Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Lol the other day I was talking to someone about this. We didn't know why they hadn't had heated roads yet. Figured it had to be in the making somewhere.

 

Is the traction better/worse than asphalt though?

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

I have no idea. It's a cool idea but something smells fishy.

Posted

Might work better for parking lots.

Posted

Might work better for parking lots.

 

I know heated driveways are a thing now.

fides' Jack
Posted

I read all about this.  It's actually a brilliant idea.  And from what I understand, the traction is better than you would get with asphalt (http://www.solarroadways.com/faq.shtml#faqTraction).

 

Like so many other projects, this has huge potential but requires serious investor/government financial support.  I can't even imagine how much it would cost to convert a major roadway to this technology.  

Posted

Very interesting. I've been in roadwork / intelligent highways for decades and can imagine the hurdles they have to overcome. Accommodating rain is a huge issue. High speed roads are semi permeable. Handling large volumes of water in the design is huge, while also maintaining traction..... Protecting the system from lightning, storing the power generated. That is the Achilles heel of large scale solar power production.

blazeingstar
Posted

That looks like it would be great in flat, hot cities, and not something that would work well in say, Seattle, where it rains alot, or Maine where it's all mountains.

 

We can't even keep asfault nice...I don't see how we'd ever manage to keep solar pannels safe.

Posted

I read an article about this a few months back and I LOVE LOVE LOVE the idea! Might need a little more time to work out some additional kinks but I think its fantastic! 

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

Cool! Maybe we can have a discussion on this. Since I get all of my information from youtube videos, I've saved you all the trouble by posting it directly:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H901KdXgHs4

 

If it's too long, just watch the first 10 minutes. 

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

I'm pretty sure the tech is perfectly real, but they haven't had the opportunity to test it large-scale. These kinds of applications usually look extremely promising on the electronics test-bench and then have some kind of problem when they're installed. For solar that can include power storage and the fact that they usually require regular cleaning in order to maintain their rated efficiencies, which is hard enough when they aren't installed in a road.

 

That said, you can't learn to overcome that without trying it out and seeing what works and what doesn't. I hope they do it. :)

Edited by arfink
Posted

I hope they get the opportunity to test this large scale. 

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

My feeble attempt to throw this into the debate table hasn't worked yet. I'll bring up some unoriginal concerns I have with this project:

1. Covering all of our roads with this stuff will costs trillions and trillions of dollars.
2. Solar panels might work better on the side of roads instead of under them. That way they can move around to match the position of the sun instead of laying flat.
3. If the LEDs are built into the panels, won't it be needlessly costly to replace a few broken bulbs?
4. LEDs can't be seen in sunlight, meaning they'll be only useful as lane dividers at night.
5. You need a bunch of energy to melt snow. They made it seem way too easy in their videos.

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

My feeble attempt to throw this into the debate table hasn't worked yet. I'll bring up some unoriginal concerns I have with this project:

1. Covering all of our roads with this stuff will costs trillions and trillions of dollars.
2. Solar panels might work better on the side of roads instead of under them. That way they can move around to match the position of the sun instead of laying flat.
3. If the LEDs are built into the panels, won't it be needlessly costly to replace a few broken bulbs?
4. LEDs can't be seen in sunlight, meaning they'll be only useful as lane dividers at night.
5. You need a bunch of energy to melt snow. They made it seem way too easy in their videos.

1 It's awful expensive to build roads anyway, the bulk of the cost is the drainage and roadbed structure. Benifits of power production could easily outweigh the cost of the panels themselves.
2 solar panels are still productive, though not optimally in a flat orientation. Most panels are fixed orientation because cost to mobilize isn't offset by inreased power generation.
3 current LEDs have incredible life, I wouldn't think it is a big issue
4 current LEDs are day visible. Most traffic signals are LeD and you see them every day.
5 I have no concept of melting snow.
CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

1 It's awful expensive to build roads anyway, the bulk of the cost is the drainage and roadbed structure. Benifits of power production could easily outweigh the cost of the panels themselves.
2 solar panels are still productive, though not optimally in a flat orientation. Most panels are fixed orientation because cost to mobilize isn't offset by inreased power generation.
3 current LEDs have incredible life, I wouldn't think it is a big issue
4 current LEDs are day visible. Most traffic signals are LeD and you see them every day.
5 I have no concept of melting snow.

 

1. Asphalt still seems much cheaper than the materials used in solar roadways. I think we could get more benefits by putting the solar panels on our houses instead.

2. But are we sure that the cost of using solar roadways to power the country will be offset by increased power generation? It's a good idea but do we actually know how much power we'll be getting out of this? 

3. Good point. It all would depend on how study the roads are and whether the LEDs could get damaged in some way. 

4. Yes, but we see them because they have a cover over them. The traffic lights without those covers are very hard to see. Paint seems like a better option imo.

5. You've never tried it? It's loads of fun. 

Posted

1. The idea is that we are using greener energy, we will be able to produce so much power from the solar energy that it would be extremely cost effective.

2. I dont see how having them on the sides would better...they would get more direct sunlight by being on the actual road unless Im misunderstanding you.

3. The panels are set up in a patch work pattern so that you can remove individual ones to replace bulbs if needed.

4. I have no doubt that they can add a color strip to the panels that would serve as dividers so you can see the lines during the day.

5. Snow is evil

Posted (edited)

1. Asphalt still seems much cheaper than the materials used in solar roadways. I think we could get more benefits by putting the solar panels on our houses instead.
2. But are we sure that the cost of using solar roadways to power the country will be offset by increased power generation? It's a good idea but do we actually know how much power we'll be getting out of this?
3. Good point. It all would depend on how study the roads are and whether the LEDs could get damaged in some way.
4. Yes, but we see them because they have a cover over them. The traffic lights without those covers are very hard to see. Paint seems like a better option imo.
5. You've never tried it? It's loads of fun.

1 Further research required to determine costs. Don't forget, asphalt includes petroleum. It is cheaper but studies of installation and maintenance over product life is required. There may be specific applications that cost differential is less. I'd still call it currently unproven but realistically feasible in theory.
2 I'd still call it currently unproven but realistically feasible in theory.
3 current LEDs are essentially a chip. Not easily damaged by vibration. System design would probably be modular to facilitate repair for any roadway
4 cover and color(Kelvin) in signals actually REDUCE the luminosity and viewability. current generation design is incredible. Paint (actually thermoplastic with glass beads dropped on top) have a short service life for view ability in low light situations. It's dependent solely on reflecting ambient light. Any system that generates light would be superior.
5. No snow in Tampa since 1977. Edited by Anomaly
blazeingstar
Posted

None of this solves the problem at all of hilly, rainy places.  Solar panels need sun, parts of America.  Buffalo NY has 4.4 days annually of cloud-free skies and well over 200 cloudy days.  North-facing hills sometimes have snow well into May or even June, even when it stops snowing in early May.

 

 

Posted

None of this solves the problem at all of hilly, rainy places. Solar panels need sun, parts of America. Buffalo NY has 4.4 days annually of cloud-free skies and well over 200 cloudy days. North-facing hills sometimes have snow well into May or even June, even when it stops snowing in early May.

not as big an issue as you think. Insolation rating (avg yearly) in Buffalo is 3.16 vs Atlanta 4.67. There would be consideration oh some specific terrain, but roads are naturally mild grade and well exposed.
I think the biggest hurdle is efficient power storage. If connected to the grid, it could replace some traditional power generation during daylight, but then roads would need power at night.
blazeingstar
Posted

not as big an issue as you think. Insolation rating (avg yearly) in Buffalo is 3.16 vs Atlanta 4.67. There would be consideration oh some specific terrain, but roads are naturally mild grade and well exposed.
I think the biggest hurdle is efficient power storage. If connected to the grid, it could replace some traditional power generation during daylight, but then roads would need power at night.

 

Which would probably burn more energy in the winter....as some days in the northeast we barley have 8 hours of light....er cloud

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...