Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Reunion Between Catholics And Lutherans


Recommended Posts

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Lutherans and Catholics can never be reunited unless the Lutherans reject their heresies, and reject Luther as a spiritual leader.

Posted

Lutherans and Catholics can never be reunited unless the Lutherans reject their heresies, and reject Luther as a spiritual leader.


And yet both Catholics and Lutherans are part of the Church of Christ
Nihil Obstat
Posted

And yet both Catholics and Lutherans are part of the Church of Christ

Only those Lutherans who are innocent of the Lutheran errors.

Posted (edited)

Why do they need to come to full communion? The Church of Christ already exists and operates in communities that reject Roman Catholic dogma:

 

17.  Therefore, there exists a single Church of Christ, which subsists in the Catholic Church, governed by the Successor of Peter and by the Bishops in communion with him.58 The Churches which, while not existing in perfect communion with the Catholic Church, remain united to her by means of the closest bonds, that is, by apostolic succession and a valid Eucharist, are true particular Churches.59Therefore, the Church of Christ is present and operative also in these Churches, even though they lack full communion with the Catholic Church, since they do not accept the Catholic doctrine of the Primacy, which, according to the will of God, the Bishop of Rome objectively has and exercises over the entire Church.

 

http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20000806_dominus-iesus_en.html

 

 Why don't they need to come into full communion, or are you being sarcastic? I'm trying to understand where you're coming from my friend.

 

That paragraph number 17 is talking about the Eastern Orthodox  and Oriental Churches that are not in full communion with Rome. Because they have apostolic succession and a valid Eucharist, they are more closer united (through imperfectly) to the Catholic Church then Protestants who only have the one sacrament of initiation, baptism. Baptism is a sacrament of the Catholic Church that Orthodox and Protestant groups have… and therefore they are indebted to the Catholic Church because without her they wouldn't have baptism.  Doesn't that mean the Catholic Church is still understood to be the universal sacrament of salvation? I think its important to understand #17 in the context of #18:

 

 

On the other hand, the ecclesial communities which have not preserved the valid Episcopate and the genuine and integral substance of the Eucharistic mystery,61 are not Churches in the proper sense; however, those who are baptized in these communities are, by Baptism, incorporated in Christ and thus are in a certain communion, albeit imperfect, with the Church.62 Baptism in fact tends per se toward the full development of life in Christ, through the integral profession of faith, the Eucharist, and full communion in the Church.63

 

http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20000806_dominus-iesus_en.html

 

 

Baptism tends to the end which is "full development of life in Christ, through the integral profession of faith, the Eucharist, and full communion in the Church."

Edited by Seven77
Posted

Peace,

 

 Why don't they need to come into full communion, or are you being sarcastic? I'm trying to understand where you're coming from my friend.

 

I was being serious, why do Lutherans (or any other Christian group for that matter) need to come into full union since according to many documents they are already part of the Church of Christ? I have yet to read anywhere something that states they must embrace Catholicism. It seems the Roman Catholic Church has come to accept the existence of these groups within their own right. 

 

 

That paragraph number 17 is talking about the Eastern Orthodox  and Oriental Churches that are not in full communion with Rome. Because they have apostolic succession and a valid Eucharist, they are more closer united (through imperfectly) to the Catholic Church then Protestants who only have the one sacrament of initiation, baptism. Baptism is a sacrament of the Catholic Church that Orthodox and Protestant groups have… and therefore they are indebted to the Catholic Church because without her they wouldn't have baptism.  Doesn't that mean the Catholic Church is still understood to be the universal sacrament of salvation? I think its important to understand #17 in the context of #18:

 

 

What it also says is that the Church of Christ remains in these schismatic communities despite rejecting Catholic Dogma. My understanding which apparently is wrong, is that the Church of Christ *is* the One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church headed by the Roman Pontiff and that baptism made one a member of this Church. To separate you from the Church founded on Peter meant cutting yourself off form the Church of Christ. It seems the correct view now is to say that the Church of Christ exists in it's own right and subsists in many communities even if they hold on to doctrines that are mutually exclusive from one another. 

Posted

wat

 

Lutherans and Catholics are members of the Church of Christ.

Posted

It's not either/or. I can have family who I think are in error and/or rejecting the truth. (I do, actually) They are still my family, and they are of the family body. The anaology is similar to ecumenism -  others have a faith and proclaim Jesus, even if we hold them in error on many things or not adhering to the fullness of truth. Our work should be to pray and minister to them. You can't work out problems if you don't talk, or if you don't highlight what is good in the other. This doesn't mean selling yourself short and faling to hold what is true.  Ultimately God knows if people are really his or not, we can only go on our best of spiritual patrimony and faith. If people compromise the truth they hold for other reasons they are spiritual devils (hypocrites and against God). But we also need to recognise, aside from ecumenism, we have work on problems in our own dioceses. Thre are those i' in communion' (and there always have been) who are defective and  or in error. Is the church doing enough on this front? How can the church work with others when it doesn't adequately sort out its own problems?

Posted

Peace,

 

 

I was being serious, why do Lutherans (or any other Christian group for that matter) need to come into full union since according to many documents they are already part of the Church of Christ? I have yet to read anywhere something that states they must embrace Catholicism. It seems the Roman Catholic Church has come to accept the existence of these groups within their own right. 

 

 

 

What it also says is that the Church of Christ remains in these schismatic communities despite rejecting Catholic Dogma. My understanding which apparently is wrong, is that the Church of Christ *is* the One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church headed by the Roman Pontiff and that baptism made one a member of this Church. To separate you from the Church founded on Peter meant cutting yourself off form the Church of Christ. It seems the correct view now is to say that the Church of Christ exists in it's own right and subsists in many communities even if they hold on to doctrines that are mutually exclusive from one another. 

 

Mortify, you were not wrong.  The Pope did teach as you understood.  The Church has since changed its teaching on what the nature of the Church is in recent times as Lumen Gentium (promulgated in Vatican II) states.  How the Church reconciles its modern understanding with its original is a circle I've not been able to square.  Some will point to doctrinal development without understanding Newman's own limits on the theory, while others try to convince themselves documents like Unam Sactum can be understood in a Lumen Gentium way. 

 

Anyway, yours is a good question.  Honest Catholics will admit their Church errs sometimes in its teachings.  (Church also used to teach unbaptized infants didn't go to heaven but stuck in limbo and that usery was sinful). 

 

E

Nihil Obstat
Posted

The Church cannot err. If something was true before VII, it remains equally true for Catholics today. The Church of Christ is the Catholic Church, and the Church is necessary for salvation.

Posted

Mortify, you were not wrong.  The Pope did teach as you understood.  The Church has since changed its teaching on what the nature of the Church is in recent times as Lumen Gentium (promulgated in Vatican II) states.  How the Church reconciles its modern understanding with its original is a circle I've not been able to square.  Some will point to doctrinal development without understanding Newman's own limits on the theory, while others try to convince themselves documents like Unam Sactum can be understood in a Lumen Gentium way. 

 

Anyway, yours is a good question.  Honest Catholics will admit their Church errs sometimes in its teachings.  (Church also used to teach unbaptized infants didn't go to heaven but stuck in limbo and that usery was sinful). 

 

E

 

Eliakim,

 

Admitting change carries significant consequences. Are you of the opinion the Chair is currently empty?

Posted

Eliakim,

 

Admitting change carries significant consequences. Are you of the opinion the Chair is currently empty?

 

No, the Chair isn't empty.  Intelligent and honest Catholics admit change occurred.  The problem is not having an infallible list of infallible statements. 

 

Some Catholics ignorantly rail at Protestants for not having an infallible magisterium, but foolishly don't see the beam in their own eye here. 

 

Dogma cannot be changed, but many things aren't dogma. 

 

Catholics are called to obey the ordinary magisterium but primacy of conscience enables us to avoid embracing magisterium's occasional errors or un-Christ-like penalties attached to some Church laws. 

 

Don't be a LAACC. 

 

E

Posted

No, the Chair isn't empty.  Intelligent and honest Catholics admit change occurred.  The problem is not having an infallible list of infallible statements. 

 

Some Catholics ignorantly rail at Protestants for not having an infallible magisterium, but foolishly don't see the beam in their own eye here. 

 

Dogma cannot be changed, but many things aren't dogma. 

 

Catholics are called to obey the ordinary magisterium but primacy of conscience enables us to avoid embracing magisterium's occasional errors or un-Christ-like penalties attached to some Church laws. 

 

Don't be a LAACC. 

 

E

 

I don't quite follow you, Eliakim. So you accept the current claimant to the Papal throne and that the magisterium has contradicted itself? Seems like you feel the Popes have exercised a power they don't really have, and that certain doctrines were promulgated as dogma when they really weren't. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

No, the Chair isn't empty.  Intelligent and honest Catholics admit change occurred.  The problem is not having an infallible list of infallible statements. 

 

Some Catholics ignorantly rail at Protestants for not having an infallible magisterium, but foolishly don't see the beam in their own eye here. 

 

Dogma cannot be changed, but many things aren't dogma. 

 

Catholics are called to obey the ordinary magisterium but primacy of conscience enables us to avoid embracing magisterium's occasional errors or un-Christ-like penalties attached to some Church laws. 

 

Don't be a LAACC. 

 

E

Are you trying to imply that extra ecclesiam nulla salus is not in fact infallibly taught by the Church? Interesting tactic.

Posted

I don't quite follow you, Eliakim. So you accept the current claimant to the Papal throne and that the magisterium has contradicted itself? Seems like you feel the Popes have exercised a power they don't really have, and that certain doctrines were promulgated as dogma when they really weren't. 

 

Almost.  I'd say rather the Church has at times promulgated errant teachings that it was more than willing to let be understood to be infallible by the laity, if it furthered Church power.  Remember not everything the Pope or magisterium does is infallible. 

 

Are you trying to imply that extra ecclesiam nulla salus is not in fact infallibly taught by the Church? Interesting tactic.

 

It is, but it was incorrectly taught at times.  See above. 

 

E

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Almost. I'd say rather the Church has at times promulgated errant teachings that it was more than willing to let be understood to be infallible by the laity, if it furthered Church power. Remember not everything the Pope or magisterium does is infallible.


It is, but it was incorrectly taught at times. See above.

E


And what makes you think that modern man is so much better capable of understanding God's will? Is it the characteristically modern tendency towards personal sanctity? Record Mass attendance? The great respect and reverence for the Liturgy and its traditions? Our laity who are so understanding of Catholic teaching? Oh wait...

Truly we live in an age of great holiness. :rolleyes:
Posted

Lutherans and Catholics are members of the Church of Christ.

 

 How is it then that a Catholic In a state of grace can receive the Eucharist in a Catholic parish and a well-meaning sincere Lutheran cannot receive the Eucharist?

Posted

And what makes you think that modern man is so much better capable of understanding God's will? Is it the characteristically modern tendency towards personal sanctity? Record Mass attendance? The great respect and reverence for the Liturgy and its traditions? Our laity who are so understanding of Catholic teaching? Oh wait...

Truly we live in an age of great holiness. :rolleyes:

 

I'm just pointing out the fact that some Church teachings do change.  In times past it was more holy and reverent but erred by being too strict. 

 

Never be a LAACC. 

 

E

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I'm just pointing out the fact that some Church teachings do change. In times past it was more holy and reverent but erred by being too strict.

Never be a LAACC.

E


Which teachings change? Why? How? Who decides these things?
Posted

Which teachings change? Why? How? Who decides these things?

 

Pls read carefully my posts above. 

 

E

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...