Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is There A Crisis In The Church?


  

21 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

Vote and discuss.

Edited by The Phetus
veritasluxmea
Posted

There's always a crisis of faith in the Church, especially after counsels. 

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

There's always a crisis of faith in the Church, especially after counsels. 

 

Wrong. There is a crisis in the Church *before* a council, and that's the entire purpose of them. The Council of Trent wouldn't have happened if the Reformation didn't happen.

 

And just because a council has happened that does not excuse widespread lack of fidelity and reverence, unless, of course, you don't think these things are the case. Do you think there is a crisis, or do you think these are simple aftershocks of a council?

Edited by The Phetus
veritasluxmea
Posted (edited)

Wrong. There is a crisis in the Church *before* a council, and that's the entire purpose of them. The Council of Trent wouldn't have happened if the Reformation didn't happen.

There's a crisis before, there's a crisis after, and then there's still a crisis... there's always a crisis. If it's not one thing it's another. 

 

 

And just because a council has happened that does not excuse widespread lack of fidelity and reverence, unless, of course, you don't think these things are the case. Do you think there is a crisis, or do you think these are simple aftershocks of a council?

Of course the council doesn't excuse it. It also didn't cause it. I think it's both a crisis and aftershocks. 

 

I'm optimistic that the Church, the culture, the world actually might perk up for a bit, but of course it will then dive down and eventually stay down until the second coming. 

 

Edited by veritasluxmea
PhuturePriest
Posted

 

There's a crisis before, there's a crisis after, and then there's still a crisis... there's always a crisis. If it's not one thing it's another. 

 

Of course the council doesn't excuse it. It also didn't cause it. I think it's both a crisis and aftershocks. 

 

I'm optimistic that the Church, the culture, the world actually might perk up for a bit, but of course it will then dive down and eventually stay down until the second coming. 

 

 

I'm not asking about the culture or the world, I'm asking if you think a majority of Catholics are truly reverent and have full fidelity to Church teaching. I haven't said anything about councils.

PhuturePriest
Posted

48c9b4c5d666588f2f0ba265102696d7.jpg

 

Jack-o%27-Lantern_2003-10-31.jpg
 

Posted

I am the crisis. 

 

Grace overcomes me. But the funny thing about that, is you have to let grace work in you. And people like to be in control.

 

 

 

Moral of the story -- it's not all about you. Let God.

 

 

Meh.

veritasluxmea
Posted (edited)

I'm not asking about the culture or the world, I'm asking if you think a majority of Catholics are truly reverent and have full fidelity to Church teaching. I haven't said anything about councils.

Then no. But periods of time where a majority of Catholic were reverent and had full fidelity and all that were fleeting, if ever complete. Yes, there is a crisis, there is always some kind of crisis. 

Edited by veritasluxmea
PhuturePriest
Posted

Then no. But periods of time where a majority of Catholic were reverent and had full fidelity and all that were fleeting, if ever complete. Yes, there is a crisis, there is always some kind of crisis. 

 

"No", as in you don't think there's a crisis concerning fidelity and reverence, or "No" as in yes? I'm not meaning to seem as if I'm going after you, I was just confused by the wording.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Then no. But periods of time where a majority of Catholic were reverent and had full fidelity and all that were fleeting, if ever complete. Yes, there is a crisis, there is always some kind of crisis. 

 

Sorry, just saw the edit.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Then no. But periods of time where a majority of Catholic were reverent and had full fidelity and all that were fleeting, if ever complete. Yes, there is a crisis, there is always some kind of crisis. 

 

I disagree with your assertion that there is always a crisis. Are there always problems of at least some minor type? Of course. But there isn't always a *crisis*, per se. 25% of Catholics not going to Mass every week is a problem; 75% of Catholics not going to Mass every week is a crisis. 10% of Catholic women using contraception is a problem; 90% of Catholic women using contraception is a crisis.

 

See what I'm getting at?

Posted

Athanasius Schneider:


Q. What is this crisis you mention?

BAS: ‘This is a broader crisis than the reception of the Blessed Sacrament. I think this issue of the reception of Holy Communion by the remarried will blow up and show the real crisis in the Church. The real crisis of the Church is anthropocentrism, forgetting the Christocentrism. Indeed, this is the deepest evil, when man or the clergy are putting themselves in the centre when they are celebrating liturgy and when they are changing the revealed truth of God, e.g. concerning the Sixth Commandment and human sexuality.

‘The crisis reveals itself also in the manner in which the Eucharistic Lord is treated. The Eucharist is at the heart of the Church. When the heart is weak, the whole body is weak. So when the practice around the Eucharist is weak, then the heart and the life of the Church is weak. And when people have no more supernatural vision of God in the Eucharist then they will start the worship of man, and then also doctrine will change to the desire of man.

‘This crisis is when we place ourselves, including the priests, at the centre and when God is put in the corner and this is happening also materially. The Blessed Sacrament is sometimes in a cupboard away from the centre and the chair of the priest is in the centre. We have already been in this situation for 40 or 50 years and there is the real danger that God and his Commandments and laws will be put on the side and the human natural desiring in the centre. There is causal connection between the Eucharistic and the doctrinal crisis.

‘Our first duty as human beings is to adore God, not us, but Him. Unfortunately, the liturgical practice of the last 40 years has been very anthropocentric.

'Participating in liturgy is firstly not about doing things but praying and worshipping, to love God with all your soul. This is true participation, to be united with God in your soul. Exterior participation is not essential.

‘The crisis is really this: we have not put Christ or God at the centre. And Christ is God incarnated. Our problem today is that we put away the incarnation. We have eclipsed it. If God remains in my mind only as an idea, this is Gnostic. In other religions e.g. Jews, Muslims, God is not incarnated. For them, God is in the book, but He is not concrete. Only in Christianity, and really in the Catholic Church, is the incarnation fully realised and this has to be stressed therefore also in every point of the liturgy. God is here and really present. So every detail has meaning.

‘We are living in an un-Christian society, in a new paganism. The temptation today for the clergy is to adapt to the new world to the new paganism, to be collaborationists. We are in a similar situation to the first centuries, when the majority of the society was pagan, and Christianity was discriminated against.’


Q. Can you see a split coming in the Church?

BAS: ‘Unfortunately, for some decades some clergy have accepted these ideas of the world. Now however they are following them publicly. When these things continue, I think, there will be an interior split in the Church of those who are faithful to the faith of their baptism and of the integrity of the Catholic faith. There will be a split with those who are assuming the spirit of this world and there will be a clear split, I think. One can imagine that Catholics, who remain faithful to the unchangeable Catholic truth may, for a time, be persecuted or discriminated even on behalf of those who has power in the exterior structures of the Church? But the gates of the hell, i.e. of the heresy, will not prevail against the Church and the Supreme Magisterium will surely issue an unequivocal doctrinal statement, rejecting any collaboration with the neo-pagan ideas of changing e.g. the Sixth Commandment of God, the meaning of sexuality and of family. Then some 'liberals', and many collaborators with the spirit of this world, many modern “thurificati et traditores” will leave the Church. Because the Divine truth will unresistingly bring the clarification, will set us free, and will separate in the midst of the Church the sons of the Divine light and the sons of the of the pseudo-light of this pagan and anti-Christian world. I can presume that such a separation will affect each level of the Catholics: lay people and even not excluding the high clergy. Those clergy who accept today the spirit of the pagan world on morality and family declare themselves Catholics and even faithful to the Pope. They even declare extremists those who are faithful to the Catholic faith or those who are promoting the glory of Christ in the liturgy.’



http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2014/06/bishop-athanasius-schneider-in-england.html

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Absolutely there is a crisis, I voted yes to all of the above. We live in very unusual times.

 

That said -- the story has a good ending. In the meantime I think the faithful are enduring something of a foxhole existence in the midst of spiritual warfare and have to toe the line between indifference and despair.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

In short: yes, crisis of faith and reverence.

 

I think that what Benedict XVI said about the Church shrinking down in the future will come to pass. There are increasingly less social reasons to be a nominal Catholic, and increasingly more difficult to be a faithful Catholic and still find a place in the public square.

 

Oh well. We can't all live in times of increase. And, as Gandalf said, it is what we do with the time that is given to us that is important.

Posted (edited)

In some ways, there is always a crisis of faith.  It's very hard to accurately account for how many people truly believed in ages past (historians call it the "convert counting" problem.)  At the same time, the present time (from about the 1970s onwards) has been troubled by the fact the Church is ever true and constant, but not her churchmen.  Clerics and laity alike have forgotten who they were, and why they needed the faith, and above all, forgot the absolute necessity of Jesus Christ and his Church.  In some places this seems to be changing, particularly among trad communities who are starting to move out of isolation.  Trad priests mingling with their other brethren and along with all the laity, being unashamed to declare the Truth of the Church.  (Please, don't get me wrong, there are some incredibly faithful OF priests, but sometimes they are domineered by others including their superiors to keep quiet.)

 

Crises at councils are real.  Preceding them is heresies and laxity, after, a decision to follow or disobey the resolutions of the councils.  The particular problems with Vatican II, however, was that proper catechesis on the rulings of the council was poorly carried out, and in many cases practices developed which were contrary to the council itself.  Catechesis, particularly after Trent, was by far better, at least on a theoretical level - there were tools developed for the average priest to teach his congregation.  Instead, teaching on Vatican II only brought obfuscation of the council's teachings.  It's only in recent years that people are truly reading the documents.  Those who did in the past often ran afoul of clerics (Mother Angelica, for example). 

Edited by truthfinder
Fidei Defensor
Posted

The only crisis I see is a plague of sinfulness without repentance. We're human and sinful, but there is much less propensity to actually call sin what it is and to call for conversion of heart.

Posted

The only crisis I see is a plague of sinfulness without repentance. We're human and sinful, but there is much less propensity to actually call sin what it is and to call for conversion of heart.

You have said exactly what I was thinking, but in a much more concise manner :)

PhuturePriest
Posted

48c9b4c5d666588f2f0ba265102696d7.jpg

 

HwIXN3K.jpg

 

 

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KlGMsAHoCzE

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...