Nihil Obstat Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 (edited) Just curious if this is an area of disagreement between some Catholics. Answer and discuss however you see fit. I hope that those who answer yes will make some comment regarding what entities they have in mind, at least in a general sense. Edited May 31, 2014 by Nihil Obstat
chrysostom Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 The readiest example of an individual enemy of the Church is Saul, who persecuted Jesus by persecuting His members.
PhuturePriest Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 I'm baffled by anyone who says otherwise. I have never heard of a Saint or Church document that says there do not exist enemies of the Church outside of Satan.
Fidei Defensor Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 I've generally felt that with the Church, it follows the same logic that Christ used — if they aren't with him, they're against him.
Nihil Obstat Posted May 31, 2014 Author Posted May 31, 2014 These are the answers I was hoping for. Cool, cool. So... let us make this more fun then. NEW QUESTION!!! Do the following groups count as enemies of the Church?: Freemasonry? The Communist movement? The Secularist movement? The American government - as an institution taken as a whole? Add your own too. I just named a few groups that came to mind as possibilities.
Spem in alium Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 These are the answers I was hoping for. Cool, cool. So... let us make this more fun then. NEW QUESTION!!! Do the following groups count as enemies of the Church?: Freemasonry? The Communist movement? The Secularist movement? The American government - as an institution taken as a whole? Add your own too. I just named a few groups that came to mind as possibilities. "Enemy" is a strong word and not one I lightly use, but in terms of Freemasonry I'm more inclined to say yes than no. Socialist groups I've seen in my own country also strongly go against the Church, so they could also be considered an "enemy". I can't comment much on the American government.
PhuturePriest Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 These are the answers I was hoping for. Cool, cool. So... let us make this more fun then. NEW QUESTION!!! Do the following groups count as enemies of the Church?: Freemasonry? The Communist movement? The Secularist movement? The American government - as an institution taken as a whole? Add your own too. I just named a few groups that came to mind as possibilities. I don't think most modern-day Freemasons are enemies of the Church, mostly because they don't realize how anti-Catholic Freemasonry is. My dad has a friend who is a Freemason, and he is very friendly towards Catholics, and would probably be repulsed at the anti-Catholicism Freemasonry teaches. However, I do think the organization at least in belief is anti-Catholic and thus an enemy of the Church, regardless of how the people themselves feel about the matter. Communism is and has always been hostile to Catholicism. In Communist Bavaria (at least I think it was Bavaria), priests were tortured and starved, and were forced to stand upright and sleep only 1 hour a day in small cells, to the point where most lost their minds. That screams pretty "enemy of the Church" to me. Secularism is opposed to Catholic teaching and many secularists are virulently anti-Catholic. The American government isn't inherently anti-Catholic, I don't think. It's definitely going higher and higher on the list, though.
Nihil Obstat Posted May 31, 2014 Author Posted May 31, 2014 Proposition: the American government as an institution is formally at odds with fundamental teachings of the Church. Anyone want to play with that one?
Nihil Obstat Posted May 31, 2014 Author Posted May 31, 2014 I think it could reasonably be argued that the government of the United States is formally secularist. If secularism is inimical to the Church, then apply transitive property and.......
picchick Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 People who openly attack the Church morals (agreed on the pro-abortion movement) are enemies of the Church
Credo in Deum Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 The best way to find a horrible enemy of the Church is to do an examination of conscience and then grab a mirror.
picchick Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 The best way to find a horrible enemy of the Church is to do an examination of conscience and then grab a mirror. Disagree. en·e·my noun \ˈe-nə-mē\ : someone who hates another : someone who attacks or tries to harm another : something that harms or threatens someone or something : a group of people (such as a nation) against whom another group is fighting a war How is sinning hateful of the Church? How is it an attack on the Church?
CatherineM Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 I've been called a whore of Babylon and a idol worshiper. So yeah, I think we have enemies.
Perigrina Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 Proposition: the American government as an institution is formally at odds with fundamental teachings of the Church. Anyone want to play with that one? I do not feel qualified to answer this about a country not my own, but, if you substitute in Canada, I'll give you a "yes" response.
brandelynmarie Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 I'm even wondering about the UN now, especially most recently after they asked the Church to change Its moral teachings on abortion :think:
Credo in Deum Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 Disagree. en·e·my noun \ˈe-nə-mē\ : someone who hates another : someone who attacks or tries to harm another. : something that harms or threatens someone or something : a group of people (such as a nation) against whom another group is fighting a war How is sinning hateful of the Church? How is it an attack on the Church? : someone who hates another : someone who attacks or tries to harm another. Christ says if we love Him then we will keep His commandments. When we sin, especially mortal sin, how are we loving Christ? If we are not loving Christ than how can we be said to love the Church when it is Christ's mystical body? Are you saying Christ and the Church are separate? Also as Christ said"He who is not with Me, is against Me". Sin opposes God and is the real enemy of the Church. : something that harms or threatens someone or something: Sin harms everyone as Adam and Eve have proven to us. Sins by professed Catholics harm the Church more than the actions of outsiders. When commenting on the sex abuse caused by priests Pope Benedict XVI stated: ""Today we see in a truly terrifying way that the greatest persecution of the Church does not come from enemies on the outside, but is born of the sin within the Church," Out of all of the people who persecuted Christ during His passion, which one do you think hurt His Sacred Heart the most? Do you think it was the Pharisees, Romans, Pagans, etc? Or, do you think it was His apostle, Judas?
Maggyie Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 Nihil, I'll bite. I don't think that's the case. I don't think secularism is necessarily an enemy of the church, either. To be an enemy implies active hostility. When boiled down to its foundation, I don't think the government is hostile to the church, just indifferent. And unhelpful.
Nihil Obstat Posted May 31, 2014 Author Posted May 31, 2014 Nihil, I'll bite. I don't think that's the case. I don't think secularism is necessarily an enemy of the church, either. To be an enemy implies active hostility. When boiled down to its foundation, I don't think the government is hostile to the church, just indifferent. And unhelpful. With regards to secularism specifically, what about previous condemnations of the popes? They usually attack secularism in the harshest possible terms, as being directly against the social reign of Christ the King.
Perigrina Posted May 31, 2014 Posted May 31, 2014 Nihil, I'll bite. I don't think that's the case. I don't think secularism is necessarily an enemy of the church, either. To be an enemy implies active hostility. When boiled down to its foundation, I don't think the government is hostile to the church, just indifferent. And unhelpful. I think that it is a matter of hostility when it comes to individuals, but of opposition to Church teaching when it comes to institutions or ideologies.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now