Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted

Haha! It was still a good one too! ;)

 

I really enjoyed that series. fo sho!

 

The best one ever.

Posted

Im always looking for stories similar.

 

Im not sure if you checked out the book suggestion thread, but there is a shorter series centering around a female necromancer. The feel of the story is very similar to Harry Potter. So if you dont mind the main protagonist being a girl you might enjoy it!  There is a lot of discussion that could happen with those books and Im always looking for people to chat with about them!

PhuturePriest
Posted

Im always looking for stories similar.

 

Im not sure if you checked out the book suggestion thread, but there is a shorter series centering around a female necromancer. The feel of the story is very similar to Harry Potter. So if you dont mind the main protagonist being a girl you might enjoy it!  There is a lot of discussion that could happen with those books and Im always looking for people to chat with about them!

 

What have you gathered from me as a person that you think a female protagonist would bother me? Have you not seen my infamous Anne of Green Gables thread?

Posted

No I dont think I have! But that is another amazing series! Still makes me cry when Matthew dies 

PhuturePriest
Posted

I like Lockhart for one main reason. He was an absolute, utter, despicable fraud, but he was only able to maintain that fraud because he was actually highly skilled in his own right at a totally different thing than what he was famous for, i.e. memory charms. Nobody really knew that he was essentially a memory charm savant because it did not fit the persona he had created. But if I remember correctly, it was implied that he was possibly the very best wizard in the world at that spell. Really interesting concept, IMO.

 

I just looked it up. It turns out not only was Gilderoy Lockhart in fact very smart and talented, but so much so that he was sorted into Ravenclaw house.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Only the best in Ravenclaw.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

Wit beyond measure is man's greatest treasure.

Posted

Wit beyond measure is man's greatest treasure.

 

I am out of props.

 

 

There is something not right about that.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

I am out of props.

 

 

There is something not right about that.

 

I can take cash or cheque instead.

Posted

I can take cash or cheque instead.

 

 

Meh. I will pay you in jujubes instead.

 

45190-Jujubes.jpg

PhuturePriest
Posted

Only the best in Ravenclaw.

 

Gryffindor is good enough for Dumbledore, so it's good enough for me.

 

Though Ravenclaw would be my second choice of House, and some quizzes put me as a Ravenclaw rather than Gryffindor.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

Meh. I will pay you in jujubes instead.

 

45190-Jujubes.jpg

 

This is acceptable.
 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Gryffindor is good enough for Dumbledore, so it's good enough for me.

Though Ravenclaw would be my second choice of House, and some quizzes put me as a Ravenclaw rather than Gryffindor.

Dumbledore is a very flawed person. A hero yes, but no saint.
PhuturePriest
Posted

Dumbledore is a very flawed person. A hero yes, but no saint.

 

99% of his flawed personality happened when he was a young adult, and it was motivated by his liking for Grindelwald. He became a very good and outstanding person for the rest of his life, though obviously even the most saintly among us make mistakes.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

99% of his flawed personality happened when he was a young adult, and it was motivated by his liking for Grindelwald. He became a very good and outstanding person for the rest of his life, though obviously even the most saintly among us make mistakes.

I disagree. I think his role in the books leaves something to be desired from a moral perspective. He was highly manipulative at times, and while the case can be made that it was necessary, I think that his character does lapse into consequentialism. For that matter I think the books in general were rather consequentialist, especially towards the end, but there you go.

PhuturePriest
Posted

I disagree. I think his role in the books leaves something to be desired from a moral perspective. He was highly manipulative at times, and while the case can be made that it was necessary, I think that his character does lapse into consequentialism. For that matter I think the books in general were rather consequentialist, especially towards the end, but there you go.

 

I do disagree with some of his decisions, namely, asking Snape to kill him, which we of course view as immoral, but these aren't Catholic books, so you can't expect Catholic morality and thought to be throughout the book like it is in The Lord of the Rings.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I do disagree with some of his decisions, namely, asking Snape to kill him, which we of course view as immoral, but these aren't Catholic books, so you can't expect Catholic morality and thought to be throughout the book like it is in The Lord of the Rings.

One does not have to be Catholic to see how a reasonable application of consequentialism as presented in the books could very quickly lead to bad places.

I do not think this was intentional on Rowling's part. Simply put, I do not think she has a highly developed sense of ethical theory. And that is fine - she is an author, not an ethicist. It is typical of the times we live in. But I do think that her lack of competence when it comes to ethics shows through frequently. In Dumbledore for sure, even more so in Harry.

PhuturePriest
Posted

One does not have to be Catholic to see how a reasonable application of consequentialism as presented in the books could very quickly lead to bad places.

I do not think this was intentional on Rowling's part. Simply put, I do not think she has a highly developed sense of ethical theory. And that is fine - she is an author, not an ethicist. It is typical of the times we live in. But I do think that her lack of competence when it comes to ethics shows through frequently. In Dumbledore for sure, even more so in Harry.

 

Care to expound?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Care to expound?

My go to example is always the so-called Unforgivable Curses. When they introduce those in Goblet of Fire, my first thought was that finally we have some true objective moral limits. It was an excellent opportunity. These Curses are grossly immoral, unjustifiable. Using one on another person makes you a criminal, period. These Curses represented a strict moral standard that allows no exceptions. Not explicitly Catholic, but in line with Catholic moral thought.

And for a while it did work this way. Only dark wizards used Unforgivable Curses. In a sense we might have identified dark wizards entirely by their willingness to use those Curses.

 

But then the Good Guys started using them.

 

I forget when that started. Maybe somewhere in Order of the Phoenix, maybe in Half Blood Prince. Cannot quite recall. I think it started with some of the members of the Order, in their underground work against Voldemort's return. I think it was the Imperius Curse that they were using.

The point is not that they were doing grossly wrong things at the time. Not necessarily. But this thing that had been set up as an objective moral standard had suddenly been violated. And - while I cannot recall in perfect detail I am convinced of this point - the Good Guys suddenly using these Curses goes completely unremarked.

At the very least have someone question "is it ok to use these Curses? Are we just as bad as them if we cross this line?" etc., but nobody ever did. There was no questioning of the morality of those Curses.

Even Harry started using them. I recall at least once or twice that he even tried to use the Cruciatus Curse. Essentially torture. I think Mrs. Weasley used it as well, and probably a couple others. Now, I can see making a valid point with this, that sometimes good people do bad things, that evil naturally drags down good people and drives them towards committing evil themselves. But no such point was made. In fact rather the opposite, I think. The odd silence from the heroes with regards to those Curses does imply that to them there is simply nothing out of the ordinary. The Curses, to them, seem to be a morally neutral tool.

 

So either the Curses did represent a true moral line, in which case our heroes acted immorally despite their great need (and this ethos is never condemned by Rowling's narrative voice), or perhaps even worse, we have an explicit example of some immoral acts being justified in difficult circumstances.

As I said, in my opinion it is clear to me that Rowling, like the average western person, is not particularly competent when it comes to ethical theory. So I do not think the books represent an actual attack against objective morality. I simply think that they represent the confused moral sense of our generation, where consequentialism is implicitly accepted.

LittleWaySoul
Posted

Ooooh do I like where this conversation is going! Please, continue!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...