Not A Mallard Posted September 18, 2014 Posted September 18, 2014 Husband + wife + 0 = baby. 'Nuff said.
CrossCuT Posted September 18, 2014 Posted September 18, 2014 Saw this story a few months back. Pretty cool! Genetically speaking, mitochondrial DNA is separate from your actual cells DNA, but in functionality, the mitochondria play a huge role. Not sure how this will play out legally, but we shall see I guess. Only potential moral problem is the destruction of an embryo to harvest either the mitochondrial DNA or cell dna in order to combine it with a healthy mitochondria. Luckily there is a way to do that without the use of an embryo and simply harvest the mitochondria from an egg before fertilization.
Archaeology cat Posted September 18, 2014 Posted September 18, 2014 Saw this story a few months back. Pretty cool! Genetically speaking, mitochondrial DNA is separate from your actual cells DNA, but in functionality, the mitochondria play a huge role. Not sure how this will play out legally, but we shall see I guess. Only potential moral problem is the destruction of an embryo to harvest either the mitochondrial DNA or cell dna in order to combine it with a healthy mitochondria. Luckily there is a way to do that without the use of an embryo and simply harvest the mitochondria from an egg before fertilization.I wouldn't say that's the only moral problem. It would still require IVF, right?
Credo in Deum Posted September 18, 2014 Posted September 18, 2014 Eugenics. Nothing new under the sun.
CrossCuT Posted September 18, 2014 Posted September 18, 2014 I wouldn't say that's the only moral problem. It would still require IVF, right? Ah yes, that is true. Eugenics. Nothing new under the sun. I dont think its Eugenics. Eugenics operates solely for the purpose of manipulating genetic material to result in a superior baby...ei to select the best genes for appearance, intelligence, health and what not. I wouldn't consider curing Mitochondrial disease as eugenics; there is a difference between using technology to eliminate a disease vs using it to simply make someone better when there was nothing wrong in the first place.
Archaeology cat Posted September 18, 2014 Posted September 18, 2014 Mitochondrial diseases are crazy. THere was a question about whether Kieran's cyclic vomiting could be from a mitochondrial issue, but they aren't thinking that so much now. Finding a way to actually cure mitochondrial diseases would be awesome, provided they can do so without using immoral means.
CrossCuT Posted September 18, 2014 Posted September 18, 2014 Having a defective mitochondria is a big deal. It is involved with soooo much in your body. If this works, it would be a saving grace for many babies that die only months after they are born because of the problem.
CatherineM Posted September 18, 2014 Posted September 18, 2014 This is less about eugenics and more about vanity and stupidity. It's from the quarter that think babies are fashion accessories and a "right." I love the quote from Juassic Park about scientists spending all their time on can we do it rather than on should we do it. I can imagine so many really nasty things that could come from this besides bad moral decisions.
veritasluxmea Posted September 19, 2014 Posted September 19, 2014 I once heard that they found a way to create a baby using only two women, but I'm to lazy to look up the link. Hopefully nothing comes of it. what a violation of human rights.
CrossCuT Posted September 19, 2014 Posted September 19, 2014 This is less about eugenics and more about vanity and stupidity. It's from the quarter that think babies are fashion accessories and a "right." I love the quote from Juassic Park about scientists spending all their time on can we do it rather than on should we do it. I can imagine so many really nasty things that could come from this besides bad moral decisions. What about this has anything to do with vanity?
CatherineM Posted September 19, 2014 Posted September 19, 2014 What about this has anything to do with vanity? The vanity of wanting to create a perfect baby rather allowing God to do the creating.
PhuturePriest Posted September 19, 2014 Posted September 19, 2014 (edited) Edited September 19, 2014 by FuturePacker
veritasluxmea Posted September 19, 2014 Posted September 19, 2014 The vanity of wanting to create a perfect baby rather allowing God to do the creating. "perfect" here simply means designing someone to look as they want. That's not "perfect." So much for everyone is beautiful.
CrossCuT Posted September 19, 2014 Posted September 19, 2014 The vanity of wanting to create a perfect baby rather allowing God to do the creating. Are you referring to eugenics or curing mitochondrial disease?
CatherineM Posted September 19, 2014 Posted September 19, 2014 If you carry some horrific genetic disorder, don't have natural children, just adopt. You don't have to play with an elemental force just so you can say that little Susie has my eyes and nose.
CrossCuT Posted September 19, 2014 Posted September 19, 2014 Im not going to judge anyone for making that decision for themselves; im not going to say that someone is doing it for vain reasons. I think it is a fantastic new window of opportunity to fight a fatal disease and a step in a positive direction to being able to fight other diseases we dont fully understand yet.
Didacus Posted September 21, 2014 Posted September 21, 2014 Eugenics. Nothing new under the sun. I agree - this opens the door to many questions, many of which have the potential of being disastrous! Such an area must be explored very carefully, and limits set prior to embarking on such a path.
Didacus Posted September 21, 2014 Posted September 21, 2014 Im not going to judge anyone for making that decision for themselves; im not going to say that someone is doing it for vain reasons. I think it is a fantastic new window of opportunity to fight a fatal disease and a step in a positive direction to being able to fight other diseases we dont fully understand yet. Fighting disease is one thing, but say a couple wanted a girl instead of a boy would they be allowed to manipulate genetics to this end? What about Down's syndrome? What if you wanted to give your child just that little extra edge and make sure he or she was smart (considering stupidity as a disease... actually, more like a plague of sorts). Huge and many questions to be answered here...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now