 (edited) My fiancee says it's an hour before receiving the Eucharist, so he often has a snack a half hour before Mass. He is a grazer, if he's doing anything besides programing without eating he gets cranky, so I haven't bothered to break out cannon law to correct him. Given that I'm diagnosed hypoglycemic, I usually eat an hour before, as that was the way I was raised. We both wait a half hour after, which I don't know why we both do, but we do. Edited February 13, 2014 by blazeingstar
ChristinaTherese Posted February 13, 2014 Author Posted February 13, 2014 (edited) Well, I was told by an FSSP priest that it is an hour before receiving the Eucharist, so I think your fiancee is right about that. ETA: Um, you mentioned canon law. What does it say exactly? (I could probably find it easily enough though if you don't want to hunt it up.) Edited February 13, 2014 by Christina Thérèse
CatholicCid Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 Relevant Canon from the Code: Can. 919 §1 Whoever is to receive the blessed Eucharist is to abstain for at least one hour before holy communion from all food and drink, with the sole exception of water and medicine. §2 A priest who, on the same day, celebrates the blessed Eucharist twice or three times may consume something before the second or third celebration, even though there is not an hour's interval. §3 The elderly and those who are suffering from some illness, as well as those who care for them, may receive the blessed Eucharist even if within the preceding hour they have consumed something.
Basilisa Marie Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 Unless you're good friends with them, I wouldn't say anything to them. They may not know, and if they don't, then it's certainly forgiven at the penitential rite. I might talk to your priest about this, let him know that you notice that it seems like a lot students don't know about the hour fast, or don't abide by it. Then let him do something about it if he feels it necessary.
blazeingstar Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 So it is an hour before communion NOT before Mass. Unless you're speaking of Daily Mass or hitting up a buffet in the vestibule, you're probably AoK as Mass is an hour long and communion is not until it's nearly done.
cartermia Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 I always say 30 minutes before mass starts because that is just about the right time with my priest homilies for it to be an hour.
PhuturePriest Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 So, I'm not sure what I'm supposed to do when I see others in the Catholic Cadre on campus here eating just before Mass, and probably intending to receive the Eucharist. I mean, they were presumably taught that they're supposed to fast for an hour before Mass, but they don't seem to care. Or at least not all of them do. Should I say something? I doubt it would do much to change anything, and I don't really want to go being obnoxious/judgmental, but ought I to say something just in case? And if so, what would I even say? These people were raised Catholic but at least the one who made me think of this today is more nominal. She knows she's supposed to go to Mass every Sunday too, I'm sure, but doesn't. What would you guys do in my shoes? (What I did was just sit there and think maybe I should say something but I didn't know what so I just stayed quiet.) (And an aside about the cadre: We're going to have next to nobody in the fall, because we have quite a few seniors graduating, and the two of us who will be a junior and a senior want to study abroad. There might be sophomores and freshmen... I sure hope there are. But we'll come back from Europe to a different group. Oh, and the grad student and prof will be around when they can. And we have a few profs who show up for Mass. But anyway, that's not what I'm asking about.) This is a common misconception. There isn't an hour fast before the Mass, there's an hour fast before receiving the Eucharist. You could technically finish eating twenty minutes before Mass and still not break the Fast.
Nihil Obstat Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 This is a common misconception. There isn't an hour fast before the Mass, there's an hour fast before receiving the Eucharist. You could technically finish eating twenty minutes before Mass and still not break the Fast. Which is kind of sad, if you ask me...
Eliakim Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 And what happens if one says, "Thanks for pointing that canon law out, but I'll keep grazing, thaaanks..." Answer: Mortal sin. That's the magisterium for you.
CatholicCid Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 And what happens if one says, "Thanks for pointing that canon law out, but I'll keep grazing, thaaanks..." Answer: Mortal sin. That's the magisterium for you. Actually, that's man for you. The Canon exists for a simple reason, is based in both Scripture and Tradition, and, really, is the laxest it has ever been so as to encourage frequent reception of the Holy Eucharist. To ignore it would seem to state that one doesn't actually understand the Canon or simply does not care.
blazeingstar Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 Which is kind of sad, if you ask me... Sad that it's not more than an hour?
Nihil Obstat Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 Sad that it's not more than an hour? I think the previous three hours would be preferable. What kind of fast is it if you can complete it by accident?
Eliakim Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 Actually, that's man for you. The Canon exists for a simple reason, is based in both Scripture and Tradition, and, really, is the laxest it has ever been so as to encourage frequent reception of the Holy Eucharist. To ignore it would seem to state that one doesn't actually understand the Canon or simply does not care. Does that bother any other intellectually curious person on this Phat site that continuing to willfully graze is a mortal sin which unless confessed sends one to hell for all eternity?
blazeingstar Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 I think the previous three hours would be preferable. What kind of fast is it if you can complete it by accident? That's your opinion though, not church Law. It is just as cafeteria of you to imply that others should choose to fast for longer, or that not being mindful of the fast somehow is inadequate in the eyes of the Church and God.
Nihil Obstat Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 That's your opinion though, not church Law. It is just as cafeteria of you to imply that others should choose to fast for longer, or that not being mindful of the fast somehow is inadequate in the eyes of the Church and God. @@
CatholicCid Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 (edited) Does that bother any other intellectually curious person on this Phat site that continuing to willfully graze is a mortal sin which unless confessed sends one to hell for all eternity? I would be more concerned with the willful obstinance and refusal of such a person to accept such a simple and straightforward request of the Church, let alone the person's complete unrepetance for doing so. After all, all mortal sin, if willingly unconfessed, could lead to ruin (Mark 3:28-29). That being said, we'd first have to look at the characteristics that make up a mortal sin and determine if violating this Canon is a mortal sin. First, is this a grave matter? Secondly, is the person committing the act with full knowledge? And, finally, are they doing so freely? Using hypotheticals regarding grazing, we could go back and forth. Why is the person grazing? Are they merely hungry? Do they deny the real presence and, therefore, see no need to fast? As you can imagine, there would be many questions to ask. All of this would, of course, be a question for the moral theologians and/or Canon Lawyers. Edited February 14, 2014 by CatholicCid
Deus te Amat Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 When I went to WYD, I saw people eating during Mass. Stuff happens.
CatholicCid Posted February 14, 2014 Posted February 14, 2014 When I went to WYD, I saw people eating during Mass. Stuff happens. To be fair, during WYD, one could eat at the very beginning of Mass and still keep a several hour fast :spike: And, as you said, stuff happens. I honestly would guess that most people simply haven't heard of the need to fast before Mass or that they have simply misunderstood it.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now