Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Popcorn Movies And Mindless Violence


Recommended Posts

Posted

It certainly isn't wrong but it is terrible. Promoting violence in anyway shape or form should be a much worse sin then sex.

 

When I wrote about "good violence" I was conveying the idea that it is morally right.  You apparently agree with me that there are circumstances in which violence is morally right.  I agree with you that violence is terrible and should only be used when necessary.  

 

One does not need personal experience of violence to comment on the moral status of violence.  One needs to have studied Church teaching on morality (which I have). 

 

Does an unrealistic portrayal violence in movies promote morally evil violence?  I am unaware of any definitive answer to this question.  It seems to me that a movie such as Winter Soldier that has a good moral message is unlikely to promote immoral violence. So, in my opinion, the answer is no.

 

By the way, sex is not, in itself, a sin.  It is a sin when it is misused.  Just like violence.
 

Credo in Deum
Posted

Trying to argue that sex is worse then violence is as backwards as a football bat.

footballbat.jpg

 

Your move, Semper!

Semper Catholic
Posted

When I wrote about "good violence" I was conveying the idea that it is morally right. You apparently agree with me that there are circumstances in which violence is morally right. I agree with you that violence is terrible and should only be used when necessary.

One does not need personal experience of violence to comment on the moral status of violence. One needs to have studied Church teaching on morality (which I have).

Does an unrealistic portrayal violence in movies promote morally evil violence? I am unaware of any definitive answer to this question. It seems to me that a movie such as Winter Soldier that has a good moral message is unlikely to promote immoral violence. So, in my opinion, the answer is no.

By the way, sex is not, in itself, a sin. It is a sin when it is misused. Just like violence.


There is no "good" violence.
Posted

There is no "good" violence.

 

I have explicitly told you that I am using "good" to mean "morally right".  This is an accepted and conventional use of the word.

 

Since you do believe that there is morally right violence, you must have some reason for objecting to using the word "good".  Could you explain what that is.

Credo in Deum
Posted

The person who gives you AID's through sex is better than the person who slaps you in the face telling you to keep it in your pants. Why won't you get this, Perigrina?

 

 

 

Semper Catholic
Posted

The person who gives you AID's through sex is better than the person who slaps you in the face telling you to keep it in your pantaloons. Why won't you get this, Perigrina?


Lol ill take bad analogies for $500 Alex.
Semper Catholic
Posted

I have explicitly told you that I am using "good" to mean "morally right". This is an accepted and conventional use of the word.

Since you do believe that there is morally right violence, you must have some reason for objecting to using the word "good". Could you explain what that is.


The word good implies something positive. Doing the right thing isn't always a "good" or positive thing. The military likes to refer to this as taking the hard right over the easy wrong.
Posted

The word good implies something positive. Doing the right thing isn't always a "good" or positive thing. The military likes to refer to this as taking the hard right over the easy wrong.

 

I will make a point to use terminology that you are more comfortable with in future discussions with you.  However, note that I did not say anything that you actually disagree with.  You just did not like the wording.
 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Shall we say "just" instead?

Credo in Deum
Posted

Lol ill take bad analogies for $500 Alex.

Sorry we are out of those.  The categories left are:

 

Handball, Slap-sex, and Mike Tyson.  

Not The Philosopher
Posted

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=axE83zcx6wY

PhuturePriest
Posted

I think this might be part of the reason that, when it comes to violent movies, I tend to prefer the rather grittier ones. Not because I enjoy the violence, but because I think it is preferable to be a little shocked by it, even a little horrified. Goodfellas and Donnie Brasco come to mind first of all. Dark Knight and Dark Knight Rises, for sure. Taken, perhaps. I saw Reservoir Dogs once, and that was a bit much for me. 

I do still like some of the big blockbuster action movies. The original Star Wars trilogy is among my favourites, and Kill Bill. But I like those for different reasons. I go into a movie like that with a different mindset. It works, but it is different. But by and large I prefer a movie where violence has actual consequences, not just for the bad guys, but also for innocents, and even the protagonists.

 

For instance, what kind of weird world is it where a hero can gun down a hundred bad guys and just walk away? That is terrifying. Sometimes violence is justified, but it should never be casual. Even when it is justified, I think it must also damage the 'good guy'.

 

This is why I think The Hunger Games is one of the best things that has happened to the film industry in a long time. In the second movie, you see Katniss struggling very much with the fact that she has killed people, and she has major PTSD over it. It shows the reality: That although she is very capable at killing, like many people are, she has a soul, and is more than just a bloodthirsty killer. So many movies show the hero as this impenetrable killing machine who never feels consequences, when in reality it is quite the opposite. The Hunger Games shows this quite clearly with all of the characters, even the ones who are evil (Think Cato at the end of the first movie, when he says "Do it; I'm dead anyway. I always was; I never realized it until now.")

Not A Mallard
Posted

This is why I think The Hunger Games is one of the best things that has happened to the film industry in a long time. In the second movie, you see Katniss struggling very much with the fact that she has killed people, and she has major PTSD over it. It shows the reality: That although she is very capable at killing, like many people are, she has a soul, and is more than just a bloodthirsty killer. So many movies show the hero as this impenetrable killing machine who never feels consequences, when in reality it is quite the opposite. The Hunger Games shows this quite clearly with all of the characters, even the ones who are evil (Think Cato at the end of the first movie, when he says "Do it; I'm dead anyway. I always was; I never realized it until now.")

Though I haven't seen the second Hunger Games (I saw the first one on Netflix, which apparently has scenes taken out), this is making me think about how much the Marvel superheroes glamorize violence.  Though Captain America is a just man, he kills countless bad guys and he doesn't seem haunted by it (unless the super serum turned him into a mindless killing machine).  Tony Stark blows a guy's chest out in Iron Man 3 and he makes a one-liner afterwards.  He's more traumatized by his experiences in The Avengers than he is about killing people.

Posted

I suppose there could be a problem for people who take the fighting in Winter Soldier and similar movies seriously, but it is about as realistic as the battle scene in the Nutcracker Suite.

 

http://youtu.be/rlVgLtZvHLc

 

I would be more concerned about first person shooter games, since one imagines oneself as the agent of violence.

 

 

Posted

I much prefer intelligent, well-planned and executed violence.

Not A Mallard
Posted

To tie back to the opening post, my enthusiasm for Transformers [4] has died down.  Even if it isn't as raunchy as the first three, I don't feel right supporting a movie based on kids toys that's not even made for kids.

Not A Mallard
Posted

To tie back to the opening post, my enthusiasm for Transformers [4] has died down.  Even if it isn't as raunchy as the first three, I don't feel right supporting a movie based on kids toys that's not even made for kids.

Well, I just learned that comic books were made for kids in the first place, so I guess this isn't much different.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...