Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Credo in Deum
Posted (edited)

I'm Pro-Life, since I'm anti-cancer, anti-drug abuse, anti-obesity, anti-anti anti anti-ism. Some say I'm so Pro-Life, that I'm an Antiist. 

 

It all makes perfect sense if you don't think about it.

Edited by Credo in Deum
Posted

Skepticism is healthy in science and it is needed. The idea that there can be no room for skepticism in climate change is dogmatic thinking, which is fine in religion, but not in science. Why is it that people cannot be skeptical of climate change, when there have been many predictions of gloom and doom that have never happened?

I don't deny climate change but I am skeptical it. I doubt it because I remember growing up believing it, believing all the sky is falling predictions, all of which should have happened already but didn't. My front yard is not a beach, though I remember being taught by this time it should have been, and I see recently that prediction is being recycled, again. It still snows and rather heavily, even though I was taught that would be a thing of the past by this time. The ozone layer is still there, even though I remember being taught that it would not be or be greatly reduced by now. Massive hurricanes have not been overly active, even though I was taught that they would be very numerous by now and very powerful. Etc, etc...

It feels like ever ten years or so we've only got 10 years before the end of the world. When evangelists foretell the end of the world and it doesn't happen not only is it answered with skepticism but mockery. But when climate change advocates do the story is completely different.

When someone or a group says 'x' will happened and then it doesn't it is perfectly fine to have a healthy skepticism of that person or movement.

 

You have every right to be skeptical. But 97% of scientists disagree with you. Which side do you want to error on?

Posted

Right, but I still don't see it as a pro-life issue, except in the broadest sense of the word. The pro-life movement exists to combat abortion, the direct and fully intentional murder of millions. As Catholics we are obliged to be concerned for all human life as dictated by Christian charity, but concern for the environment is still a very different thing from concern for the unborn. For one thing, there is far less equivocation about abortion. There is no doubt that abortion directly kills millions and maims many more.

 

With climate change, you can sorta-kinda lump ordinary natural disasters and "acts of God" into a big ball and blame it on the climate, sure. It smacks of confirmation bias to me, but that's just my opinion. And you can look at the amount of CO2 humans make and see that temps have risen in a more-or-less correlated way with it, sure. But only over a comparatively short period of time during which we have been able to actually measure such things. And cleaning up the earth for the good of all is something we should be doing, but if we can't do a perfect job right away we can at least still treat the symptoms of it (treatments for allergies and diseases, new farming techniques, etc).

 

But you can't do much to help someone who has been killed before they could even be born.

 

I guess thats where we dont see eye to eye. I dont view being prolife as JUST an abortion issue. I think it encompasses so much more. I think what it means to be a true prolife person is that you are prolife through ALL stages of life. Not just before birth. 

I believe prolife means we help the poor, we protect the planet etc. My prolife views dont stop after birth.

Posted

I guess thats where we dont see eye to eye. I dont view being prolife as JUST an abortion issue. I think it encompasses so much more. I think what it means to be a true prolife person is that you are prolife through ALL stages of life. Not just before birth. 

I believe prolife means we help the poor, we protect the planet etc. My prolife views dont stop after birth.

 

Neither do mine. Which is why I think it's so important that we ensure people get to live past their birth. If we can't even do that, what good is it?

KnightofChrist
Posted

You have every right to be skeptical. But 97% of scientists disagree with you. Which side do you want to error on?


I go by what I see, and I see many people in that movement repeatedly making claims that over time are shown to be false. And when I see so many claims that turn out to be false, it makes it harder to believe other predictions and claims by the same people.
Credo in Deum
Posted

We call climate change, climate change so then the issues do not get mixed and thus lost under some sweeping generalization.  The Pro-Life movement is specifically against abortion and to lump everything anti-human death under the title Pro-Life, would be to bury the current movements mission to fight abortion under a mound of schnitzel.  

Posted

We call climate change, climate change so then the issues do not get mixed and thus lost under some sweeping generalization.  The Pro-Life movement is specifically against abortion and to lump everything anti-human death under the title Pro-Life, would be to bury the current movements mission to fight abortion under a mound of schnitzel.  

 

I think that technically Pro-life as includes opposing euthanasia too.  However I agree with your main point.
 

Posted (edited)

I go by what I see, and I see many people in that movement repeatedly making claims that over time are shown to be false. And when I see so many claims that turn out to be false, it makes it harder to believe other predictions and claims by the same people.

 

Oh you go by what you see? Then you probably believe all this stuff....

 

47D7zGq.png

Correlation-VS-Causation.png

q54sO25.png

 

OfQYQW8.png

 

 

Also, please note that science is a well oiled machine. They do make mistakes but they test and test again. We learn just as much from disproved hypotheses as we do proven hypothesis. Science can observe things that are beyond the scope of our sense.

 

Do you understand why DNA is so important? Because what we see isnt always true. For example, analogous and homologous structures. Two things might look the same, but they are actually completely different...or two things might look different but they are actually share the same function.

 

So your argument that you only believe what you see is not something Id expect an educated person to say. Thats more of a cop out.

Edited by CrossCuT
KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

So your argument that you only believe what you see is not something Id expect an educated person to say. Thats more of a cop out.


Which is just another reason why I dislike and am critical of the climate change movement. Anyone who dares question that dogma has their eduction or intelligence insulted and is dismissed out of hand. I will begin to believe when climate change gets so bad that it effects the space time continuum and causes all those false predictions of the pass to become true. That or the current predictions are shown to be true, but many of them like the raising ocean levels have been recycled various times in my life time. So I will doubt until then. Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted

Well there isnt much to say in the face of willful ignorance. 

Credo in Deum
Posted

I never thought I would say this, but where has Hasan been lately?

Posted

I never thought I would say this, but where has Hasan been lately?

 

I had wondered if he'd make an appearance. My wishful thinking imagines he may be out of doors enjoying himself after leaving DC. :)

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I always just assume he has been suspended, but I did not notice any fun fights lately.

KnightofChrist
Posted

Well there isnt much to say in the face of willful ignorance.


It is not a matter of ignorance but complete lack of trust. I do not trust the leaders of the climate change movement. They lost my trust after relying on too many 'the sky is falling' predictions that turned out to be false. Which I now believe was done to cause fear, they used fear and falsehoods to scare people into supporting their cause. If you wish to place your trust in them that is your choice. I will not question your intelligence or education.
Posted

It is not a matter of ignorance but complete lack of trust. I do not trust the leaders of the climate change movement. They lost my trust after relying on too many 'the sky is falling' predictions that turned out to be false. Which I now believe was done to cause fear, they used fear and falsehoods to scare people into supporting their cause. If you wish to place your trust in them that is your choice. I will not question your intelligence or education.

 

Dont confuse the media with the scientists. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

Im not satisfied with sitting idle. 

 

*idly*

KnightofChrist
Posted

Dont confuse the media with the scientists.


The Media does make it worse by amplifying the gloom and doom predictions.
Posted

*idly*

 

The expression "sitting idle" is grammatically acceptable.  The word "sitting" acts as a copula verb and  therefore takes a predicate adjective.  We see a similar construction in the expression "sitting pretty".

 

Yes, I am easily distracted by grammar.  Why do you ask?
 

Credo in Deum
Posted

step0001.jpg

KnightofChrist
Posted

The expression "sitting idle" is grammatically acceptable.%  The word "sitting" acts as a copula verb and
%  therefore takes a predicate adjective.%  We see a similar construction in the expression "sitting pretty".
 
Yes, I am easily distracted by grammar.%  Why do you ask?

% = delete two-space error

 
 
Yes, I am easily distracted by typography.  :nerd: :nerd: :nerd: :nerd: :nerd: :nerd: :nerd:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...