Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What Is This Noise?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Meh. The boys still work really hard to create that music, so even if you dont like it not reason to knock their abilities. They are kids!

 

BUt thats just my opinion and you all have yours! :)

puellapaschalis
Posted

Actually I think the OP and first few replies didn't make any distinction, or if they did it was to rubbish 'boys' choirs' or 'children's choirs'. But this type of boys' choir is in a completely different league to the stereotypical rabble which an overworked volunteer tries to get to sing an entrance hymn properly. It's absolutely a different thing. The mental discipline required to not lose your place in Byrd (e.g.) and freak out because nothing sounds 'right' is something you will only find with the kind of intensive training these boys have.

 

Anyone who doesn't like it can, I suppose, just avail themselves of the pile of tambourines or unnecessary vibrato over there in the corner. There's no need to snark on the English choral tradition, even if it be popped for the Top 40.

Archaeology cat
Posted

I think Leo could make a great boy soprano. He can resonate very well as he shrieks at a very high pitch. Then maybe I can convince our parish to bring in choristers.

Posted

I think Leo could make a great boy soprano. He can resonate very well as he shrieks at a very high pitch. Then maybe I can convince our parish to bring in choristers.

 

Put the shrieking to work! :)

Archaeology cat
Posted

Put the shrieking to work! :)

That's what I say!
Posted

That's what I say!

 

If he has some good pipes maybe he would enjoy focusing it into a song while in a choir! :)

Archaeology cat
Posted

He actually sang the Alleluia on Friday instead of shrieking. Of course, he sang it throughout all the Gospel and some of the homily, but it's a start.

Vincent Vega
Posted (edited)

Male sopranos (while people easily snicker and laugh) are quite rare and super rad. Its extremely difficult to sing like that so check yourself before you start poo pooing at someone elses talents. 

 

You might not understand it, appreciate it, or even like it, but lets not be negative.

 

 

Ok, thats enough from the lame-o police. :)

If this was aimed at me, you could have quoted me.

 

Since I work as an organist and choirmaster in the Anglican tradition, I understand both the historical and modern significance of boy's choirs, and I don't think I ever pooh-poohed anyone's talents. I just don't care for it.

 

Choirs of men and boys are a different matter entirely. Although, to be honest, if I had the choice of conducting King's and Trinity, I'd probably go with Trinity. The timbre of the male soprano is just not agreeable to my ear. This of course is a matter of taste, and surely the choir school model is responsible for an innumerable amount of incredible adult male musicians. It just isn't my bag.

Edited by Vincent Vega
PhuturePriest
Posted

Meh. The boys still work really hard to create that music, so even if you dont like it not reason to knock their abilities. They are kids!

 

BUt thats just my opinion and you all have yours! :)

 

The overwhelming tolerance in here is making me feel ill.

PhuturePriest
Posted

I think Leo could make a great boy soprano. He can resonate very well as he shrieks at a very high pitch. Then maybe I can convince our parish to bring in choristers.

 

He's got to be better than the lady who sings at our parish. The thing is, she's so bad that you can't mock her without feeling bad about it.

 

So I'll let Tim Hawkins do it instead.

 

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=61xj6XKPmvg

veritasluxmea
Posted

The overwhelming tolerance in here is making me feel ill.

Good grief. The need to affirm that they're all right and cool shows what's wrong with society today. I didn't even think it was girly until people brought it up. Some people like them, some people don't, and others are snarky no matter the topic. Welcome to Phatmass. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

Good grief. The need to affirm that they're all right and cool shows what's wrong with society today. I didn't even think it was girly until people brought it up. Some people like them, some people don't, and others are snarky no matter the topic. Welcome to Phatmass. 

 

I was making a joke about how indifferent and mellow Crosscut was. I like people that like to take a stand. :P Not necessarily aggressively, but firmly.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

http://youtu.be/KLjvfqnD0ws

Posted

If this was aimed at me, you could have quoted me.

 

Since I work as an organist and choirmaster in the Anglican tradition, I understand both the historical and modern significance of boy's choirs, and I don't think I ever pooh-poohed anyone's talents. I just don't care for it.

 

Choirs of men and boys are a different matter entirely. Although, to be honest, if I had the choice of conducting King's and Trinity, I'd probably go with Trinity. The timbre of the male soprano is just not agreeable to my ear. This of course is a matter of taste, and surely the choir school model is responsible for an innumerable amount of incredible adult male musicians. It just isn't my bag.

 

Music is a strong tradition in my family; we all participate in some way. Some play instruments, some sing etc. I personally love the tone and purity of the children choirs...especially a BA boys choir mostly because its just so beautiful!

franciscanheart
Posted

Actually I think the OP and first few replies didn't make any distinction, or if they did it was to rubbish 'boys' choirs' or 'children's choirs'. But this type of boys' choir is in a completely different league to the stereotypical rabble which an overworked volunteer tries to get to sing an entrance hymn properly. It's absolutely a different thing. The mental discipline required to not lose your place in Byrd (e.g.) and freak out because nothing sounds 'right' is something you will only find with the kind of intensive training these boys have.

 

Anyone who doesn't like it can, I suppose, just avail themselves of the pile of tambourines or unnecessary vibrato over there in the corner. There's no need to snark on the English choral tradition, even if it be popped for the Top 40.

 

Pretty sure the only input I had was the title of the thread. Which I posted in hopes that the people of phatmass with whom I have been associated for a number of years would give me the benefit of the doubt in addition to using their logical brain to conclude that I must be talking about the synthesized portions of this piece. WHY in God's name would you do that to such lovely music? To make them more palatable to the average ear? PLEASE.

 

That was my point. And Deus Te Amat seemed to understand. Pretty sure Winchester was being Winchester and MAKING A JOKE.

 

You people are uptight. No wonder dUSt is perpetually fending off your whiny drivel: you take yourselves too beaver dam seriously.

 

I was in a children's choir. I raised thousands of dollars to support my local children's choir. I LOVE BOYS CHOIRS. I've attended a number of concerts, have more CDs than is right, and praise the boy choir sound OFTEN. I think they are impressive creatures and I gain much pleasure from listening to the music they create together. I even got to sing with a boy's choir while I was in my city's children's chorus -- which, by the way, was also extremely demanding.

 

But sure, let's go with your opinion: You're right. Everyone else is wrong. We are all terrible people who can't appreciate the real beauty of a good boy choir. :rolleyes:

franciscanheart
Posted

BTW: My favorite local boys choir...

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8VXrRAWcmB4

Posted (edited)

Lovely!

Edited by CrossCuT
Posted

Hahaha. People telling Airways what to think. Lol. Probably the most qualified person to comment on this thread.

 

Also, go Gators.  

franciscanheart
Posted

BTW: My favorite local boys choir...

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8VXrRAWcmB4

 

Start listening around 29:08. They'll take your breath away.

franciscanheart
Posted

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JGXERrZKOC0

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...