Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Movie About Catholics With Same Sex Attraction


Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted

http://everlastinghills.org/movie/

 

Desire of the Everlasting Hills showcases 3 Catholics and their stories of how they got out of the "gay lifestyle" and became faithful Catholics. Very inspiring for anyone struggling with these attractions.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

Saw it about a week ago. It is pretty razzle dazzle.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

I'm glad that the one gentleman was able to keep his relationship with his partner, albeit chaste. Good for them!

ChristianGirlForever
Posted

I have family members with this issue, so I was curious to watch the film. I was really shocked by how inappropriate some of the content was. I wish it had been handled more delicately. Perhaps I'm just not used to this subject matter, but I felt the video should have held a warning of mature content.

The Hierophant
Posted (edited)

For a second I thought you were going to talk about the 1994 movie Priest. [Edit:  Not that I love that movie, just thought for sure that's what you meant]

Edited by The Hierophant
Nihil Obstat
Posted

I have family members with this issue, so I was curious to watch the film. I was really shocked by how inappropriate some of the content was. I wish it had been handled more delicately. Perhaps I'm just not used to this subject matter, but I felt the video should have held a warning of mature content.

I have not seen the movie. Broadly speaking, what sort of content are we talking about?

ChristianGirlForever
Posted

I have not seen the movie. Broadly speaking, what sort of content are we talking about?


Hmmm. I don't want to get censored. Don't get me wrong, there was a lot of good in it, but I believe certain things said were unnecessary. One guy said something that even he realized he shouldn't have said, and the interviewer said it was great. They kept it in.

Here is the link to the review by Crisis magazine. It mentions one of the things that turned my stomach.

http://www.crisismagazine.com/2014/hearts-restless

Feel free to PM me, if you like.
ChristianGirlForever
Posted (edited)

For a second I thought you were going to talk about the 1994 movie Priest. [Edit: Not that I love that movie, just thought for sure that's what you meant]


I've never heard of Priest. What is it about? Edited by ChristianGirlForever
Vincent Vega
Posted

Hmmm. I don't want to get censored. Don't get me wrong, there was a lot of good in it, but I believe certain things said were unnecessary. One guy said something that even he realized he shouldn't have said, and the interviewer said it was great. They kept it in.

Here is the link to the review by Crisis magazine. It mentions one of the things that turned my stomach.

http://www.crisismagazine.com/2014/hearts-restless

Feel free to PM me, if you like.

I'm curious, but not curious enough to read that whole article.

ChristianGirlForever
Posted

I'm curious, but not curious enough to read that whole article.


Lol. I totally know what you mean. One of my Achilles' Heels is my curiosity. Although the film was interesting, I kinda wish I hadn't watched it because it was disturbing. I think it's probably best for someone coming out of that lifestyle to watch, not for a straight, sheltered girl like me. Lol

One of the guys on there broke my heart, and I prayed for him, so I guess some good came out of my watching it.
Posted

I watched about half of it and their personal stories are amazing. Yes, they are very very blunt about their experiences, but thats life.

 

I want to finish it then decide how I feel about it as a whole.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Hmmm. I don't want to get censored. Don't get me wrong, there was a lot of good in it, but I believe certain things said were unnecessary. One guy said something that even he realized he shouldn't have said, and the interviewer said it was great. They kept it in.

Here is the link to the review by Crisis magazine. It mentions one of the things that turned my stomach.

http://www.crisismagazine.com/2014/hearts-restless

Feel free to PM me, if you like.

Thanks. I will read that as soon as I have the opportunity.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

I have family members with this issue, so I was curious to watch the film. I was really shocked by how inappropriate some of the content was. I wish it had been handled more delicately. Perhaps I'm just not used to this subject matter, but I felt the video should have held a warning of mature content.

I wouldn't say it was necessarily inappropriate — just blunt and for mature audiences.

 

It's good to not tip-toe around this particular issue because it is such an important one, to some people at least (to me, for sure.)

Posted

I didn't find it really that graphic, to be honest. I watched it and kept waiting for what you might be referring to, but nothing really stood out as particularly shocking. It is a mature subject, but it seems like one would assume that without an explicit forewarning. I don't know how you could have an hour long documentary about homosexuality without some reference to sexual activity. Personally I think they struck a good balance with being real about their experiences, while also keeping graphic details out.

Some of the cinematic style bugged me though.

ChristianGirlForever
Posted

I found the twins thing really shocking, for example. I didn't think the woman referred to it all delicately. It was obscene. Perhaps I was naive thinking it would be pretty clean. As I said, I'm sheltered, but yikes about that bit.

I hope it helped you, Tardis. :) I just wish it had held a Mature Audiences Only warning beforehand. If a minor watched it, that wouldn't be good, IMO.

Posted (edited)

I finally watched Desire of the Everlasting Hills, a recent hour-long film that’s gotten a lot of attention in our circles of late. It tells the stories of three Catholics who, at least at one time, understood themselves to be homosexual but now, in light of their return to the Church… well, you’ll just have to watch it and see how unpredictable and multi-layered their narratives are. AsEve Tushnet has pointed out, these are by no means simple “ex-gay” stories, but nor, I think, are they exactly the sort of stories we often highlight on this blog. I thought I had heard most everything in our little gay Christian world, but this movie surprised me.

 

http://spiritualfriendship.org/2014/08/06/how-to-narrate-complexity/  Wesley Hill

 

 

 

Recently, Wesley Hill posted some wonderful thoughts here about the film Desire of the Everlasting Hills. It is a captivating documentary about three Christians who either return or convert to Catholic Christianity, leaving behind active homosexual lifestyles. There are so many wonderful takeaways, many of which Wes highlights quite well. But I want to focus on one aspect of their stories that struck me as particularly powerful: sacrificial love.

 

http://spiritualfriendship.org/2014/08/10/love-true-love-wherever-it-exists/    Nick Roen

 

 

 

 

Edited by cappie
Posted

Interesting. Seeing as I find the premise of homosexuality and homosexual attraction being a choice/lifestyle over a biological factor to be silly, and that is an idea this film seems to be comfortable with, I'm not sure I'll watch it. I have nothing but respect for those homosexuals who are faithful to Church teachings on celibacy and abstain however. That is surely a most difficult road.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

Interesting. Seeing as I find the premise of homosexuality and homosexual attraction being a choice/lifestyle over a biological factor to be silly, and that is an idea this film seems to be comfortable with, I'm not sure I'll watch it. I have nothing but respect for those homosexuals who are faithful to Church teachings on celibacy and abstain however. That is surely a most difficult road.

 

It's not an ex-gay movie, if that's what you mean.

Posted

it sounds like a fascinating movie but I am not sure it would be appropriate for our weekly community movie nights

Posted

I appreciated it for what it was. There were a couple of suggestive moments which it wouldn't be right for everyone to hear, but I wouldn't say it was Explicit. What I was pleasantly surprised by was that it let the three people tell their very different, yet very similar stories at length, and I think that's where its power came from. However, I was left wondering, who was this film directed at? Practising Catholics who want to know more about homosexuality? Other people who come back to Catholicism after time away? It seemed to end very suddenly for me - though movingly - with them saying 'my life is so much better now I'm celibate; the end'. Don't think it ONLY said that but I was left wanting to know more than it offered.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...