Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Basic Science Test... Oh Brother!


Recommended Posts

Posted

Well... I have NO idea why this ended up in the YAHOO FINANCE SECTION (?!) but I thought it was an interesting commentary on what people do and do not know.

 

The percentages of what people got right and wrong are really frightening.

 

I was a lit major... and I got a 100% right.  How did the rest of you do????

 

 

http://finance.yahoo.com/news/heres-basic-science-1-4-180551784.html

Posted

I got 100% although I can see why there is only 39% agreement on the question about the Big Bang, as it's not entirely clear or universally agreed upon even among scientists that the universe did start this way. And no, I'm not talking about creationism, I mean that there are credible scientists who don't think it started with a Big Bang, and so I'm not terribly surprised that there is divergence there. 

Posted

I can't hear or read "Big Bang Theory" without thinking of the comical sitcom.

Posted

Agreed on both points -- Big Bang is a disputable question -- and I remember the Astronomy teacher saying it might also be 'Big Crunch' ... perhaps a 2nd sitcom in the making?  ;)

Posted

Ha!! I am a literature and a theology major and I got 100% although I do not entirely believe in Darwin's version of evolution.  I knew what the "correct" answer to that question was, however.  Where's the intermediate fossil record and etc.  Please do not start a debate!!

 

I have also read a very interesting book written by a man who is a MIT astrophysics professor and an orthodox Jew.  He talks about the beginning of the universe and relates it to quantum theory (all you science people PLEASE do not laugh at me).  One thing that I took away was that if the universe was indeed created by a big bang, then time may have functioned in a very different way at the beginning than it does now.  

Posted

8/9 (approx. 89%) And jeez, I thought the Science teacher was kidding when he said that people still thought the solar system was geocentric...

Posted

9/9 . Though I will admit I am not a "normal" person in that my dad was a high school science teacher and I majored in Aerospace Physics.

ChristinaTherese
Posted

100%, although I'm just about as "normal" as TT, since my dad and brother are electrical engineers, my mom started out in med school and homeschooled my brother and me, I started as a biochem major and then switched to linguistics, and I've been learning a lot about the history of western civilization (art, a bit of music, philosophy, science, literature (not as much, mostly just text that fit into the previous categories)) through the honors program at me school.

 

But yeah... I thought everyone knew that the solar system (not the universe) is heliocentric. (And I have to wonder, if we revolve around the sun and the sun revolves around the center of the Milky Way, does the Milky Way revolve around anything?)

Posted

The Milky Way clearly revolves around Mars (candy company)!

brandelynmarie
Posted (edited)

So maybe there is a Big Crunch Bar involved as well! :p


Oh & I got 10/10....the question about radiation made me laugh...since I do work with man made radiation :hehe:

Edited by brandelynmarie
Archaeology cat
Posted

100% here

Posted

I might not have known the one about lasers till ARFink (because might have confused it with SONAR)

Posted

I might not have known the one about lasers till ARFink (because might have confused it with SONAR)

PhuturePriest
Posted

I had to guess a few of them, but it didn't really take extensive reasoning skills to figure out if lasers worked by focusing sound waves... :P

Posted

100% 

 

Psychology major who left school at age 15.

 

Yep. I am old enough for that to still have been legal in the UK.

 

I'll have the Big Crunch Bar please.

 

 

 

 

 

Posted (edited)

Not if I get it FIRST you wont, Max.  Charity begins at home.  MY home.  I'm hungry.

 

crunchbar.jpg?w=300&h=225

 

If you are VERy nice, I may share some of Mr. AL and my Brigettine Monks fudge with nuts with you.

 

 fudj11.jpg

 

But the Big Crunch?  

 

uh uh. NOOOO way!

Edited by AnneLine
Posted (edited)

When you give it up for Lent I can have it. :woot:  :hehe:  :notworthy:  :evil:

 

 

Or I will swap for a hot spicy roll.

Edited by maximillion
PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

8/9 (approx. 89%) And jeez, I thought the Science teacher was kidding when he said that people still thought the solar system was geocentric...

 

http://galileowaswrong.com
 

On the right side are several animations showing how everything explained by a heliocentric model is still valid in a geocentric model. Each model has strengths and weaknesses, I know a guy who creates models for tracking space junk entries...ect. In fact the specific stuff he does really only has a couple of people who understand it. He even uses a geocentric model sometimes because it can create easier calculations, other times a heliocentric model is better. Bottom line, motion is relative.

ChristinaTherese
Posted (edited)

Oh yeah. Tycho Brahe just made the model with the Earth staying still, the sun revolving around the earth, and all of the other planets revolving around the sun. It would work well enough for a lot of calculations. Ptolemy had a whole set of epicycles that the planets rotate on. (Look it up if you're curious, I spent long enough writing about this stuff in a paper I turned in this morning.) These models work well enough for calculations if you want to just observe the stars or whatever. The thing is that Newton (he explains a lot), Galileo (he got some neat visual evidence), and Kepler (he worked out that the planetary orbits are really elliptical) made a model with much more elegant mathematics and logic behind it. But the older models still work for most purposes.

 

Fun fact: The earth wobbles on its orbit because the point that traces an ellipse around the sun is the center of gravity between the earth and the moon, not the center of the earth.

 

ETA: I was writing a 4-page paper on heliocentrism last night that was due today for a midterm....

Edited by Christina Thérèse
Posted

http://galileowaswrong.com

On the right side are several animations showing how everything explained by a heliocentric model is still valid in a geocentric model. Each model has strengths and weaknesses, I know a guy who creates models for tracking space junk entries...ect. In fact the specific stuff he does really only has a couple of people who understand it. He even uses a geocentric model sometimes because it can create easier calculations, other times a heliocentric model is better. Bottom line, motion is relative.


That is a very good point... I wonder why they never talk about that in Science...? Maybe they talk about it in high school. Thank you for pointing that out!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...