Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

How American Parenting Is Killing Marriage


Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted

My understanding is that we are to love all equally, in that the definition of love is to will the good of another. We are to will that all go to heaven and that all serve God and be happy, and we are to do this equally. This doesn't mean you can't enjoy being with some more than others (meaning it's perfectly acceptable to enjoy alone time with your spouse more than your children), but that doesn't mean you love your spouse more and your children less.

 

Is this on target with all that's been said thus far?

Archaeology cat
Posted

Honestly, I thought it was stupid, and I'm surprised so many people I know liked it.
Here's why. My husband agreed with me that it's not one or the other, that you have to love your spouse over your kids or your kids over your spouse. We feel that the nature--the vocation--of being parents is that you sacrifice yourselves for your kids, and so kids' needs must come first, especially when they are very young. But the love between spouses and the love between parents and children are BOTH important; it's not a competition, or at least it hasn't ever been for us.
I would never say that I love my husband more than my kids, and my husband wouldn't say that he loves me more than the kids, either. Our love for each other and our love for our kids is *different,* and we don't see it as a competition. We don't feel at all like our relationship with our kids comes at the expense of our relationship with each other. Our relationship must be a strong foundation, and in that sense it comes first, but that doesn't mean that we love each other MORE than we love our kids, or our kids MORE than we love each other.
Love is not quantifiable. What a mercenary view of it! It seems to totally leave out the supernatural.
I read the advice of the two Saints I look to most regarding parenting--St. John Bosco and Bd. Zelie Martin--and I can't imagine they would agree with this article. I think the author is looking at the entire issue through the completely wrong lens.
Maybe that's just me, though.


You said what I thought.

Also, my first two were born overseas, so I have lived in another country. I also had a lot of international friends there, and my kids' godparents are different nationalities than where I lived (Kieran's are from The Gambia, and Charlotte's godmother is English-Filipina and grew up in Italy). I saw lots of different parenting styles, some I liked and some I didn't. I'd say my style most closely matched that of my Zimbabwean friends. A mutual British friend said she couldn't understand why they never wanted a babysitter, until they finally explained to her that they were a family and didn't do things without their children. We are pretty much the same way. But we also work on our own relationship. We don't see it as a competition.
Archaeology cat
Posted

I do agree with the authors' observation that parenting is almost seen in religious terms, so that if you do something different, you are seen as a bad parent, not just a different one. We are unfortunately seeing the consequences of that as more parents have CPS called on them for simply letting their kids play outside without the parent standing over them.

Posted

I think there are a lot of legitimate criticisms about helicopter parenting and making your child the center of the universe. I don't agree those things are healthy for the child, even though the child may be outwardly successful because of it. But I don't see any hard evidence that this is what leads to the destruction of marriage. There's no data just speculation that is perhaps plausible, but there are simpler explanations: hedonism, utilitarianism, egoism; trends that have more or less taken hold of american culture.

Posted

It hurts marriage in that many of the kids created by helicopter parenting don't get married.

Posted

Curiousing, you don't have kids, do you? Not saying that to be smug, just saying that having kids sometimes changes your perspective on certain things.
 

 

I have four kids and I agree with the article. The greatest gift I could ever give my children is to put their mother first.

Posted

I have four kids and I agree with the article. The greatest gift I could ever give my children is to put their mother first.


I tried to clarify earlier that I wasn't asking curiousing that because I felt that people with kids wouldn't agree with the article, but more because of the curiousing's specific comments referring to married people/people with kids and how they act in regard to their social lives. Even the most sanguine, extroverted people I know had a big change in their social lives after they got married and had kids. A lot of single people complain about that and say it'll never happen to them ... And then, inevitably, to some degree, it does once they themselves get married and have kids. It was that kind of change in perspective I was mostly referring to.

I have a bunch of friends with lots of kids who agree with the article, and I understand, and agree with, the underlying truth it was trying to express, that parenting should never come between spouses and cause their marriage to be put on the back burner. But I still think it was done very stupidly and in a fuddled manner, and I still don't think it's a good thing to say that one loves their spouse MORE than their kids, or their kids MORE than their spouse. To each his own, though. That's just the way I personally feel about it. :)
Posted

When people begin seriously dating, their world gets smaller.
When they get married and have kids, their world gets smaller still.
And that is the nature of the vocation to family life.
Marriage shrinks a person's world, it limits the horizon in a meaningful way to the 2, 3, 4 or however many souls belong to the family unit.
Whereas people in religious communities are free to be more open to others, and single people still more free to be open.
The price for the freedom of singleness is living with the knowledge that most everyone you ever know will always put someone else before you (their spouse, their children.)

Let me tell you a story so you know I know what I'm talking about. On my 24th birthday, I was very unwell. Too sick to leave my bed or have any cake. Severely annoying. I wanted my sister to stay with me that day, and thought it would be easy to guilt her into doing this. But she did not stay with me, because it was a Saturday night and she had a date w/ her very serious boyfriend. A few days later I went for a long hospital stay. My sister came to visit me after work, but only when she could arrange her date to be somewhere in the part of the city where I was hospitalized. When her date was elsewhere, she did not visit. Let me tell you, I was tremendously butthurt over this, and frankly still am now that I think about it. As twins, we'd always been each others number 1 person. But she was dating the person she was planning to marry, and that is the nature of that vocation. A very difficult lesson for me as a singleton. But that is the nature of my vocation. Basically, pick your poison. Or rather, pick the way you'd like to sacrifice.

Posted

The catechism says, "Marriage and the family are ordered to the good of the spouses and to the procreation and education of children. The love of the spouses and the begetting of children create among members of the same family personal relationships and primordial responsibilities."
 
So really, it talks about spouses loving each other, but nothing of loving your children--just creating them. lol
 
It goes on to quote, "He who loves his son will not spare the rod. . . . He who disciplines his son will profit by him." - Sir 30:1-2.

Obviously, I'm not saying we shouldn't love our kids, but it seems to me that the church teaches that there is a definite order of priority.
 
I also like what my friend Matthew Warner had to say about this topic: "The truth is that the very best way to love your kids is to love their mother first. When you love their mother first, you aren't choosing her over the kids. You're choosing to love your kids in the most powerful way possible: through your marriage. And by providing them with what they MOST need - not your friendship or personal relationship or attention - but with a stable family held together by a strong, loving marriage."

Posted

Yup! Not disagreeing with you at all there. :)

Posted (edited)

Honestly, I thought it was stupid, and I'm surprised so many people I know liked it.

Here's why. My husband agreed with me that it's not one or the other, that you have to love your spouse over your kids or your kids over your spouse. We feel that the nature--the vocation--of being parents is that you sacrifice yourselves for your kids, and so kids' needs must come first, especially when they are very young. But the love between spouses and the love between parents and children are BOTH important; it's not a competition, or at least it hasn't ever been for us.

I would never say that I love my husband more than my kids, and my husband wouldn't say that he loves me more than the kids, either. Our love for each other and our love for our kids is *different,* and we don't see it as a competition. We don't feel at all like our relationship with our kids comes at the expense of our relationship with each other. Our relationship must be a strong foundation, and in that sense it comes first, but that doesn't mean that we love each other MORE than we love our kids, or our kids MORE than we love each other.

Love is not quantifiable. What a mercenary view of it! It seems to totally leave out the supernatural.

I read the advice of the two Saints I look to most regarding parenting--St. John Bosco and Bd. Zelie Martin--and I can't imagine they would agree with this article. I think the author is looking at the entire issue through the completely wrong lens.

Maybe that's just me, though.

 

I also thought the blog piece was stupid, and had little of substance to support its extremely questionable thesis that our society over-values children and parenthood.  (Any society which kills and discards so many unborn children because they are inconvenient certainly does not over-value children.)

It sounded to me like the ranting of a bitter childless person.

(And really, anyone upset over "baby on board" signs on cars needs to get a life.)

 

I also totally agree that love of spouse and love of children should not be in conflict, or measured against one another.

 

In my experience, I think that having, loving, and caring for children actually strengthens the marriage bond.  This reflects what our pastor told us, that children help give a needed outward focus to married life and love.

 

I think the idea that excessive valuing or love of children is the cause of high divorce rates is nonsense.

Divorce rats actually started to sky-rocket following the sexual revolution of the '60s/'70s, and plenty of childless couples get divorced

I'm sure many of the empty-nesters getting divorced stayed together long as they did "for the sake of the children," but I'd bet that most of them would have divorced much sooner had they been childless. 

It's also dubious that their marriages would have been stronger or better had they been less devoted to their children.

 

Lack of proper discipline of children, and spoiled kids are a genuine problem, but this is not a matter of loving them too much over one's spouse.  Discipline is part of love, and actually takes more effort than just letting kids have their way all the time.

Edited by Socrates

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...