veritasluxmea Posted September 26, 2014 Posted September 26, 2014 Does anyone have a (good) recommendation for a book on Orthodoxy? Like a nice, thoughtful commentary on the history/theology/culture of Orthodoxy, what it's been and done in the past and what it's doing now and where we're going from here. What I'm not looking for here is an apologetics book for Orthodoxy. I'm thinking something along the lines of a book written by a theologian who's a convert, or has spent a lot of time in Orthodox-dominated circles, something along the lines of "101 questions on Orthodoxy", that's thorough and honest. Secondly, does anyone know of a book that discusses the claims of Orthodoxy from a Catholic apologetics standpoint? Like the stuff from Catholic Answers? One that's actually GOOD and insightful, not cookie-cutter... Or if you have a combination of books but a bunch of different people, and the order you think they should be read, like starting with history and ending in apologetics and switching between different biases- that would be even better. Thanks :)
PhuturePriest Posted September 26, 2014 Posted September 26, 2014 Why didn't you just private message Marigold? :P
Amppax Posted September 26, 2014 Posted September 26, 2014 From an Orthodox perspective, Kallistos Ware's The Orthodox Church. From a Catholic perspective Aiden Nichols Rome and the Eastern Churches.
veritasluxmea Posted September 26, 2014 Author Posted September 26, 2014 Why didn't you just private message Marigold? :P He he, I get it ;) But in all seriousness, I don't know if she would have any recommendations, if they would be helpful to me, or even if she wants to give out recommendations. I would love her input but whatever, it's cool. From an Orthodox perspective, Kallistos Ware's The Orthodox Church. From a Catholic perspective Aiden Nichols Rome and the Eastern Churches. Thanks, I will look those up.
marigold Posted September 26, 2014 Posted September 26, 2014 Why didn't you just private message Marigold? :P Because that would be scary. Going to have a think about it Veritas.
CatherineM Posted September 26, 2014 Posted September 26, 2014 If you want a book about historical dissenters and how the orthodox view was decided upon, Discent From the Creed is a great read.
Nihil Obstat Posted September 26, 2014 Posted September 26, 2014 From an Orthodox perspective, Kallistos Ware's The Orthodox Church. From a Catholic perspective Aiden Nichols Rome and the Eastern Churches. I was going to recommend Ware as well. I would highly recommend Geoffrey Hull's book Banished Heart: Origins of Heteroproxis in the Catholic Church. It is not strictly about Orthodoxy, but its scope includes the points at which the eastern and western Churches began to diverge, the reasons for that divergence, and its implications down the road. It is primarily in the context of the Liturgy, but by nature that leads into theology and ecclesiology as well. It gives a very interesting, IMO rather unique perspective on the Orthodox, from a Catholic perspective. And I would daresay that it is a very friendly perspective too.
Lady-Indis Posted September 26, 2014 Posted September 26, 2014 What about GK Chesterton's book, Orthodoxy? Hard reading, but very rewarding. I don't know if that's what you are looking for though..
Amppax Posted September 27, 2014 Posted September 27, 2014 What about GK Chesterton's book, Orthodoxy? Hard reading, but very rewarding. I don't know if that's what you are looking for though.. The OP is specifically looking for books about Eastern Orthodoxy. While Orthodoxy is a great book, it isn't about Eastern Christianity.
Amppax Posted September 27, 2014 Posted September 27, 2014 (edited) Of the two books I recommended, I've only read parts. A little of Ware, but more of Nichols. I can't recommend Nichols enough, not the easiest read, but excellent. Edited September 27, 2014 by Amppax
Egeria Posted September 27, 2014 Posted September 27, 2014 Here are some standard introductory books on Orthodoxy: Metropolitan Kallistos Ware's The Orthodox Church has already been mentioned and is something of a classic. It provides a historical overview and general description of Orthodox practice. (It is also available on line here). Metropolitan Kallistos' The Orthodox Way is also really good as a supplement to that. It provides more of an introduction to Orthodox faith and life. Metropolitan Hilarion Alfeyev's The Mystery of Faith. An Introduction to the Teaching and Spirituality of the Orthodox Church is similar to The Orthodox Faith, but is more extensive. Father Alexander Schmemann's For the Life of the World: Sacraments and Orthodoxy is also something of a recent classic that is well-worth reading. Father Thomas Hopko's The Orthodox Faith: An Elementary Handbook on the Orthodox Church is a good basic introduction in four volumes that cover doctrine, worship, the Bible and Church history, and spirituality. It can be found online here. Father Vassilios Papavassiliou's Journey to the Kingdom. An Insider's Look at the Liturgy and Beliefs of the Eastern Orthodox Church is a very accessible introduction to Orthodox faith through the participation in the Divine Liturgy. (His other little books on Advent, Holy Week and Lent also give a very good and accessible entry into these seasons through the liturgical texts).
Egeria Posted September 27, 2014 Posted September 27, 2014 Oh, and I forgot the best of all! This is not a typical "introduction" and it is more theological, although written from a personal perspective: Father Andrew Louth's Introducing Eastern Orthodox Theology. This was originally written as a series of lectures delivered at the Amsterdam Centre for Eastern Orthodox Theology (that I think were part of a Master's programme that included non-Orthodox students) and the original lectures can be found here. (Scroll to the bottom and find the pdf files called OrthodoxTheologyPersonalIntroductionLouth...).
marigold Posted September 27, 2014 Posted September 27, 2014 (edited) I second the Metropolitan Kallistos recommendation, and Egeria's first list - haven't read the Louth. How about The Orthodox Church: An Introduction to Its History, Doctrine, and Spiritual Culture by John McGuckin - there's your theologian who's a convert. Thanks to Nihil for the Banished Heart suggestion. Maybe I've been looking in the wrong places, but I've been very disappointed by the standard of Catholic writing about the Orthodox Church. One of you guys could change that? :) Edited September 27, 2014 by marigold
Egeria Posted September 27, 2014 Posted September 27, 2014 How about The Orthodox Church: An Introduction to Its History, Doctrine, and Spiritual Culture by John McGuckin - there's your theologian who's a convert. I've heard good things about it Marigold, but have not yet got hold of it because of the price - although that now seems less than it was when it first came out. But I like what I've read of Fr McGuckin, so am sure it would be worth getting hold of. And it's probably ideal in this context.
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye Posted September 27, 2014 Posted September 27, 2014 how about ' the fullness of truth, no need to look any further' by O.G original gospel.
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye Posted September 27, 2014 Posted September 27, 2014 like be carefull, we are encouraged to praise and worship and pray to our god with the other christians and have fellowship but just be careful.
Nihil Obstat Posted September 27, 2014 Posted September 27, 2014 Thanks to Nihil for the Banished Heart suggestion. Maybe I've been looking in the wrong places, but I've been very disappointed by the standard of Catholic writing about the Orthodox Church. One of you guys could change that? :) Yeah, like I mentioned, it is not precisely about Orthodoxy, but give the themes it deals with it actually gets quite in depth on the Liturgy in the east and west in the first millenium, the development of theology, and their more divergent developments after the schism. I did say that I consider it friendly towards Orthodoxy. I think that is true, but Banished Heart does not pull any punches. Both for western and eastern Christianity, the book does point out faults on both sides, some of which had a role in causing the split. For the west, some of the main shortcomings Hull points out are a really consistent sense of liturgical (and to a great extent theological) imperialism, i.e. western theologians trying to impose western understandings on eastern Christians, who tended to be regarded as theologically suspect. Also the west has been suffering from a sort of creeping ultramontanism, at least since Trent as a response to Protestant rejection of authority. On the other hand, while the west has not always safeguarded her Liturgy, the east - at least according to Hull - has generally been quicker to adopt heterodox formulae for the sake of secular rulers, especially some of the emperors. And he goes into detail on times when this has happened. So in general I found it to be a very fair book, and invaluable for understanding the current crisis in the Church.
marigold Posted September 27, 2014 Posted September 27, 2014 how about ' the fullness of truth, no need to look any further' by O.G original gospel. like be carefull, we are encouraged to praise and worship and pray to our god with the other christians and have fellowship but just be careful. I do think we are not only encouraged but obligated to find out as much as we can understand about other traditions - it's not good enough to say that X, Y or Z are wrong, you have to know why and how they came to be that way. I was tempted to be snarky and just put 'the Bible' too, but I don't think that really cuts it when someone is asking honestly and without prejudice on their side. Wouldn't look very good for me on the Last Day, would it. For myself (and in my experience this is also the usual Orthodox position) I would say the opposite of your second statement - it's great to dialogue and talk things out and get to know one another as people, but you don't pray with the heterodox.
marigold Posted September 27, 2014 Posted September 27, 2014 Yeah, like I mentioned, it is not precisely about Orthodoxy, but give the themes it deals with it actually gets quite in depth on the Liturgy in the east and west in the first millenium, the development of theology, and their more divergent developments after the schism. I did say that I consider it friendly towards Orthodoxy. I think that is true, but Banished Heart does not pull any punches. Both for western and eastern Christianity, the book does point out faults on both sides, some of which had a role in causing the split. For the west, some of the main shortcomings Hull points out are a really consistent sense of liturgical (and to a great extent theological) imperialism, i.e. western theologians trying to impose western understandings on eastern Christians, who tended to be regarded as theologically suspect. Also the west has been suffering from a sort of creeping ultramontanism, at least since Trent as a response to Protestant rejection of authority. On the other hand, while the west has not always safeguarded her Liturgy, the east - at least according to Hull - has generally been quicker to adopt heterodox formulae for the sake of secular rulers, especially some of the emperors. And he goes into detail on times when this has happened. So in general I found it to be a very fair book, and invaluable for understanding the current crisis in the Church. Good! I'm glad it doesn't pull punches. Blind spots and pulling the wool over our own/others' eyes causes us a lot of problems. I don't want to feel superior to you, I want to know what the truth is. My priest was once asked by a catechumen about the Inquisition and whether we consider ourselves 'blameless' because we haven't perpetrated something like that. He said, 'Well, we don't have that blood on our hands. But we have a lot of other blood on our hands.' I'll try to get a copy. :)
Amppax Posted September 27, 2014 Posted September 27, 2014 Don't get me started on the Inquisition, especially considering it's lack of relevance to this thread.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now