Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

BeenaBobba
Posted

Hi everyone,

A few days ago or maybe even a week or so ago, I wrote that I've been in a long discussion about abortion and atheism at a forum run by a Liberal atheist. To the best of my knowledge, I've been polite and charitable, but they've accused me of being overbearing and have even used called me a certain swear word that begins with a "b." I've never really been accused of that by people, so I don't know if it's true or not. Can you please go take a look at our debates to see if I truly have been bad? A Christian there has said that she doesn't like what I've been doing, but I've simply just been making the case for Catholicism. You can find our debates under the "Why Atheism?" thread and the "The Atheism Debate: Pro and Contra" thread in the debate part of the "Religious Blend" section, and you can find the "Why I'm Against Abortion" thread in the debate part of the "Women's Issues" section. You can get to the forum [url="http://keebs.forumhoster.com//index.php?act=idx"]here[/url]. The discussion gets really bad from page six onward in the "Why Atheism?" debate, so if you read anything, that's where you should go.

I would really, really appreciate some input on this. If I'm acting wrongly, I'd really like to know. And I'd also like some advice as to whether I should just leave this forum.

Thanks so much, and God bless,

Jennifer

voiciblanche
Posted

Jen, you seem obnoxiously charitable. I've never known you to be anything but obnoxiously charitable. I didn't read every page of all the threads, but I don't agree with any of their accusations. I encourage you to pray about this situation, because you could be evangelizing by being there, or you could be just hurting yourself by hearing all of this. But as far as you being charitable, of course you are.

Posted

I agree with voici. I am praying Jen, a lot!

BeenaBobba
Posted

[quote name='voiciblanche' date='Jun 7 2004, 10:42 PM'] Jen, you seem obnoxiously charitable. I've never known you to be anything but obnoxiously charitable. I didn't read every page of all the threads, but I don't agree with any of their accusations. I encourage you to pray about this situation, because you could be evangelizing by being there, or you could be just hurting yourself by hearing all of this. But as far as you being charitable, of course you are. [/quote]
Thanks, VB, that means a lot to me. I'm pretty drained after that debate, and my feelings are kind of hurt. It's not fun having everyone gang up on you, as was the case there. But I will pray about whether I should leave or not. Part of me wants to stay despite their accusations because I want to speak for the Truth, and to show them that there are people out there who hold to something just as strongly as they do. The Sermon on the Mount came to mind while I was over there debating, but the Christian girl who doesn't agree with me implied that I wasn't expressing my points with gentleness and with respect. (The atheists said that I've pushed them even further from religion.) But part of my thinks I'm wasting the time I could be using dialoging with non-Catholics who actually respect me and are willing to interact with my arguments.

God bless,

Jennifer

voiciblanche
Posted

If you would like, I can join that forum if you're going to stay. I can help you promote the Truth, and perhaps you might not feel as ganged-up on. I'm here for you. :wub: :)

BeenaBobba
Posted

[quote name='voiciblanche' date='Jun 7 2004, 10:51 PM'] If you would like, I can join that forum if you're going to stay. I can help you promote the Truth, and perhaps you might not feel as ganged-up on. I'm here for you. :wub: :) [/quote]
That would be awesome, voici! You'd have no idea how much that'd mean to me, but please don't feel obliged. :)

God bless,

Jennifer

voiciblanche
Posted

I'd be happy to do it. I'm going to finish reading these threads tonight and join tonight. I'm going to pray about it, too, tonight, and we'll see how we both feel about it tomorrow. :)

Posted

Jennifer if you want I will join too with voici. Don't know if I will be of much help to you, but I'm here.:)

BeenaBobba
Posted

[quote name='VeraMaria' date='Jun 7 2004, 11:00 PM'] Jennifer if you want I will join too with voici. Don't know if I will be of much help to you, but I'm here.:) [/quote]
Hi Vera,

If you wanted to join (please don't feel pressured to do so), that would be great! You and voici have been incredibly nice to suggest doing so. :)

God bless,

Jen

BeenaBobba
Posted

Hi voici,

I forgot to tell you this before, but you have to be over 13 to join without parental permission. I'm not sure how old you are now, but I thought I remember you saying that you're 12.

God bless,

Jen

voiciblanche
Posted

:ph34r:


They don't know that. Shhh.

BeenaBobba
Posted

[quote name='voiciblanche' date='Jun 8 2004, 02:01 AM'] :ph34r:


They don't know that. Shhh. [/quote]
Haha. I won't tell. But, honestly, honesty is the best policy. I don't want you to have to lie to help me out, so don't post till your 13. :) (You're a doll for wanting to help me out, though.)

God bless,

Jen

P.S. When will you be turning 13? :P

voiciblanche
Posted

August. But come on. These people are nuts. You need help, man. And it's just two months. I'll be okay.

voiciblanche
Posted

Bumpage. Answer, Jen, lol.

BeenaBobba
Posted

[quote name='voiciblanche' date='Jun 8 2004, 02:49 AM'] August. But come on. These people are nuts. You need help, man. And it's just two months. I'll be okay. [/quote]
Well, you certainly act much older than your age. You're probably the smartest 12-year-old that I've ever known. :) But, if it's a sin for you to post there, I wouldn't want you to do it. If it wasn't a sin, then by all means post! (It seems kind of sinful to me, though, but maybe others can add their $.02 here on what they think.)

Did you read the "Why Atheism?" thread? If so, what did you think?

God bless,

Jen

P.S. I'm not trying to be a nag or anything. I just wouldn't want you to sin on my account.

voiciblanche
Posted

As far as sinning - I don't consider it sinning. I think God wants me to help you and defend Him, and I don't think two months matter much in this instance.

The "Why Atheism?" thread - I've been reading for like three hours, and I'm only one page eight. It's crazy. But I've already got some comments down, which I will post when I get to the end. At like three in the morning, lol.

Mickey's_Girl
Posted

[quote name='BeenaBobba' date='Jun 7 2004, 08:47 PM'] but the Christian girl who doesn't agree with me implied that I wasn't expressing my points with gentleness and with respect. (The atheists said that I've pushed them even further from religion.) But part of my thinks I'm wasting the time I could be using dialoging with non-Catholics who actually respect me and are willing to interact with my arguments.
[/quote]
LIKE ME!!!! I respect you immensely!

:wub: to Jen!

I didn't bother to go read the thread; I get enough drama here on Phatmass. :rolling: But Jen, you are EXTREMELY charitable, so clearly these people must be mistaken. :) Maybe they were just having a BAD DAY.

MG

voiciblanche
Posted

By the way, Jen, I didn't realize you'd just made like ten of the pages of that thread TODAY! I was like, whoa.

crusader1234
Posted

[quote]P.S. I'm not trying to be a nag or anything. I just wouldn't want you to sin on my account. [/quote]

Obnoxiously Charitable is right - I dont think that this is a sin... especially not mortal. Lying about yuor age couldnt be a sin our everyones Grandmothers would go to hell! :unsure:

Haha, you should make a post entitled "HELP ME FIGHT ATHEISTS ON A FORUM" then you'd get lots of volunteers. I could help, but when it comes to debates, I tend to find that no matter which side he is on, PSPX is definaetly one of the more interesting posters.

:peace: -rich

voiciblanche
Posted

Oh my gosh. I wrote like a big, heartfelt response to all that stuff and SHE CLOSED IT. Arrgh.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...