Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Can You Receive Communion If You Arrive After The Consecration?


Recommended Posts

The Bus Station
Posted

I arrived at mass this morning after the consecration, so I thought I should not receive.  I went to a later Mass and received then.  From my research, it looks like the Church has no official teaching on this.  So ... how late is "too" late?

Not The Philosopher
Posted

Personally speaking, I would not receive communion. Iunno if it would be actually sinful to do so, but I wouldn't view myself as being sufficiently disposed to receive the graces given in communion.

Posted

I was always taught that you had to be there for the readings and the consecration if you want to receive communion.

 

But I don't know where that's written down.

brandelynmarie
Posted

I was always taught you need to be there for the Gospel readings & Consecration in order to receive unless there is a grave reason.

For example, several weeks ago I was in a minor car accident on my way to Mass. Once I had taken care of all the legal stuff, I made it just in time to get into line to receive Holy Communion. I'm of the thought that God knows I tried to be there on time & sees my goodwill...now if I hit the snooze bar one too many times however...that's another story :topsy:

Basilisa Marie
Posted

There is no real hard and fast rule about how late you have to be for it to not count. It's certainly not in canon law. I think best practices say you have to be present for the Liturgy of the Word and the Liturgy of the Eucharist, so arriving before the first reading seems to me like a good place for the cutoff (since the readings are the meat of that part of the mass).  Arriving before the Gospel if you really have to cut it close. You should also take your intentions into account - do you have a legitimate reason for being late or are you just trying to catch the end of your favorite show or getting your lipstick just right? I'd be more inclined to be generous with people who are late because they were stuck in traffic behind an accident vs. something frivolous. 

Post consecration? Yeah, I'd have a hard time arguing that that counted. Good on you for going to the next mass and receiving there, I think you definitely did the right thing. :) 

Posted

Most Catholics who ask this question have confused the ability to receive Communion with the fulfillment of our Sunday Duty. The Sunday Duty is one of the Precepts of the Church, and it says that "You shall attend Mass on Sundays and holy days of obligation and rest from servile labor."

 

The Sunday Duty is a fulfillment of the Third Commandment: "Remember to keep holy the sabbath day." It is binding under pain of mortal sin, so if we deliberately do not fulfill it, we cannot receive Communion again until we have gone to Confession. However, this is a separate question from whether we can receive Communion without participating in a Mass.

 

The reception of Holy Communion in no way depends on your participation in the Mass (as long as you have not already received Communion earlier that day). cfr c.917 A person who has received the Most Holy Eucharist may receive it again (iterum) on the same day only during the celebration of the Eucharist in which the person participates.

 

You do not have to have fulfilled your Sunday Duty in order to receive Communion. But the flipside is that receiving Communion, in and of itself, does not fulfill your Sunday Duty. And, as I noted above, if you deliberately fail to fulfill your Sunday Duty, you cannot receive Communion in the future until you have gone to Confession.

 

So here's the rule of thumb: If you come in late to Mass on a Sunday or a holy day, through your own fault, you can still receive Communion. But you will need to attend another Mass, in full, that day in order to fulfill your Sunday Duty.

 

People who arrive late to Mass have to honestly ask themselves, Why? If they arrive late because of some justified reason or unforeseen event, such as blocked traffic due to an accident, they have acted in good conscience, likewise for many elderly people, even getting to the church is an odyssey, and one must not burden their consciences by counting the minutes.

 

If people arrive late due to culpable negligence, and especially if they do so habitually, then they need to seriously reflect on their attitudes, amend their ways,

Posted

I think that in an emergency, with your heart in the right disposition one could simply walk in at communion time and receive Communion and not commit any sin.  After all, when Communion is given in the hospital sometimes the recipient has only moments to prepare...or a person who has Communion delivered to their home.

 

Weither or not this aptly fulfills the Sunday obligation is another question.  That's what I would ponder.  Other than pure ADD, there's only been a few drastic situations where I was late for mass, one being because the church published the Mass time but they didn't have it over the summer and we had to drive to another church.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

 

 

You do not have to have fulfilled your Sunday Duty in order to receive Communion. But the flipside is that receiving Communion, in and of itself, does not fulfill your Sunday Duty. And, as I noted above, if you deliberately fail to fulfill your Sunday Duty, you cannot receive Communion in the future until you have gone to Confession.

 

 

Aha, because there's still time to fulfill the Sunday Duty? So you can receive communion if you come reaaaaallly late to 9am Mass, and then go to 11am Mass?  

brandelynmarie
Posted

Wait? So I didn't fulfill my Sunday obligation in my above scenario? Do I need to confess this??

Uh oh...

Posted

A previous priest of mine, Fr. Blust, gave a rule of thumb that your obligation is fulfilled if you arrive for Mass at least by the start of the Collect. 

Posted

Aha, because there's still time to fulfill the Sunday Duty? So you can receive communion if you come reaaaaallly late to 9am Mass, and then go to 11am Mass?  

 

My trad spiritual director told me a while back that this is correct, and seeing as how trads are incredibly finicky about the Liturgy, I was inclined to believe him.

Posted

Aha, because there's still time to fulfill the Sunday Duty? So you can receive communion if you come reaaaaallly late to 9am Mass, and then go to 11am Mass?  

 

Yes the obligation is to attend Mass or as I learnt it "To HEAR Mass on Sundays and Holy Days of Obligation."

Posted

A previous priest of mine, Fr. Blust, gave a rule of thumb that your obligation is fulfilled if you arrive for Mass at least by the start of the Collect. 

 

Actually the rule was, when I was growing up, You must be present for the reading of the Gospel and you could depart when the priest has received Communion. This was the minimum for Canon Lawyers to fulfill the obligation, but it is hardly within the spirit of the sacrifice of the Mass which has a definite commencement and a definite conclusion.  :saint2: 

Posted

Wait? So I didn't fulfill my Sunday obligation in my above scenario? Do I need to confess this??

Uh oh...

 

No in your case you're fine

Posted

Personally I don't feel comfortable receiving if I arrive after the Kyrie has been said, but that's just my own preference - I think it's because I love the Kyrie and the Gloria and I don't feel adequately prepared to hear the readings or receive Communion without praying them. Most people I know say you should arrive before the Gospel.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

I will recieve holy eucharist even if i show up when the communion line has begun. It is church official. But it is true i will not recieve the indulgence from the holy mass showing up so late, and i guess best to kneel after you recieve if your just showing up in the nick of time and remain till the holy mass is finnished. An old timer threatened to knock me one when i did that once so i asked a priest what the churches official rule on it was and he told me, his name is fr popplewell and he is fssp, he also agrees with fr cappie that the church states you can leave as soon as the priest has consumed the host, you don't even have to recieve the host yourself, good in the case when you haven't been to confession and your not in a state of grace  and can only recieve the indulgence from holy mass.

 

I too would like to know what contributes to attending holy mass. I personaly would think the start of the concecration period till the end, because we all read holy scripture right? or should. But than again i think there are 3 parts of the holy mass which are considered compulsary to know by heart which if present for all 3 at least may attain the right to have being attended holy mass, these are, the agnus dei, the kyrie and the gloria. Maybe those 3 where only considered compulsary in the old latin rite, unsure of the churches stance now but perhaps a good indicator of whether you have attended mass or not, and also attending mass perhaps isn't enough, one must participate in the mass, at least these 3 parts.

Posted

God isn't about "counting" and getting to the Gospel, etc.  You need to attend Mass once a week.  Period.  Now, if you're in a car accident, if something goes awry, like going to a church that didn't have Mass and needing to drive across town to the only other Mass that day...God is understanding.

 

If you come in 30 minutes before Mass begins but spend it daydreaming about world domination and then reailze that it's the homily somehow, God is probably less understanding depending on how willfull the daydreaming was.

 

Its just like the fast.  Are you going to the 11am Mass, welll the letter of the law is to fast for an hour before communion so you'd need to stop eating at 10:30.  There is a difference spiritually between stopping at Dunkins and getting a Boston Creme with a tall coffee and jamming it into your pie hole becuase you can and letting a family breakfast run late and realizing that you're licking syrup off your fingers at 10:30.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...