Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Popes And Liturgies


Recommended Posts

ithinkjesusiscool
Posted

Pax!

What can you say about the Liturgies of Pope John Paul II, Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI and Pope Francis?

and does Pope Francis celebrate great Liturgies (or is it just that he's good at meeting people)? Or is Benedict the only one of these three who know how to celebrate great Liturgies? 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Their writings as well as their actions do indicate that Pope Benedict has/had a greater focus on the liturgy. It is his area of expertise more than Pope John Paul's or Pope Francis'.

ithinkjesusiscool
Posted

People praise pope Francis but do they praise his way of celebrating Liturgies?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

People praise pope Francis but do they praise his way of celebrating Liturgies?


Not that I have heard, at least.
Fidei Defensor
Posted

Even the ugliest liturgy, so long as it follows the rubrics, still brings us Jesus. We should always remember that.

ithinkjesusiscool
Posted

The ugliest Liturgy? Are you arguing that Mass should be said as long as it is valid. Wouldn't a black Mass be valid? What exactly did you mean?

Fidei Defensor
Posted

The ugliest Liturgy? Are you arguing that Mass should be said as long as it is valid. Wouldn't a black Mass be valid? What exactly did you mean?

I mean aesthetically ugly.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Even the ugliest liturgy, so long as it follows the rubrics, still brings us Jesus. We should always remember that.

Are flagrantly ugly liturgies, even when those involved had every opportunity to make things more beautiful, more in line with the mind of the Church, and more faithful to the rubrics, as pleasing to God as beautiful, edifying liturgies, in which the sacred ministers have respect for and devotion to the texts and celebration of the Mass?

maximillion
Posted (edited)

Since I have no way of knowing the mind of God then there is no way of knowing. It is a human trait to look for the aesthetically pleasing. Maybe that does not apply to God.

 

What IS pleasing to God has to be a form of liturgy where He is honoured, which helps people discover His truth, and which assists in His revelation of Himself to the participants.

 

Does that mean it has to be aesthetically pleasing in our eyes.......moot point, IMO, since I know God can turn anything into an opportunity to save souls, even an 'ugly' liturgy.

 

 

Edited by maximillion
Nihil Obstat
Posted

I clarified enough that I think there is a clear answer. In any case, flouting the rubrics of the liturgy is mortally sinful.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

Are flagrantly ugly liturgies, even when those involved had every opportunity to make things more beautiful, more in line with the mind of the Church, and more faithful to the rubrics, as pleasing to God as beautiful, edifying liturgies, in which the sacred ministers have respect for and devotion to the texts and celebration of the Mass?

No. I'm just pointing out that for those faithful who don't have access to beautiful liturgies, that Jesus still becomes present.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

No. I'm just pointing out that for those faithful who don't have access to beautiful liturgies, that Jesus still becomes present.


But from a general perspective, it is incorrect to assume that such a Liturgy is "just as good", right?
Posted

God likes beautiful or aesthetically pleasing things.. Old Testament descriptions of the temple, the vestments, the Song of Songs. Mary bought expensive perfume for Jesus' feet and she was affirmed. Judas said the money was better put elsewhere, and he was rebuked. Yes, Jesus is present at the Mass. Yes, that also means we should make it beautiful.  

Fidei Defensor
Posted

But from a general perspective, it is incorrect to assume that such a Liturgy is "just as good", right?

It depends on how you're defining "just as good." If the only measure is whether or not Jesus is present, then yes, it's "just as good." However, a both valid and licit liturgy is always to be preferred to an illicit one, or God forbid, an invalid one.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

It depends on how you're defining "just as good." If the only measure is whether or not Jesus is present, then yes, it's "just as good." However, a both valid and licit liturgy is always to be preferred to an illicit one, or God forbid, an invalid one.

That is my entire point though. Validity is an insultingly low hurdle. Liturgical minimalism does not do us good as a Church. We should not consider the Liturgy as being done 'good enough' simply because it was valid and the priest did not preach heresy. That view does not respect the Church's liturgical heritage, or the liturgy's venerated position in the Faith.
Fidei Defensor
Posted

That is my entire point though. Validity is an insultingly low hurdle. Liturgical minimalism does not do us good as a Church. We should not consider the Liturgy as being done 'good enough' simply because it was valid and the priest did not preach heresy. That view does not respect the Church's liturgical heritage, or the liturgy's venerated position in the Faith.

I agree with you. I'm just saying, because we don't live in a perfect world, that those who aren't blessed with the most beautiful liturgies in the world can still rest assured that they are receiving Jesus (all the while praying to fix the liturgies they are unfortunate to have to attend.)

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I agree with you. I'm just saying, because we don't live in a perfect world, that those who aren't blessed with the most beautiful liturgies in the world can still rest assured that they are receiving Jesus (all the while praying to fix the liturgies they are unfortunate to have to attend.)

People use that as an excuse though, or as a stick with which to beat people who really do care about the Liturgy. You see why we have to be careful.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

People use that as an excuse though, or as a stick with which to beat people who really do care about the Liturgy. You see why we have to be careful.

Of course.

Posted

Tardis... you better be watching the canonization. 

Fidei Defensor
Posted

Tardis... you better be watching the canonization. 

I was, I was!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...