Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Weekday Communion Service Without A Priest


Recommended Posts

The Bus Station
Posted (edited)

I unknowingly walked into one of these this morning, thinking I was going to Mass.  Later found out that it was held because our diocesan priests are on retreat this week.  The whole service was done very reverently, but I didn't quite know what to make of it.  Is it better to have a weekday communion service or to just hold out until Sunday when a priest can say Mass?

Edited by The Bus Station
puellapaschalis
Posted

As a personal opinion, communion services should be avoided unless it's a) a Sunday and b) the distance to the nearest Mass is prohibitive. And even then I'd set that distance pretty high.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Communion services are just fine, because they act as a stop-gap for realities like priests having other obligations that prevent them from being able to say mass at their parish, without sacrificing a community's opportunity to come together in prayer and receive communion. As long as they aren't seen as a "replacement" for a mass or done in an irreverent way, I see no problem. It's a reality that comes with a priest shortage, and whether or not they're a good thing really depends on how and why they're being done. 

 

Some people don't like them, and would rather wait until they can attend mass on Sunday, and that's perfectly fine too.

blazeingstar
Posted

It's a reverent way to distribute communion when Mass is unavailable.  Don't make more of it than it is.  I know at a local church we have communion service (ironically also on Wednesdays, during the normal Daily Mass time) in order to allow the priest to say Mass at a nursing home dementia wing (not open to the public).

Posted

Communion services are just fine, because they act as a stop-gap for realities like priests having other obligations that prevent them from being able to say mass at their parish, without sacrificing a community's opportunity to come together in prayer and receive communion. As long as they aren't seen as a "replacement" for a mass or done in an irreverent way, I see no problem. It's a reality that comes with a priest shortage, and whether or not they're a good thing really depends on how and why they're being done. 

 

Some people don't like them, and would rather wait until they can attend mass on Sunday, and that's perfectly fine too.

 

This largely is the same as what the bishops said. Yay! 

 

http://www.usccb.org/prayer-and-worship/the-mass/frequently-asked-questions/weekday-celebrations-in-the-absence-of-a-priest.cfm

Posted

I unknowingly walked into one of these this morning, thinking I was going to Mass.  Later found out that it was held because our diocesan priests are on retreat this week.  The whole service was done very reverently, but I didn't quite know what to make of it.  Is it better to have a weekday communion service or to just hold out until Sunday when a priest can say Mass?

 

Are you in Indiana? Cuz where I live, it's the same thing this week.

 

:-/

LouisvilleFan
Posted

I unknowingly walked into one of these this morning, thinking I was going to Mass.  Later found out that it was held because our diocesan priests are on retreat this week.  The whole service was done very reverently, but I didn't quite know what to make of it.  Is it better to have a weekday communion service or to just hold out until Sunday when a priest can say Mass?

 

Sunday Mass is an obligation, so I don't see how it compares to an optional weekday Communion Service. You would receive the same grace from Holy Communion regardless. 

Posted

Sunday Mass is an obligation, so I don't see how it compares to an optional weekday Communion Service. You would receive the same grace from Holy Communion regardless. 

There are still additional graces from the Mass itself. If you couldn't receive Communion, where does that leave you?

Posted

...as what the US bishops said.

 

FTFY.
 

 

Meh, on a forum based in the US, talking to someone from the US, I don't feel the need to be specific. Thanks though. 

The Bus Station
Posted (edited)

Thanks for the responses, everyone. :)

 

 

Are you in Indiana? Cuz where I live, it's the same thing this week.

 

No, curiousing, I am not in Indiana -- funny coincidence! ... or conspiracy :ninja:

Edited by The Bus Station

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...