chrysostom Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 Must be doing something right... Wait, really? I was just about to write the Bishop about the slobbering, pudgy, too-cute-for-Mass liturgical abuse. [spoiler]jk[/spoiler]
truthfinder Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 We once had a just about entirely silent Low Mass - priest had lost his voice so everything was whispered and they don't use a mic. Only heard the homily. Probably one of the nicest Masses, not for every Sunday, but a nice respite after Easter.
superblue Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 At my Cathedral I attend on occasion, we had for one year, a really great choir, young an old mixed in, and it was amazing, everyone sounded so professional, it was great, then some scholar had the idea to start a " contemporary choir " electric guitars, electric drums, and players who felt it necessary to hold a rift of a note for an extended period of time after each song, on the flip side of that, that contemporary choir some how got the word out where they were playing, and the cathedral saw a temporary spike in attendance during their " performance ", not to mention everyone sticks around now to give a round of applause to the choir once the Priest has proceeded out of the church. I try to give people the benefit of the doubt that they are trying to do good for the mass but when the singing is so off key, or there are songs like " our God is an Awesome God " I am like, I don't remember that being a psalm to be sung at any point in the mass either after communion or before. And if a bishop is only giving a suggestion about a silent mass, an no one takes him up on that suggestion it says a lot about those parishes who ignore the suggestion and about the bishop as well ( now if that is a negative connotation on either I don't know but I think it says something ) I personally wont complain to anyone about such things in my parish or at the Cathedral as, I cant do any better, so I don't feel that since I cant bring a better solution to the table or at least sing, then why bother, but venting online is always some relief. I wouldn't mind a real silent mass at my Cathedral or my usual Parish, where people are actually quiet ( not whispering , which for the elderly, they have a tendency to whisper like a 5 yr old, they think it is a soft whisper but it is really a loud one. ) Before, During, and After mass, to allow people the opportunity to actually pray. So while the music is a good topic for debate, it is the least of my complaints, the only time I really get to pray in silence any more is in adoration. I am starting to see the need for a bigger visible banner that reads, either something sarcastic, or something like, others are trying to pray , go out side to have a conversation. We literally have small placards at the entrances ( a bit hard to see if you are not looking for it ) it reads, Quiet please , to no avail. Now to be fair I haven't tried all the parishes in my town, and I have no idea if there is a latin mass in my area, which I have heard are a lot more reverent , but in the end, I guess the main goal is to pack people in the pews, any way possible, so if it means a contemporary choir with electric everything and songs that have nothing to do with the mass, or a really horrible clique version of the Gloria to be sung, to allowing people to have social conversations before during and after mass, phones included, then so be it, I guess it is becoming more of pack em in, get the money, and hope that you reach a few in the long run. Reverence takes a back seat, while the last bit remaining is in the clergy at the alter.
brandelynmarie Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 The weekday Masses in my parish are usually "silent". Love them :love:.
Catherine Therese Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 Pretty sure the GIRM requires the mass parts to be sung at minimum. So while it's ok not to have additional hymns, the mass parts should be sung, and I'd be surprised to hear of a bishop implementing anything at odds with the GIRM.
franciscanheart Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 Pretty sure the GIRM requires the mass parts to be sung at minimum. So while it's ok not to have additional hymns, the mass parts should be sung, and I'd be surprised to hear of a bishop implementing anything at odds with the GIRM. There are a few parts that are chanted, but there's no music and no proper chant. I think we sing two or three things, tops.
maximillion Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 Early morning. Silent. Slowly spoken. Long thanksgiving. Mass. Best thing since sliced bread.
marigold Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 Can someone explain this whole deal of optional bits, hymns vs no hymns, personal preference etc.? Genuine question. If some bits aren't Necessary then why have them at all? In my wandering teens I went to a very early Mass which sounds like one of these silent ones. It was a really ... good experience, and I did come away with a sense of reverence and appreciation. I also read a book, I think it was called The Meaning of the Mass, that explained the different parts of the liturgy and I think also talked about what parts are absolutely necessary for the Mass to be valid. It's a different mindset which is why I'm interested to know what you guys know and can explain to me.
cappie Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 Those wailing babies are hopefully future catholics, I'd prefer crying babies to any of the music at the cathedral an other parish I attend. If those wailing babies are baptised they are Catholics now :hehe2:
cappie Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 There are some people in the world who would die to attend Mass, we should be thankful for Mass
Benedictus Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 Can someone explain this whole deal of optional bits, hymns vs no hymns, personal preference etc.? Genuine question. If some bits aren't Necessary then why have them at all? In my wandering teens I went to a very early Mass which sounds like one of these silent ones. It was a really ... good experience, and I did come away with a sense of reverence and appreciation. I also read a book, I think it was called The Meaning of the Mass, that explained the different parts of the liturgy and I think also talked about what parts are absolutely necessary for the Mass to be valid. It's a different mindset which is why I'm interested to know what you guys know and can explain to me. The prescribed words and structure of the liturgy is set. The church gives some variation options on certain prayers, so they fit the season and the occasion. These are outlined in the liturgical norms. As far as I'm aware there is no scope to go outside these norms unless there is an agreed exception somehow, such as use of a different rite. The questions of 'validity' relates to the consecration of the hosts. This event would have to be done correctly (and by a valid priest) as part of the mass, otherwise it would simply be a service of the word (which isn't the norm in Catholic parishes). The entrance antiphon, psalams and readings change at each service. Beyond that the variations are mostly around music, degree of simplicity and style. There isn't any need for hymns or instrumental music. But priests etc can decide on something that's fitting, and this will vary from place to place.
fides' Jack Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 Dust - thanks for bringing this up! I wish 1000 times that I was at your parish. We don't have (as far as I know) a single parish in our diocese which offers any kind of "silent" Mass. A week and a half ago, before Mass the choir director got on the mic and said that since so few people have volunteered to sing, part of the Mass would be a cappella, and part would be silent. I was SOOO overjoyed to hear that. Unfortunately, their idea of a cappella was apparently some kid on an electric guitar trying his 2nd or 3rd practice to the tune of a well-known hymn, but he started messing up and ended up ad libbing completely. This was during Communion. I was distracted just having to hear a solo electric guitar, but I became angry enough with the direction that it took that I didn't receive Communion. I didn't even notice the silent part, which was only during the collection before the offertory. Normally I just try to ignore all music during Mass anymore, because I'm so tired of it. I can understand the whole idea of trying to keep people interested who would have no patience for silence or traditional chant or hymns - but I think my diocese has completely given up on those of us who are a bit more traditional leaning in our taste for reverence in music/art/architecture/etc... And this is in 1 out of 2 dioceses (the other being Lincoln) whose bishop spoke out supporting Church morals during a fiasco in the U.S. shortly after the scandal a decade ago. We're not a terribly liberal diocese. We desparately, DESPERATELY need a solution like that. Pretty sure the GIRM requires the mass parts to be sung at minimum. So while it's ok not to have additional hymns, the mass parts should be sung, and I'd be surprised to hear of a bishop implementing anything at odds with the GIRM. There is no part of the Mass that has required singing. 'Strongly encouraged' would be a more accurate term. But then, so is chant, and the organ, and not using extraordinary ministers, etc...
Clare Brigid Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 Dust - thanks for bringing this up! I wish 1000 times that I was at your parish. We don't have (as far as I know) a single parish in our diocese which offers any kind of "silent" Mass. A good strategy, at least for finding a quieter Mass, is to attend the earliest Sunday morning Mass available to you. There is usually no music and no cast of thousands.
dUSt Posted July 30, 2014 Author Posted July 30, 2014 I think there is a huge need for quality control in the Church. Presentation matters. Beautiful architecture matters. Quality music matters. If some of these parishes with money would not consider using amateur high school art to decorate their churches, or use a Jr High student's stained glass project to put in the windows behind the altar, why do they think it is acceptable to allow a teenager to play riffs he learned on Guitar Hero during mass? Churches are built in stages--beautiful stained glass may come later in the budget. Stations of the cross sculptures may be a few years away. They don't put up temporary cardboard displays in the meantime--they simply do without until they can get something worthy to put in a church. Why not with music?
Nihil Obstat Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 I think there is a huge need for quality control in the Church. Presentation matters. Beautiful architecture matters. Quality music matters. If some of these parishes with money would not consider using amateur high school art to decorate their churches, or use a Jr High student's stained glass project to put in the windows behind the altar, why do they think it is acceptable to allow a teenager to play riffs he learned on Guitar Hero during mass? Churches are built in stages--beautiful stained glass may come later in the budget. Stations of the cross sculptures may be a few years away. They don't put up temporary cardboard displays in the meantime--they simply do without until they can get something worthy to put in a church. Why not with music? It is because there is no recognition that there does exist an objective standard by which we evaluate our Liturgy. There is this perception that anything goes as long as it is meaningful - and who knows whose definition of meaningful we are using. But that is a mistake because we, as Roman Catholics, do have an objective standard, and that is the Roman Rite itself, as an integrated whole. The Roman Rite is a rite of the Church, and it is characteristically Roman. It seems redundant to say it, but I do not think enough people understand what this means. As a rite, it shares certain universal characteristics with all of the liturgies of the Catholic Church. Being Roman, it has certain features that identify it as such. Felt banners and junk music match neither the characteristics of a Catholic rite, nor the characteristics of the Roman rites. Same goes for the countless aberrations that have arisen as a result of abuses. If they are not Roman, and if they do not match the characteristics of Catholic rites, then they do not belong in our Masses, period. So you are completely right. A student's stained glass project is not appropriate for the windows behind the altar, a high school art class' senior projects are not appropriate to replace iconography and statuary, and the guitar riffing by the poor hippie kid who does not know any better is not an appropriate replacement for the chants which are proper to the Roman Rite. But the biggest problem is that people do not know this, and there is a certain resistance to attempts to educate them. For most I think it is invincible ignorance. For some, willful ignorance. For a very small minority I do think there is a 'reforming' modernist mindset which is, ultimately, protestant in its ethos. But it can be difficult to sort out who is who. I do not know the most effective way to overcome that particular barrier.
dUSt Posted July 30, 2014 Author Posted July 30, 2014 I think it comes down to, if you want it done right, do it yourself. For example, most of us have the power to make sure there is no talking and socializing in the sanctuary before mass--simply ask the pastor if you can lead the rosary before the liturgy begins--or immediately after. This is just one example of many things any one of us can do. Will we do it? Will we be the ones who get off our lazy butts and make real change?
Nihil Obstat Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 (edited) I think it comes down to, if you want it done right, do it yourself. For example, most of us have the power to make sure there is no talking and socializing in the sanctuary before mass--simply ask the pastor if you can lead the rosary before the liturgy begins--or immediately after. This is just one example of many things any one of us can do. Will we do it? Will we be the ones who get off our lazy butts and make real change? To a certain extent that is true. That is a very good way to cut down on the ambient noise in the church proper. But a lot of other areas, especially music, artwork, and architecture, take much more complex solutions, and often quite a lot of money. I mean, what is a church to do when their choir is made up of older people who sing, objectively speaking, very poorly, and are perfectly happy doing what amounts to praise and worship karaoke every week? That was my old parish. What do you do when the church itself was so appallingly constructed and renovated that a halfway decent sanctuary would cost literally millions. That is my geographical parish. And most churches in my diocese. I mean yeah, you can donate more money. But that money goes first to repairs and upkeep, and most parishes are barely scraping by with those expenses. Those parish councils and finance committees would laugh you out of the room if you suggested building a proper Catholic altar, when instead they could finally get around to repairing the roof and the furnace. There are no insurmountable obstacles to a proper renewal of the liturgy, but unfortunately I do not see many easy fixes for some of the problems we have to deal with. Realistically, I think a true renewal will take generations. Edited July 30, 2014 by Nihil Obstat
fides' Jack Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 A good strategy, at least for finding a quieter Mass, is to attend the earliest Sunday morning Mass available to you. There is usually no music and no cast of thousands. I used to think this was the case at our parish, too, but our earliest Mass (8:30) tends to be the 2nd most crowded (after the 10:30), and the worst for music. Interestingly, at our parish, the anticipatory Mass is the best for music, since they try to incorporate children's Masses more often at this time - and I will listen to children singing acceptable music any day over the more "adult" stuff they do at other Masses. I think there is a huge need for quality control in the Church. Presentation matters. Beautiful architecture matters. Quality music matters. If some of these parishes with money would not consider using amateur high school art to decorate their churches, or use a Jr High student's stained glass project to put in the windows behind the altar, why do they think it is acceptable to allow a teenager to play riffs he learned on Guitar Hero during mass? Churches are built in stages--beautiful stained glass may come later in the budget. Stations of the cross sculptures may be a few years away. They don't put up temporary cardboard displays in the meantime--they simply do without until they can get something worthy to put in a church. Why not with music? Will you please temporarily turn on additional props per post so I can prop this more??? I think it comes down to, if you want it done right, do it yourself. For example, most of us have the power to make sure there is no talking and socializing in the sanctuary before mass--simply ask the pastor if you can lead the rosary before the liturgy begins--or immediately after. This is just one example of many things any one of us can do. Will we do it? Will we be the ones who get off our lazy butts and make real change? Just as soon as we stop having kids on an almost-annual frequency, and I can finally finish school. Then sure, I'll volunteer more. :)
truthfinder Posted July 30, 2014 Posted July 30, 2014 Well I'll betray my traddy inclinations and say, if it's available and you really need a respite, try the vigil Mass. Some are quiet, some are not - depends on the church.
SNJM Posted July 31, 2014 Posted July 31, 2014 I am blessed enough to attend a parish that has a professional choir and an outstanding organist. The Masses that I have attended that don't have this level of music are awful. I travel often, and I don't know where this "non-Catholic" music that has crept into our Churches has come from. It's non-denominational (Christian) and usually has nothing to do with the Liturgy and cannot be considered Catholic when there is basically a sole concentration on salvation (and nothing on works). No mention of Mary (unless she is called "Momma Mary") and definitely no litanies or traditional music of any kind that come from the writings of the saints. Because of that, when I travel, I now look for the Mass "without" music, which usually is the first Mass on Sunday (or from what I have seen). I am officially in the Orange Diocese (though spend a lot of time in LA) and we have some great things happening!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now