Didacus Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 This document dares to say that Christianity is more peaceful than islam. What gull! And its linked to Christian Answers too! Read this little snipet: Christianity, by contrast, is a universal religion, meant for all peoples in all countries. It has much greater breadth, and much lower intrinsic potential for violence. Its founder - Christ - was a martyr, who refused to fight to save his life. Thought the new Testament acknowledges that the old Testament revelation is from God, it does not contain new commands to use violence, as Christianity was not to be allied from its birth to a state in the way Judaism was. the fact that in Christianityu church and state are distinct means that as a religion Christianity has less potential for violence since it is not called upon to use force in the way a state is. this, coupled with Jesus' own example and his "love thy enemy" teachings (e.g. matt. 5:44), gives Christianity less inaate potential for violence." Link: http://www.catholic.com/documents/endless-jihad-the-truth-about-islam-and-violence the document goes on to describe Mohammed as a warlord - obviously, Jesus was every bit as much of a warlord as Mohammed. Worse even! We can`t deny the violence perpetrated by Jesus, any more than we cannot deny the purely peaceful nature of Mohammed. I think we should all come together and criticize this site for blatant islamophobic remarks, as well as bigotry. We should ask that they apologize to the Islamic world for their disregard to a purely peaceful religion and people who have never, ever, ever, done anything wrong to their neighbors and only ask to live in peace. We should also note that they should apologize for the centuries of Christian oppression and evils done towards the Islamic world as they are nothing more than our victims; and innocent victims at that! Who is with me?
Not The Philosopher Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 Gull? I think he meant to say Gaul.
Aragon Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 I agree that Islam has many troubling aspects and that these are used by many people to justify violence. I don't think this kind of rhetoric from our side is helpful in achieving peace. It only inflames the situation and has the potential to anger and radicalise otherwise ordinary Muslims.
PhuturePriest Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 I think he meant to say Gaul. Gaul indeed had very interesting tribes which fought and were ultimately conquered by the Roman Empire, but I'm not sure what it has to do with the statement .
Norseman82 Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 Gull? obviously, Jesus was every bit as much of a warlord as Mohammed. Worse even! We can`t deny the violence perpetrated by Jesus, any more than we cannot deny the purely peaceful nature of Mohammed. I presume you are making a satirical point regarding watering down Catholicism for the sake of political correctness?
CatherineM Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 I thought this was going to be about people bigoted against Christians.
Gabriela Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 "G" is very near to "b" on the keyboard.
Gabriela Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 obviously, Jesus was every bit as much of a warlord as Mohammed. Worse even! We can`t deny the violence perpetrated by Jesus, any more than we cannot deny the purely peaceful nature of Mohammed. Right here is where you lost me.
HisChildForever Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 Right here is where you lost me. He's being sarcastic.
John Ryan Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 (edited) The trouble with Islam and the Qur'an is that it is a regression to Judaism and the Old Testament. Mohammad comes off as a Moses type figure. Instead of this message of love, mercy and kindness to our enemies, we find the same dichotomy between the Knights and the Barbarians, the Chosen and the Gentile. The caveat is Sufism, of which I hold the highest respect. Edited September 28, 2014 by John Ryan
Aragon Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 The trouble with Islam and the Qur'an is that it is a regression to Judaism and the Old Testament. Mohammad comes off as a Moses type figure. Instead of this message of love, mercy and kindness to our enemies, we find the same dichotomy between the Knights and the Barbarians, the Chosen and the Gentile. The caveat is Sufism, of which I hold the highest respect. This is a great point. I never thought of it that way.
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 (edited) He's being sarcastic. The holy catholic church villainizes sarcasm and mockery. I think it says so in the chatechism. :) no pun intended didicaus. just saying. Edited September 28, 2014 by Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
PhuturePriest Posted October 1, 2014 Posted October 1, 2014 The holy catholic church villainizes sarcasm and mockery. I think it says so in the chatechism. :) no pun intended didicaus. just saying. The Catholic Church nowhere says sarcasm is sinful or not allowed, and I'd like you to cite your claims.
veritasluxmea Posted October 1, 2014 Posted October 1, 2014 The holy catholic church villainizes sarcasm and mockery. I think it says so in the chatechism. :) no pun intended didicaus. just saying. The Catholic Church nowhere says sarcasm is sinful or not allowed, and I'd like you to cite your claims. Are these all... sarcastic?
PhuturePriest Posted October 1, 2014 Posted October 1, 2014 Are these all... sarcastic? He's said before quite seriously that the Church says sarcasm is sinful, but he's never been able to cite it.
Socrates Posted October 2, 2014 Posted October 2, 2014 I agree that Islam has many troubling aspects and that these are used by many people to justify violence. I don't think this kind of rhetoric from our side is helpful in achieving peace. It only inflames the situation and has the potential to anger and radicalise otherwise ordinary Muslims. I doubt it. Those hardcore "extremist" Muslims who are willing to wage violent Jihad, I'm sure, could care less whether or not "infidels" think Islam is violent. (They are more than willing to commit violence in the cause of Islam, and obviously have no problem with Islam being violent.) Likewise, non-violent Muslims would be unlikely to join violent "radical" groups on the basis of Christians considering their religion violent. ("How dare you say Islam is violent?! I will kill you all to prove how non-violent we are!") We shouldn't avoid speaking politically incorrect truths out of fear of "inflaming radicals." The unwillingness of many Western liberals to acknowledge the reality of Islam has done nothing to defuse radical Islam, and has actually played right into their hands. (For them, the more we keep our heads in the sand, the better.) The trouble with Islam and the Qur'an is that it is a regression to Judaism and the Old Testament. Mohammad comes off as a Moses type figure. Instead of this message of love, mercy and kindness to our enemies, we find the same dichotomy between the Knights and the Barbarians, the Chosen and the Gentile. The caveat is Sufism, of which I hold the highest respect. But we Catholics/Christians consider Moses a genuine prophet of the Most High God, unlike Mohammed. There is such a thing as just war, and it is wrong to consider Jesus Christ and "the God of the Old Testament" as being at odds. The trouble with Islam is that it is a false religion based on the teachings of a false prophet, which explicitly denies Christ as God and Savior, and makes the Gospels to be lies (they claim Jesus was really a prophet who preached Islam, and that He was neither killed nor resurrected.) That much is true of both violent and "peaceful" schools of Islam.
Deus te Amat Posted October 2, 2014 Posted October 2, 2014 He's said before quite seriously that the Church says sarcasm is sinful, but he's never been able to cite it. Lemme help. CCC 2481: "Boasting or bragging is an offense against truth. So is irony aimed at disparaging someone by maliciously caricaturing some aspect of his behavior." Sarcasm: Originmid 16th century: from French sarcasme, or via late Latin from late Greek sarkasmos, from Greek sarkazein ‘tear flesh,’ in late Greek ‘gnash the teeth, speak bitterly’ (fromsarx, sark- ‘flesh’).
beatitude Posted October 2, 2014 Posted October 2, 2014 (edited) Didacus, almost all the threads I've seen from you are about Islam being violent. No matter what views any of us might have on this other religion or that other philosophy, I don't think posting repetitively about its evils and Christianity's superior nature is going to achieve anything for anyone. What are you trying to accomplish? I have been living and working in a conflict zone for most of my adult life, with people who are extremely vulnerable (those with intellectual disabilities and psychiatric conditions, who are often shunned and marginalised even in peaceful places and times). I also did similar work in my home country, where people with conditions like Down Syndrome are still institutionalized sometimes and still perceived as not being fully people, which remains the case all over the world. One of the things this experience has taught me is that the roots of violence and violence really are present in our own hearts and that the only way to fight them is by keeping our eyes on the humanity of our brother even when it's hard to see. For us this obviously means looking first to the cross, where Jesus appeared 'as one to make men screen their faces', and 'so disfigured that he seemed barely human'. The cruelty of the killers in IS disfigures them, makes them seem barely human, but because of the cross we should be able to recognise that God made them lovingly and he loves them even now, they are still precious in his sight, they're our lost brothers and sisters and we need to pray for them. (We may pay lip service to this idea, but do we really feel it? Do we really love these people? And are we trying to?) For some people the actions of IS may disfigure the perceptions of the Muslim people who share their neighbourhood. Yesterday I heard someone from a friend's church proclaiming that he hoped ISIS members burn in hell, and I keep seeing so many acidic snarky comments about 'the religion of peace' and the superiority of Christianity. Our Christianity is manifested in our compassion, and I don't see how this attitude helps to show our Gospel for what it is, or allows us to love others better. And what's the point? When we die we won't be judged on whether our religion was objectively better than another person's, but on how we lived our faith, through the mercy of Jesus. If we want others to reach that mercy we have to show it in our own lives, starting with how we talk and think about others - and to paraphrase the Fatima prayer, especially those who need it most. I don't see how this kind of thing helps us with that. Edited to add: this seems a good place to draw attention to this thread - pledging to pray the rosary for peace during the month of October. Edited October 2, 2014 by beatitude
veritasluxmea Posted October 2, 2014 Posted October 2, 2014 Lemme help. CCC 2481: "Boasting or bragging is an offense against truth. So is irony aimed at disparaging someone by maliciously caricaturing some aspect of his behavior." Sarcasm: I would argue here that it would be wrong to use sarcasm when it's rude, mean, belittling, and uncharitable. Maybe I'm not seeing it, but the quote doesn't say sarcasm is by its nature wrong. Sometimes sarcasm can be positive and not about anyone in particular, in which case it would be ok to use.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now