Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

10 Commandments And Christ


Recommended Posts

Basilisa Marie
Posted

So a friend of my posted this on Facebook: 

 

 

 

If murder is a sin and violates the 10 commandments, then why was the murdering of Jesus the ticket to salvation? Two wrongs don't make a right.

 

I can't seem figure out the right kind of response. What would you say? 

HisChildForever
Posted

Looks like one of those "gotcha" statuses. 

 

Alright, so...

1. Validate his opinion. Like "Christian theology can seem tricky at times. :)"

2. When explaining yours, always keep it on the "I."

3. Keep it short and sweet--no more than 3 sentences. If your friend decides to engage then you can bulk up your responses.

4. End on a nice note, like a smiley face, to show this person that there's no animosity here and you're not looking for some huge debate.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

It demonstrates God's sovereignty, power and mercy by showing how He can draw some good from even the worst choices we make.

blazeingstar
Posted

I feel like this falls under one of those "why does God allow sin" sort of discussions.  God knew He would die, but He allowed it to happen for the sake of something better.

Posted

It has to do with sacrifice.

 

1. Abraham sacrificed pigeons and sheep and stuff in his original compact with God.

2. God asked Abraham to sacrifice Isaac - but stopped him. It's a prefiguring of God sacrificing Jesus.

3. Mosaic law established various kinds of sacrifices for various kinds of thanks, forgiveness, and so forth.

 

4. God let us kill Him - He let us commit the ultimate sin against him - and then showed us that He can take that, too, and still forgive us.

 

5. It is a mystery.

Posted

Jesus was baptised even when he didn't need to be. Through his immersion in the Jordan he showed that he had come to participate fully in our human life, with everything that entails. Humans hurt one another and humans suffer death. He didn't shy away from that part of our experience. He took it on himself so that everyone who ever finds themselves harmed or broken will be able to know that God has touched it, and God's love is with them even there in the most immediate personal way. This is the gift of salvation, which shouldn't simply be understood as a 'ticket to heaven' but as a way to be close with God - not just in heaven, but starting here and now.

Posted

Oh, the other thing I forgot -

 

All of our sins were laid on Jesus during his crucifixion. So our sins were "killed" when Jesus was killed. That's the way the old sacrifices worked, too.

 

But then Jesus proved He was God and that God fully controls life and death, creation and destruction, etc.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Thanks all - this gives me a bunch of ideas to work with. :) 

Posted

"If murder is a sin and violates the 10 commandments, then why was the murdering of Jesus the ticket to salvation? Two wrongs don't make a right."

 

To be clear, murdering Jesus wasn't a ticket to salvation for anyone responsible for the murdering.  I'm also not sure where there are two wrongs in murdering Jesus.  I only see one wrong.  Careful to affirm such a flawed statement by debating it.

Posted

So a friend of my posted this on Facebook: 

 

 

I can't seem figure out the right kind of response. What would you say? 

 

Because God the Son decided to take on human flesh and die so that humans would live again. Through his death, we live. He wasn't murdered. He voluntarily became man and took on mortality so that human beings would be immortal. His death was a choice.

 

Or, to put it bluntly: "God became man so that man might become God" - St. Athanisius of Alexandria

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...