Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Following Catholic uproar, a proposed Satanic mass at Harvard has been canceled. The mass was going to be put on by the Satanic Temple, the group who also has plans to plant a Baphomet figure on the front lawn of the Oklahoma Statehouse. Despite the fact that the Harvard Extension School Cultural Studies Club dropped its sponsorship, the group still managed to have an unsanctioned "black mass" at Harvard Square's Hong Kong restaurant and lounge. What bothers me the most about the official quashing of the Satanic Temple's mass by Harvard is that it is being hailed as a victory for religious tolerance—it's not. Instead, it's a case of a small group getting bullied into submission because it offended a big religion. 

 

...

 

Times have changed, so I’d like to tell Dr. Clooney how the American religious landscape looks in 2014. Dr. Clooney, I am a Muslim. As a Muslim in the cliché context of “post-9/11 America,” I encounter anti-Muslim discourses that use the same arguments that you have employed against Satanists. In more than one American city, Islamophobes have opposed the establishment of mosques by claiming that Muslims are intolerant and incapable of coexisting with other communities, or even that Islam is not a “real” religion and therefore cannot be entitled to the same defense of its freedoms. In the case of the so-called “Ground Zero Mosque,” people argued against the presence of a Muslim community simply on the basis that it would hurt their feelings. 

As a Muslim, I have to support the Satanists. Public revulsion of Muslims in this country is so popular that I have no choice but to stand with religions that are marked as ugly, offensive, and intolerant. Rather than join the anti-Satanist outrage and try to convince Christians that Muslims deserve to be included as “children of Abraham” or whatever, I would suggest that Muslims take a radical stand on behalf of the religious freedoms that we claim for ourselves. The people who wish to insult Muslims are not members of ridiculed fringe groups. They are not just isolated Qur’an-burning pastors, but extraordinarily well-funded and networked activists. Islamophobia is so mainstream that as Muslims, we must support freedom for all marginalized religions, because too many people have marginalized us.

....

 

What Clooney and Faust miss is that some of us find claims of Jesus Christ as the only means of salvation from eternal torture to be incredibly offensive. Any tradition whose advocates promise to be exclusive possessors of the capital-T “Truth” is going to bother someone. Should all religious discourse that claims supreme truth-making power over other religions disappear from the public? I get that Harvard Divinity School’s preferred religiosity tends to go soft in this regard: At Div School, folks don’t go much for the hellfire talk or claims of superiority. Maybe there’s a Div School version of Satanism that Clooney could go for. Or not, but who cares—Clooney’s personal taste does not provide the measurement of Satanism’s legitimacy. 

 

...

 

Read the full article here

 

http://www.vice.com/read/muslims-for-satan

Edited by Hasan
Winchester
Posted

I find myself taking Satanism as seriously as I might a GWAR concert.

 

By which I mean, not at all.

Posted

I find myself taking Satanism as seriously as I might a GWAR concert.

By which I mean, not at all.


That's cool, brah
Winchester
Posted

Other than that, the article makes good points. I like the part that implies that maybe none of this stuff is the purview of state power.

Posted

i wonder how the author would feel about a "religious" ceremony that involves desecrating the the Quran.

KnightofChrist
Posted

i wonder how the author would feel about a "religious" ceremony that involves desecrating the the Quran.

 

Or a mock version of a Satanic mockery of the Salat. 

Posted

i wonder how the author would feel about a "religious" ceremony that involves desecrating the the Quran.

 

 

I think that would depend on who was doing the desecrating and where.  I think he would find a Christian group doing it in the US the be vulgar while Saudi Christians performing the same act in Saudi Arabia would likely be something he'd be a lot more sympathetic too.  

 

However, his point is not about feelings.  As he explicitly says.  A marginalized group's ability to express itself peacefully should not be contingent on how you or he feels about that group or their expression.  

Anastasia13
Posted

I think that would depend on who was doing the desecrating and where.  I think he would find a Christian group doing it in the US the be vulgar while Saudi Christians performing the same act in Saudi Arabia would likely be something he'd be a lot more sympathetic too.  

 

However, his point is not about feelings.  As he explicitly says.  A marginalized group's ability to express itself peacefully should not be contingent on how you or he feels about that group or their expression.  

Can we test that before going to Saudi Arabia?

Anastasia13
Posted (edited)

Other than that, the article makes good points. I like the part that implies that maybe none of this stuff is the purview of state power.

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free practice thereof.

 

...We leave that to case law.

Edited by Light and Truth
ardillacid
Posted

I find myself taking Satanism as seriously as I might a GWAR concert.

 

By which I mean, not at all.

 

Is this some old person reference? 

Winchester
Posted

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free practice thereof.

 

...We They leave that to case law.

It's they. We are not the government. We were never the government. We never will be the government.  That was always a lie. 

Anastasia13
Posted

It's they. We are not the government. We were never the government. We never will be the government.  That was always a lie. 

 

Or a death sentence.

Posted

I think that would depend on who was doing the desecrating and where.  I think he would find a Christian group doing it in the US the be vulgar while Saudi Christians performing the same act in Saudi Arabia would likely be something he'd be a lot more sympathetic too.  

 

However, his point is not about feelings.  As he explicitly says.  A marginalized group's ability to express itself peacefully should not be contingent on how you or he feels about that group or their expression.  

 

Is it (desecration of the Quran) in-and-of itself offensive to Muslims or not? 

Posted

Is it (desecration of the Quran) in-and-of itself offensive to Muslims or not?


Since there are over a billion Muslims I don't think anybody can say what every single individual Muslim considers. I think it's safe to say traditionally and contemporarily most believing Muslims would find such an act offensive.
PhuturePriest
Posted

Since there are over a billion Muslims I don't think anybody can say what every single individual Muslim considers. I think it's safe to say traditionally and contemporarily most believing Muslims would find such an act offensive.

 

What if part of the Miles-Is-Awesome Religion (founded by Your Humbleness, Miles the Great) was burning mass quantities of Qur'ans? Should it be stopped if I wanted to do a ritual in His Greatness' honor on Harvard if Muslims found it deeply offensive?

 

This is why I don't like American politics.

Posted

What if part of the Miles-Is-amesome Religion (founded by Your Humbleness, Miles the Great) was burning mass quantities of Qur'ans? Should it be stopped if I wanted to do a ritual in His Greatness' honor on Harvard if Muslims found it deeply offensive?

 

This is why I don't like American politics.

 

 

I don't think so.  Although, depending on your motives, it may mean that you're a jerk.  The same is true of Satanists who want to conduct a Black Mass.

PhuturePriest
Posted

I don't think so.  Although, depending on your motives, it may mean that you're a jerk.  The same is true of Satanists who want to conduct a Black Mass.

 

I can hardly see how this wouldn't make His Humble Greatness a jerk, blessed be his name. I can hardly think of a valid reason to burn Qur'ans other than to compete with the Westboro Baptist Church for biggest d-bag of the year.

Posted

I can hardly see how this wouldn't make His Humble Greatness a jerk, blessed be his name. I can hardly think of a valid reason to burn Qur'ans other than to compete with the Westboro Baptist Church for biggest d-bag of the year.

 

 

I think if a group of Saudi Christians burnt Saudi manufactured Qur'ans to protest the Royal Family's theocracy then this would be an act that was far from obviously malicious.  

 

Although, of course, burning a Qur'an would be a lot more like desecrating a consecrated host, something the group here expressly said that they would not do out of respect for the feelings of practicing Catholics. 

 

Either way, it's speech that should be protected.  However I would say that morally there is a big difference between a minority and largely marginalized religious group, like Satanist in America or Christians in Saudi Arabia, engaging in this sort of action versus a dominate religion engaging in this sort of action with the iconography of a minority/marginalized religion.  

Posted

I think if a group of Saudi Christians burnt Saudi manufactured Qur'ans to protest the Royal Family's theocracy then this would be an act that was far from obviously malicious.  

 

Although, of course, burning a Qur'an would be a lot more like desecrating a consecrated host, something the group here expressly said that they would not do out of respect for the feelings of practicing Catholics. 

 

Either way, it's speech that should be protected.  However I would say that morally there is a big difference between a minority and largely marginalized religious group, like Satanist in America or Christians in Saudi Arabia, engaging in this sort of action versus a dominate religion engaging in this sort of action with the iconography of a minority/marginalized religion.  

 

 

Just to clarify, you would say that burning a Qur'an is an act of free speech, an act to be protected?

 

And, by the way, I would agree that an act of desecration is *more* grave if it carried out by a majority religion against a minority one. But either way, the intentional action of desecration itself is grave.

Posted

Other than that, the article makes good points. I like the part that implies that maybe none of this stuff is the purview of state power.

 

I agree about it not being the purview of state power.

As a Catholic, I believe the deliberate blasphemy of a "black mass" to be objectively gravely evil, but the decision of whether or not to host this or anything else belongs to Harvard, not to government courts.

 

Though I also don't believe the first amendment means that every private institution must be forced to accept and host whatever offensive act of provocation that demands it in the name of "free speech."

 

At the conservative Catholic school I went to, no one would consider the college allowing a "black mass" or other satanic ritual, and such a decision would not even be considered controversial there.  Courts should not force it to host "black masses" or other blasphemies.

Nobody's forced to attend or support that college, and if they want satanic orgies or whatever, they are free to go elsewhere.

 

People are free to debate the wisdom of Harvard's decision, and academic freedom - though personally I don't regard a divinity school declining to host a ritual with no purpose but to blaspheme God and insult the Christian religion a huge blow for freedom - but the decision belongs ultimately to Harvard.

 

I don't agree with much of what goes on many college campuses.  Many campuses are hypocritical about campus "freedom of speech" and, according to the author of this book, a self-described liberal atheist First Amendment lawyer, it's actually most often conservative Christians that are discriminated against. 

However, such controversies should be fought and settled at the individual college level, not dictated by government courts.  

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...