Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Somebody used the expression "spirit of Vatican II" in a positive way the other day and I found it jarring.  To me the phrase has a negative meaning. This got me wondering what this phrase means to other people.

 

What do you think when you come across the  phrase "spirit of Vatican II"?

Posted

like you experienced, it would depend on the context... most words do.

Posted

Somebody used the expression "spirit of Vatican II" in a positive way the other day and I found it jarring.  To me the phrase has a negative meaning. This got me wondering what this phrase means to other people.
 
What do you think when you come across the  phrase "spirit of Vatican II"?

 
 
Perhaps you could explain what kind of negative meaning the phrase has for you?
 
This sounds pretty positive to me:
 
On 25 July 1967, pope Paul VI says in a sermon to the Catholics of Istanbul at the Cathedral of the Holy Spirit:

The recent Vatican Council reminded us that this progress is based first of all on the renovation of the Church and on the conversion of the heart. This means that you will contribute to this progress toward unity in the measure in which you enter into the spirit of the council. An effort is demanded from each of us to revise our customary ways of thinking and acting to bring them more in conformity with the Gospel and the demands of a true Christian Brotherhood

KnightofChrist
Posted

The term "spirit of Vatican II" has often been used to pervert and or twist the texts of Vatican II. As Pope Benedict XVI explained in an address to the Roman Curia Thursday, 22 December 2005
 

The hermeneutic of discontinuity risks ending in a split between the pre-conciliar Church and the post-conciliar Church. It asserts that the texts of the Council as such do not yet express the true spirit of the Council. It claims that they are the result of compromises in which, to reach unanimity, it was found necessary to keep and reconfirm many old things that are now pointless. However, the true spirit of the Council is not to be found in these compromises but instead in the impulses toward the new that are contained in the texts.

These innovations alone were supposed to represent the true spirit of the Council, and starting from and in conformity with them, it would be possible to move ahead. Precisely because the texts would only imperfectly reflect the true spirit of the Council and its newness, it would be necessary to go courageously beyond the texts and make room for the newness in which the Council's deepest intention would be expressed, even if it were still vague.

In a word: it would be necessary not to follow the texts of the Council but its spirit. In this way, obviously, a vast margin was left open for the question on how this spirit should subsequently be defined and room was consequently made for every whim.

 

 

Lilllabettt
Posted

"spirit of Vatican II" is for many a code word for what they feel is church sanctioned rupture from previous observance. 

people who approve of that sort of thing use the phrase in a positive way, people with less sanguine view use it derisively. 

this is all quite apart from the original meaning.

I'm surprised if this is news to anybody here. 

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Well, that would depend on if they're taking about the true spirit and intention of the council or using it in a derisive or even snarky way to talk about how people use the council as an opportunity to do whatever they want, or misinterpret the intentions of the council.

Posted

 
 
Perhaps you could explain what kind of negative meaning the phrase has for you?
 
This sounds pretty positive to me:
 
On 25 July 1967, pope Paul VI says in a sermon to the Catholics of Istanbul at the Cathedral of the Holy Spirit:

The recent Vatican Council reminded us that this progress is based first of all on the renovation of the Church and on the conversion of the heart. This means that you will contribute to this progress toward unity in the measure in which you enter into the spirit of the council. An effort is demanded from each of us to revise our customary ways of thinking and acting to bring them more in conformity with the Gospel and the demands of a true Christian Brotherhood

 

I'm sure that Pope Paul VI meant something good by the word.  Unfortunately, I most often encounter it as a justification for practices that were not called for by the Council.  

Catherine Therese
Posted (edited)

I vote we claim it back.

Why let agenda-driven malcontents hijack an expression that is part of the heritage left by the Council Fathers?

Edited by Catherine Therese
Credo in Deum
Posted

 

 

What do you think when you come across the  phrase "spirit of Vatican II"?

AG00526_1.gif

Posted

KnightofChrist gave a quote from Pope Benedict that included:

 

The hermeneutic of discontinuity risks ending in a split between the pre-conciliar Church and the post-conciliar Church. It asserts that the texts of the Council as such do not yet express the true spirit of the Council. It claims that they are the result of compromises in which, to reach unanimity, it was found necessary to keep and reconfirm many old things that are now pointless. However, the true spirit of the Council is not to be found in these compromises but instead in the impulses toward the new that are contained in the texts.

 

 I was at a talk recently where the speaker did exactly that.  This woman is a theology professor who was brought in for a Lenten series of talks on Vatican II.  She was up there telling people how the Council said things it did not say and when challenged she came up with the "well that was because of compromise and this is what it really meant" line. So this kind of thinking is still being spread, in spite of Pope Benedict so clearly identifying it as wrong. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

 
 
Perhaps you could explain what kind of negative meaning the phrase has for you?
 
This sounds pretty positive to me:
 
On 25 July 1967, pope Paul VI says in a sermon to the Catholics of Istanbul at the Cathedral of the Holy Spirit:

The recent Vatican Council reminded us that this progress is based first of all on the renovation of the Church and on the conversion of the heart. This means that you will contribute to this progress toward unity in the measure in which you enter into the spirit of the council. An effort is demanded from each of us to revise our customary ways of thinking and acting to bring them more in conformity with the Gospel and the demands of a true Christian Brotherhood

Pope Paul was in an interesting position in the time after the council. He himself did recognize that the Church was in crisis, and he spoke frequently about the need for renewal and greater faithfulness. Yet at the same time, literally simultaneously, he would claim that the "spirit of Vatican II" was an astounding success which was leading the Church to Her greatest renaissance. It seemed sometimes that Pope Paul was unable to understand (or perhaps unwilling) that the "Spirit" of the Council that was allowed to run unchecked was directly connected to the frightening state of the Church at that time.

Posted

I vote we claim it back.

Why let agenda-driven malcontents hijack an expression that is part of the heritage left by the Council Fathers?

 

What is the true spirit of Vatican II?

Credo in Deum
Posted

Who knows?  IMO the true spirit of Vatican II has yet to be revealed and probably wont be until we have another council to clear up this mess. 

 

 

maximillion
Posted

I am afraid I hold a rather negative, if personal view. 

 

Sisters in my community used VII as an excuse to throw the baby out with the bath water in the 'spirit of renewal' they spouted about all the time in chapter.

 

It took distance from them, and sadly from the community before I read the documents for myself in a spirit of humility and came to my own conclusions.

 

It is my contention that those who want to will use anything to prop their own agenda, if it is VII then so be it.......

Lilllabettt
Posted

well even the Devil himself can quote scripture for his purposes

Posted

Pope Paul was in an interesting position in the time after the council. He himself did recognize that the Church was in crisis, and he spoke frequently about the need for renewal and greater faithfulness. Yet at the same time, literally simultaneously, he would claim that the "spirit of Vatican II" was an astounding success which was leading the Church to Her greatest renaissance. It seemed sometimes that Pope Paul was unable to understand (or perhaps unwilling) that the "Spirit" of the Council that was allowed to run unchecked was directly connected to the frightening state of the Church at that time.

 

The same address to the Curia that was already quoted talks about this.  Pope Benedict said that when the Council was genuinely implemented there was success, but that the rupture of the so-called "spirit of Vatican II" caused problems.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

The same address to the Curia that was already quoted talks about this.  Pope Benedict said that when the Council was genuinely implemented there was success, but that the rupture of the so-called "spirit of Vatican II" caused problems.

I agree in principle. The trouble that I see is in finding out what came from the Council which was authentically Catholic and those parts which were not. The problem with the "Spirit of Vatican II", is that those people who were behind it were also, in most cases, involved in drafting the actual documents of the Council. As you know, in a lot of cases they worked very hard to leave their mark in the documents themselves. Subtle sometimes, often in ways that can be interpreted ambiguously, but their influence was in there nonetheless.

So in finding a genuine interpretation of the Council, in many cases we have to look deeper than simply where things went off the rails afterwards. We have to look as well at how some people were working well before and during the Council to justify that spirit of rupture that you noted.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

I pray for unity of our Holy Mother Church :amen:

Posted

I agree in principle. The trouble that I see is in finding out what came from the Council which was authentically Catholic and those parts which were not. The problem with the "Spirit of Vatican II", is that those people who were behind it were also, in most cases, involved in drafting the actual documents of the Council. As you know, in a lot of cases they worked very hard to leave their mark in the documents themselves. Subtle sometimes, often in ways that can be interpreted ambiguously, but their influence was in there nonetheless.

So in finding a genuine interpretation of the Council, in many cases we have to look deeper than simply where things went off the rails afterwards. We have to look as well at how some people were working well before and during the Council to justify that spirit of rupture that you noted.

 

I think the rule of thumb for genuine interpretation of the Council is look at what the post-conciliar popes have said.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I think the rule of thumb for genuine interpretation of the Council is look at what the post-conciliar popes have said.

I agree that it is valuable to do that. I am not sure it is sufficient though. I mean, Pope Paul and Pope John Paul especially were very much invested in the whole post-VII milieu. I certainly do not hold this against them, but to a certain extent I do not think they always give us an objective analysis. They tend, IMO, to be optimistic even to an excessive degree when it comes to the results of the Council.

I do not say they are wrong in general, but I think their perspective, influenced as it was by their participation in the Council, gives us only part of the answer.

So my reply is rather prosaic in a sense. Rather than the rule of thumb for interpretation being merely what post-conciliar popes have said, I think the rule for interpretation must always be what the popes and documents said, interpreted always in light of what came before.

But I do not mean to imply that you are saying that post conciliar popes are the be all and end all of Catholicism, obviously. I know you do not think that. I simply think that even when it comes to the Council itself, in most cases it is necessary for the entire Church throughout history to speak, rather than merely the Church from 1969 to the present.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...