TotusTuusMaria Posted April 13, 2014 Posted April 13, 2014 JMJT There use to be a headcovering debate some years back (I think Alyosius and Apotheoun were part of) that was 30-50 pages or something. Is that still available?
TotusTuusMaria Posted April 13, 2014 Author Posted April 13, 2014 I am good. Thanks! Does archived mean we can't see it?
Socrates Posted April 14, 2014 Posted April 14, 2014 JMJT There use to be a headcovering debate some years back (I think Alyosius and Apotheoun were part of) that was 30-50 pages or something. Is that still available? Looking for Lenten penance?
TotusTuusMaria Posted April 14, 2014 Author Posted April 14, 2014 (edited) Looking for Lenten penance? :hehe: You figured me out. :evil: God will reward you if you supply me with a link? :nun3: Edited April 14, 2014 by TotusTuusMaria
Benedictus Posted April 14, 2014 Posted April 14, 2014 (edited) I think men and women should do so. It seems though, unless I'm mistaken, men didn't really do so in Christianity because it was associated with Jewish tradition. If a man enters a church with a hat or covering he's told to remove it, unless it's a biretta or monk cowl. Seems odd the option doesn't exist, if the covering is respectable. Edited April 14, 2014 by Benedictus
AugustineA Posted April 14, 2014 Posted April 14, 2014 I dig the head coverings and modest dress. It's the sort of outward sign of modesty that usually requires actual modesty to do. And girls look (wayyy) cuter wearing those mantillas.. boom, debate won. I feel kinda casual in plaid, so I have to step it up a notch..
Benedictus Posted April 14, 2014 Posted April 14, 2014 I dig the head coverings and modest dress. It's the sort of outward sign of modesty that usually requires actual modesty to do. And girls look (wayyy) cuter wearing those mantillas.. boom, debate won. I feel kinda casual in plaid, so I have to step it up a notch.. :lol:
Basilisa Marie Posted April 14, 2014 Posted April 14, 2014 Augustine made an argument about the passage in Paul that talks about women needing to cover their heads but men not. It basically comes down to Augustine's idea that femininity reflects the things of this world, and masculinity reflects things that are not of this world. Thus, he thought it was proper for women to veil because it served as a symbolic reminder for all people to focus things that are not of this world (i.e. God, the divine, etc), and improper for men to cover their heads, for the same reason. It's not that things of this world are bad, it's that they're lower goods. He argued that both men and women image God in their humanity, but masculinity and femininity image different things. Masculinity images God and Christ, while femininity images the beauty and goodness of creation. Now, whether or not any of that argument has any real theological heft is a different story. But I think it offers us an interesting take on the issue. :)
TotusTuusMaria Posted April 15, 2014 Author Posted April 15, 2014 Augustine made an argument about the passage in Paul that talks about women needing to cover their heads but men not. It basically comes down to Augustine's idea that femininity reflects the things of this world, and masculinity reflects things that are not of this world. Thus, he thought it was proper for women to veil because it served as a symbolic reminder for all people to focus things that are not of this world (i.e. God, the divine, etc), and improper for men to cover their heads, for the same reason. It's not that things of this world are bad, it's that they're lower goods. He argued that both men and women image God in their humanity, but masculinity and femininity image different things. Masculinity images God and Christ, while femininity images the beauty and goodness of creation. Now, whether or not any of that argument has any real theological heft is a different story. But I think it offers us an interesting take on the issue. :) That is interesting. Alice von Hildebrand says that woman reminds the world of the sacred and is sacred and that is why she has the privilege of being veiled during the holy assembly. She points out that everything in the Old Testament that was touched by God was veiled. We even make use of the veil today during the Mass to cover the sacred. God touches the body of the woman by placing within her a soul, in His image and likeness: "...there is a direct contact between God and the woman, (the husband is totally out of the picture), and once again, this divine touch gives her body a special dignity—a nobility which indicates that she is granted a special calling to respect this mysterious sphere." "And this is why the female body should be veiled because everything which is sacred calls for veiling. When Moses came down from Mount Sinai, he veiled his face. Why did he veil his face? Because he had spoken to God and at that very moment there was a sacredness that that called for veiling. Now... feminists after VII suddenly 'discovered' that when women go to Church veiled, it is a sign of their inferiority. The man takes off his hat and the woman puts on a veil. My goodness, how they have lost the sense of the supernatural. Veiling indicates sacredness and it is a special privilege of the woman that she enters church veiled." "The symbolism of the veil is obvious: it always refers to something marked by sacredness. When Moses came down from Mount Sinai after having spoken with God, he covered his face. When Christ is present in the tabernacle, the latter is covered by a veil. The veil symbolizes sacredness. The fact that the woman's intimate organs are veiled gives us a clear message: they belong to God in a special way. Knowing from all eternity that his son was to be incarnated in the womb of a virgin, it was 'proper and just' that the latter should have an exterior sign of its sacredness. The hymen does not serve a practical purpose. But it has a deep symbolic meaning. All women, having the privilege of sharing the sex of the Queen of Heaven, partake of this same privilege. In his treatise on virginity, St. Augustine remarks that even when a little girl is the product of sin, be it incest, rape or adultery, she partakes of the same privilege."
TotusTuusMaria Posted April 15, 2014 Author Posted April 15, 2014 I don't want another debate; I just wanted to read the old one because I think Aloysius had given a really compelling argument for scriptural discipline that I had never heard before and I remember both sides using the Church fathers and I was interested in reading over it again. I think I might have found the link, but still reading through the posts. Haven't found what I was looking for yet, but I did find this in case anyone wanted to read it as well...http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/topic/71958-q-on-women-veiling/?hl=veiling
Basilisa Marie Posted April 15, 2014 Posted April 15, 2014 (edited) Yeah, there's a lot that can be said on both sides of the issue. One thing that should be mentioned is that the symbolism of veiling is lost on the vast majority of people nowadays. People might say the meaning is obvious, but frankly it's not for the vast majority of Catholics today. Which could be interpreted as a need for better instruction, a statement about how veiling is more of a cultural thing, or how women who veil are giving an opportunity to joyfully witness to a good practice. If people want to bring veiling back into popular practice, they need to put their arguments from authority back on the shelf and instead talk about awesome theological reasons for it, and let the statements be made mostly by women who are happy about wearing their veils and how much good it brings to their spiritual lives. That's the only thing that's going to work. Edited April 15, 2014 by Basilisa Marie
TotusTuusMaria Posted April 15, 2014 Author Posted April 15, 2014 Well said, BM. Another interesting thread I ran across. Aloysius makes mention of a reason for the headcovering similar to Augustine and women being a reminder of the world/society... http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/topic/63947-women-veils-and-other-things/ "Whereas woman is created into a society. The woman is the glue of the society, the one that keeps things together. Her head unveiled, the glory of man, will distract man and pull them back down. For that is what woman does to man: pulls them back down from having their head in the clouds as if no one else in the world exists and brings them into social being. The sign that she exhibits by veiling her head is: at this moment, we are not interacting with each other as a society. I am focused at God with you; and you should remain focused on God. In this one instance, I will not bother your single mindedness with my concern for socialization and society. A woman will interrupt a football game to try to socialize, but she veils her head to give the sign that there is no socialization to be had in mass.Adam was not a social being until Eve came.The phrase 'the glory of man' can be seen quite well in the romances throughout history, as a man goes into endless description of the woman's beauty and grace and nearly angelic purity. This glory of man, this greatness in woman which draws man away from his selfishness, is something good and holy which ought to be veiled in the presence of that which man is supposed to give His undivided attention to." - Aloysius
Basilisa Marie Posted April 15, 2014 Posted April 15, 2014 Yeah I usually don't like any of the "wow women are just so perfect they remind men of heaven!" stuff. So much of it is focused on how the whole point of women existing is to make men better. Which, while exists as one possible interpretation of the first creation story of Genesis, falls apart once you leave Genesis 1. Men treating women like they're superhuman is really no better than treating them like they're subhuman. A problem I have with the argument you posted is that it put so much of the focus on how women veiling serves the interests of men. And surprising though it may be, women don't chiefly exist to serve the interests of men. :hehe2:
TotusTuusMaria Posted April 15, 2014 Author Posted April 15, 2014 (edited) Yeah I usually don't like any of the "wow women are just so perfect they remind men of heaven!" stuff. So much of it is focused on how the whole point of women existing is to make men better. Which, while exists as one possible interpretation of the first creation story of Genesis, falls apart once you leave Genesis 1. Men treating women like they're superhuman is really no better than treating them like they're subhuman. A problem I have with the argument you posted is that it put so much of the focus on how women veiling serves the interests of men. And surprising though it may be, women don't chiefly exist to serve the interests of men. :hehe2: Valid points and opinions. Personally, (and obviously :hehe: ) I like the points made by Hildebrand and Aloysius just as much as I like the more classical interpretations for the "why" behind the headcovering. I think the dignity of the woman can sometimes be lost in simply the classical interpretations just as, for sure, in the more modern interpretations there can be an air of superiority or as if the vocation of woman is solely for the sake of man. When understood in the context of the authors though, I am sure neither the Church fathers nor the modern philosophers and exegists had an improper understanding of woman or meant to wrongly emphasize either her great dignity and beauty or the reason in proper worship, justice, obedience, and submission. Both are beautiful ways to look at the headcovering which I find valid. We were all made for worship; life-giving, self-giving love, and we have the task of evangelization first and foremost. I do believe too women have a special ability to inspire men (and thus, civilization) to greatness, and I think that is beautiful and so important to acknowledge in evangelization. The more women can be reminded of this, I say, the better. It is by no means the only reason for existence nor even their very primary, but it is a great gift God has given them that needs to be properly exercised. Vatican II entrusted the intended Pentecost of the Council to women in a special manner, realizing (I believe) the gifts they have of inspiration for man and society. Given all that, the reality is that by actualizing their own dignity in the wearing of the headcovering they give justice to God by following divine revelation, contribute to their own good (they have actualized their dignity by practicing virtue), and give witness to both men and women (the primary means of evangelization). I apologize if I have made it seem as if they lived for the sake of men alone. Edited April 15, 2014 by TotusTuusMaria
Lil Red Posted April 15, 2014 Posted April 15, 2014 Yeah I usually don't like any of the "wow women are just so perfect they remind men of heaven!" stuff. So much of it is focused on how the whole point of women existing is to make men better. Which, while exists as one possible interpretation of the first creation story of Genesis, falls apart once you leave Genesis 1. Men treating women like they're superhuman is really no better than treating them like they're subhuman. A problem I have with the argument you posted is that it put so much of the focus on how women veiling serves the interests of men. And surprising though it may be, women don't chiefly exist to serve the interests of men. :hehe2: I luff you. :cheers:
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now