maximillion Posted March 13, 2014 Posted March 13, 2014 I eat bunnies, lots of them. Caught and painlessly dispatched by my foster son. This is mostly organic meat, it's free apart from the time it takes to catch and deal with, and it rids the local farmers of a menace. So far not one land owner has refused my foster son permission to hunt on his land. We also take birds when we can, mainly pigeon. You don't get much meat off a pigeon but six of them can make a very good meal. I haven't eaten beef in 35 years. I rarely eat pork. I do eat fish, mainly farmed or line caught if I can get it ( we fish too) as well as shellfish. I am fortunate to live in Devon UK, very rural, but right next to the sea too. We also forage. When I say we I mainly mean my foster son these days as I am disabled, but we pick greens, samphire, herbs, wild fruits etc in season. I am trying to tread lightly on this earth and to not screw up the eco-system. I won't shop in supermarkets unless it's a dire emergency, and I have a windowsill and a tiny patio garden for salad and veggies. I wish to could keep hens....... God gave us the stewardship of the earth and all that is here, and how we 'use' it - including how we raise animals for the table will be on our account sheet. Is it better for an animal to live for the food industry rather than never to have existed. Well, realms of philosophy here. Not all animals have self awareness like a dog or a cat does. Is a beef animal self aware? From my close observation of it I would say no, so, apart from considerations of cruelty in how the animal is raised/dispatched at the end, I doubt it give a hoot about it's personal existance....... What I also know is that the average human needs only 25/50 grams of animal protein a day to remain healthy ( more veg protein than this is needed ). This means that most of us in the developed world are grossly over producing and over eating animal products. It's greed.
Pliny Posted March 13, 2014 Author Posted March 13, 2014 How do I reconcile this ^^^ with this:"And the Son of man indeed goeth, as it is written of him: but woe to that man by whom the Son of man shall be betrayed. It were better for him, if that man had not been born." Hyperbole. Or--note that he said "born" and not "conceived."
KnightofChrist Posted March 13, 2014 Posted March 13, 2014 Like coldness is merely the absence of heat, evil is the absence of good. God is Good, and Goodness exist or even is existence itself, evil is the lack of that existence. God loves all in creation as He created them, for "God looked at everything He had made, and He found it very good†- Genesis 1:31.Because God loves all that He created He will not allow it to be destroyed, as energy cannot be destroyed, “[f]or you (God) love all things that are and loathe nothing that you have made; for you would not fashion what you hate. How could a thing remain, unless you willed it; or be preserved, had it not been called forth by you? But you spare all things, because they are yours, O Ruler and Lover of souls†- Wisdom 11:24-26.So yes in a very real sense non-existence is pure evil, and if God who loves all the things, as He created them, willed someone to nonexistance, rather than out of love saving them in heaven or in hell, God would uncreate a good of His creation and that would be pure evil.
NotreDame Posted March 13, 2014 Posted March 13, 2014 She's a grad student. She's in hell. Being in grad school is pretty fun... It's the grad students themselves that are hell: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FXvv5sTqNa4
CrossCuT Posted March 13, 2014 Posted March 13, 2014 Like coldness is merely the absence of heat, evil is the absence of good. God is Good, and Goodness exist or even is existence itself, evil is the lack of that existence. God loves all in creation as He created them, for "God looked at everything He had made, and He found it very good†- Genesis 1:31. Because God loves all that He created He will not allow it to be destroyed, as energy cannot be destroyed, “[f]or you (God) love all things that are and loathe nothing that you have made; for you would not fashion what you hate. How could a thing remain, unless you willed it; or be preserved, had it not been called forth by you? But you spare all things, because they are yours, O Ruler and Lover of souls†- Wisdom 11:24-26. So yes in a very real sense non-existence is pure evil, and if God who loves all the things, as He created them, willed someone to nonexistance, rather than out of love saving them in heaven or in hell, God would uncreate a good of His creation and that would be pure evil. What a poet!
HisChildForever Posted March 13, 2014 Posted March 13, 2014 Hyperbole. Or--note that he said "born" and not "conceived." So it would have been better for Judas to have died in the womb?
NotreDame Posted March 14, 2014 Posted March 14, 2014 existence is good, non-existence is evil. even existence in hell is better than non-existence. wrap your head around that. How do I reconcile this ^^^ with this: "And the Son of man indeed goeth, as it is written of him: but woe to that man by whom the Son of man shall be betrayed. It were better for him, if that man had not been born." Still waiting for a satisfactory answer.
KnightofChrist Posted March 14, 2014 Posted March 14, 2014 (edited) He was using hyperbole, Christ is saying it is really really bad to betray the Son of man. Like if He was saying it was raining cats and dogs outside He would actually mean it's raining really hard. Or like the hyperbolic statement He made when He said a person should cut of his hand if it makes him sin, He did not mean one should actually cut off his hand but rather to go and sin no more. God willed to make Judas, just as He willed to create all of man, and He willed to give us all eternal life, and He found this very good. Because of that God will not allow the good that He has created to be destroyed. Allowing any being of His creation to cease to exist would be saying He made a mistake in creating that being who was created with an immortal soul. Hell is salvation from nonexistence, nonexistence is evil because it lacks any good. Hell is better than nonexistance because existence is better by its very nature of existing and being created by God. "The Church knows three apokatastaseis. One is the [apokatastasis] of everything according to the principle (logos) of virtue; in this apokatastasis one is restored who fulfills the principle of virtue in himself. The second is that of the whole [human nature] in the Resurrection. This is the apokatastasis to incorruption and immortality. The third, in the oft-cited words of Gregory of Nyssa, is the apokatastasis of the powers of the soul which, having lapsed into sin, are again restored to that condition in which they were created. For it is necessary that just as the entire nature of the flesh hopes in time to be taken up again into incorruption in the apokatastasis, so also the powers of the soul, having become distorted during the course of the ages had instilled in it a memory of evil, so that at the end of ages, not finding any rest, will come to God Who has no limit. And thus the distorted powers of the soul will be taken up into the primeval apokatastasis, into a merely discursive knowledge of, but not into the participation in, the good things [of God], where the Creator is known yet without being the cause of [their] sin." - St. Maximos the Confessor, Quaestiones ad Thalassium (PG 90:796BC) Edited March 14, 2014 by KnightofChrist
ithinkjesusiscool Posted March 14, 2014 Posted March 14, 2014 The problem with modern vegerarianism, as I see it, is about anthropology. Many vegetarians don't even have a reasonable and good anthropology. They can't see the difference between an animal and a human. That being said, eating vegetarian food is ok (I do it myself) but delving into vegetarianism is just anti-Catholic. But question still is (and I ask you Catholics who know your Theology): why is it ok to kill an animal but not a human?
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye Posted March 14, 2014 Posted March 14, 2014 The problem with modern vegerarianism, as I see it, is about anthropology. Many vegetarians don't even have a reasonable and good anthropology. They can't see the difference between an animal and a human. That being said, eating vegetarian food is ok (I do it myself) but delving into vegetarianism is just anti-Catholic. But question still is (and I ask you Catholics who know your Theology): why is it ok to kill an animal but not a human? I doubt it is anti Catholic Christian to be a vegetarian, but to be a Catholic Christian vegetarian that says something like everyone should be vegetarian and that meat eaters are evil and will burn in hell is perhaps anti Catholic Christian. P.s. by the way i just realised and have to ask why does the spell check only capitalise Christian and not CATHOLIC ? Is this a solely U.S thing? I wonder if the U.K English spell check does catholic with a capital C?
KnightofChrist Posted March 14, 2014 Posted March 14, 2014 Still waiting for a satisfactory answer. I hope you find my last response more of an satisfactory answer than the last.
NotreDame Posted March 14, 2014 Posted March 14, 2014 I hope you find my last response more of an satisfactory answer than the last. I am slowly being persuaded... I now entertain it as a possibility, but only as a possibility. I had no idea what that dude from the 900's was talking about (though it sounded cool.) If I did understand him maybe I'd be convinced.
southern california guy Posted March 14, 2014 Posted March 14, 2014 if mere existence was the highest good, then we'd drop everything and set up a system of constant sex. Where can I sign up!!?
PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted March 16, 2014 Posted March 16, 2014 Why should I have respect for animals? They're machines. God made them for us to use and abuse and do with what I wish. They don't matter. If you cannot tell I am being sarcastic, then I have done my job. Also, NSA, I am officially out of pocky. Get on that, mmmkay? Pocky is amesome. Especially the strawberry flavors. Gosh I would give my right arm if I could live in a home built in pocky. Anyhow, may hedonism prevail and all that. False, man was made AFTER the animals and plants. We were made as a part of creation to be good stewards and to tend the garden, participating in the creative work of God by tending it. We were not allowed to eat animals until well after the fall (part of the covenant with Noah). Animals are not machines, nor are plants to relegate them to such a role means we forget that they are part of God's work and part of the means to God's communication with us. The CCC teaches us that we can come to know God through nature, we must not wantonly abuse that which is a part of how God communicates with us. With that said, plants and animals are both non-rational species and do not possess immortal souls. It is not bad to eat either one. And seeing as plants are living and even respond positively to people talking with them peacefully, and experiments have shown negative talk to have negative effects on plants it might be believed that something more is going on there than first meets the eye. yet no one is saying eating them is bad.
Selah Posted March 16, 2014 Posted March 16, 2014 False, man was made AFTER the animals and plants. We were made as a part of creation to be good stewards and to tend the garden, participating in the creative work of God by tending it. We were not allowed to eat animals until well after the fall (part of the covenant with Noah). Animals are not machines, nor are plants to relegate them to such a role means we forget that they are part of God's work and part of the means to God's communication with us. The CCC teaches us that we can come to know God through nature, we must not wantonly abuse that which is a part of how God communicates with us. With that said, plants and animals are both non-rational species and do not possess immortal souls. It is not bad to eat either one. And seeing as plants are living and even respond positively to people talking with them peacefully, and experiments have shown negative talk to have negative effects on plants it might be believed that something more is going on there than first meets the eye. yet no one is saying eating them is bad. *hand flies over head* My sarcasm, it is wasted. No matter. Come Noel. Back to the mountains with us.
PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted March 16, 2014 Posted March 16, 2014 *hand flies over head* My sarcasm, it is wasted. No matter. Come Noel. Back to the mountains with us. apparently You are sarcastic, hence even your sarcasm disclaimer is quoted...however, I have heard similar arguments IRL. your sarcastic post gave me a chance to respond to real world (NOT the TV show) scenarios.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now