Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Pope Open-minded About Ordaining Married Men


Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted

Just think...could you see Padre Pio or St. John Vianney married with kids?  I sure couldn't...
 

 

Saint John Vianney would sometimes spend entire days hearing confessions. No wife and children would ever put up with that, and they shouldn't. The priesthood isn't compatible with married life, at least in the structure and format it's in now. Priests simply don't have the time. Wives complain all the time about how their husbands spend too much time at work, and they simply work 8 hours a day! Imagine how much worse it would be if their husbands were gone at six in the morning and got back home at eight and sometimes even later at night? It simply wouldn't work.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Catholic =/= west

 

You said the East has had married priests for years, and there have been no negative things happen from the culture. I was saying that Western culture is incredibly different, and in a society where everyone is drooling at the mere thought of the Church "getting with the times", something like this wouldn't look good on us.

Posted

eh, I don't care either way. Things are different in many places anydangway

PhuturePriest
Posted

I'm actually against the idea of married priests and I'm a woman.  I think they have too many responsibilities as it is without adding a family to the mix.  I know that most of the Apostles were married (including Peter), but Jesus wasn't and priests are supposed to imitate Christ's life.  That's just my 2 cents.  ;)

 

And actually, we only have on record of Peter being married. Nothing mentions the other Apostles being married, and we especially know John wasn't, because he was so young when he began following Jesus.

Posted

Mary was 14 when she married Joseph. How young was John?

PhuturePriest
Posted

Mary was 14 when she married Joseph. How young was John?

 

He was described as not having facial hair yet.

Basilisa Marie
Posted (edited)

Saint John Vianney would sometimes spend entire days hearing confessions. No wife and children would ever put up with that, and they shouldn't. The priesthood isn't compatible with married life, at least in the structure and format it's in now. Priests simply don't have the time. Wives complain all the time about how their husbands spend too much time at work, and they simply work 8 hours a day! Imagine how much worse it would be if their husbands were gone at six in the morning and got back home at eight and sometimes even later at night? It simply wouldn't work.

 

You're silly.  If that were true, no one in the military or medical field would be married. But plenty are, and make it work just fine. 

 

However, I don't think married priests should become common practice, at least until we get many more priests. More priests would be able to share the workload, and make it easier for a man to balance his job and family. 

Edited by Basilisa Marie
Posted

my worry is that people would interpret such a move to symbolize the church is finally "getting with the times." People will start thinking priestesses and gay weddings are just a matter of time.

 

Should this matter?

 

I understand your sentiments and I do think that many supporting the ordination of married priests do so for the incorrect reasons that you refer to (ie. because it's a step toward gay weddings and priestesses.) 

 

It does complicate a genuine discussion of the issue. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

You're silly.  If that were true, no one in the military or medical field would be married. But plenty are, and make it work just fine. 

 

However, I don't think married priests should become common practice, at least until we get many more priests. More priests would be able to share the workload, and make it easier for a man to balance his job and family. 

 

Marriages with a person who is a part of law enforcement have incredibly high rates of divorce, and it has to do with how much time the job demands. I haven't seen any studies, but I'd imagine the military and medical field are much the same.

 

If we had way more priests, then having married priests wouldn't be as big of a deal. But I honestly wouldn't like it even if every parish in the world had four priests. The Church made and has upheld this practice for centuries, and it didn't do all that just because it could. In fact, as I'm sure you know, this practice was let go of for a while, but a problem arose with the clergy being very corrupt, so the practice was brought back as a way to focus the clergy back on Christ and the Church.

Posted

He was described as not having facial hair yet.

 

Late bloomer.

Posted (edited)

I'd have to ask are enough men in established marriages (in their 50's, 60's age wise) being encouraged in a possible calling they could have to be permanent deacons. Also the hosts from a certain number of masses per year, when a priest is present, could be used when he isn't there. They could be distributed by deacons at weekly masses of the word. This isn't so different to taking the Eucharist to people's homes, as done now, even by lay people.

The Pope is being receptive to their ideas but he has said he favours celibate priests in the past. He has actually said any changes would be from culture and not priest shortages. Making someone a priest in this instance is, in a sense, showing a lack of respect and dignity. It also ignores the needs the situation is bringing to the surface regarding priestly formation and the vocations and teaching of the people in such places. If a certain locality has problems or fruit isn't growing there it often shows there must be deep causes for it. The pope has said that the growth in vocations, and faithfulness, in the new areas of the church shows something about the more established areas of the church. Areas that think they always wield the power and direction of the church, namely the US and Europe.

My personal view is that celibate secular priests is more practical. The local church would have to face the consequences, financially and otherwise, of priests being married. They can't be moved between parishes or missions freely, parish work can strain a marriage and time with family (esp children), and it poses problems if the marriage breaks down or the wife, or priests children, bring disrepute to his role.
Another problem is that once a church, in law, starts to deal with wives and pensions if will find itself having to start being clearer regarding contracts, and then dealing with priests who will enter illicit marriages and unions (homosexual or otherwise).  The canon process for removing priests, and the fallout of their family with no income, will create problems. The damage seen among Anglican clergy should be a warning  this isn't to be welcomed.

Edited by Benedictus
PhuturePriest
Posted

Late bloomer.

 

I started growing mustache hairs when I was twelve, and beard hair when I was thirteen. I was proud of it and refused to shave it for two or three years. Thankfully I decided to shave it finally, as everyone tells me it looked incredibly stupid.

OnlySunshine
Posted

Just imagine that you are on your deathbed and request your last rites at 4am.  The hospital or your family calls the parish priest and he says that he can't come because his wife is away and someone has to stay with the kids.  It's too late (or early) to find a babysitter and his family doesn't live close by.  Thus, you are deprived of your last rites.  It may be a severe situation that requires priestly assistance and, if they had a family, they wouldn't be free to drop things at a moment's notice like they are now.  Matthew Kelly said it best when he said that those who put other needs before their own would be mothers first and priests 2nd.  Priests can work 100 hours a day 365 days of the year and not make a dent in the spiritual life of the parish.  It's constantly changing and requiring a priest presence at all times.  I'd hate to be married to a priest and keep him away from the duties of his parish.

Posted

Do you think God would deny someone entry into Heaven because they didn't receive last rites even if they desired them?

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

The holy bible says nothing of priests being married, and the holy catholic church already excepts anglican priests whom convert and are already married to stay married and remain priests, ie: like St Peter. The only biblical mention of married religious is the role of deacon and elder but to be classified as an elder you need to have children of age practising the faith. Read your scriptures people. Sacred tradition, the holy sacraments, and THE HOLY BIBLE! reflects the trinity, for realz  :P 3 sources of divine revelation.

Edited by Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

Winchester - No, but to the dying person it would matter and also to their family. It would be a pastoral failure. If the priest knew this was happening it must be discouraging. Something often has to give, and from reading and hearing about Anglican priests, its often ends up being a choice between their ministry or their marriage. That's if their wife hasn't already made the decision for them! Being a priests wife mustn't be easy; people come to your door all the time and expect you to be and act a specific way. Even worse if the wife happens to not be a Christian, or has a job that those in the parish frown upon. If she doesn't have children, or enough, then this brings gossip and questions. It's a situation that brings more problems than it necessarily solves.

On some level though having a priest take the place of Christ in a parish, but not being able to follow Christ in clerical celibacy seems a bit of an oxymoron to me. It seems clear St Paul's view of marriage was that it shouldn't be the norm or be encouraged, but as a mercy for Christians who aren't strong enough to persevere.  

I believe that in the Orthodox churches those entering priesthood have to be married before they are ordained. If they are single they then cannot marry once ordained. Celibate men are the only ones allowed to become bishops. Those men who are married cannot then marry again if their wife dies or she divorces him. I think this is similar for Eastern Catholics.
 While this grew up for understandable reasons I think it would be detrimental to the western church to adopt this practice in the current climate where the move would be politically hijacked and seen as a sign of liberalism, weakness or the collapse of the church. It's sad but these are the times we are in.

That aside, from my experience of the churches, the way the dioceses and the laity behave often engage and behave (plus the scandals) I'm not surprised many men don't want to give their lives to the ministry. One of the biggest hindrances for men entering the seminary I heard at vocations groups was the worry they'll train to be priests, forsaking marriage, and then 10 or 15 years later the church changes course and they'll feel cheated. Although this maybe isn't a good reason to put a vocation off, it sure is understandable why men apply later in life. I think if the church wants men to be serious about priestly vocations they need to set their course and provide some reassurances one way of the other.

Edited by Benedictus
Posted

Life is full of failures. Other rites have married priests. If it happens, it will be okay.

Posted

:rolleyes: :huh: And the Latin rite generally doesn't, so it will be okay :P

Posted

I'm not the one hyperventilating.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...