Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is It Safe To Study Theology At Notre Dame?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Cuz I'm considering doing a Master's there. I just wanna' be sure, given... you know... stuff that's happened.

Posted

Full Disclosure: This is my first post, and I attend the University of Notre Dame

 

Scott Hahn's son is studying theology there, so I think you're in the clear.  From my experience, the Theology students are very in line with church teaching.

Posted

Notre Dame is a great place for learning how to think. It is not the place to go if you have a significant need for school to show you what to think.

Posted

Full Disclosure: This is my first post, and I attend the University of Notre Dame

 

Scott Hahn's son is studying theology there, so I think you're in the clear.  From my experience, the Theology students are very in line with church teaching.

 

Welcome, Xanti! And thanks for your input! :)

Posted

Welcome, Xanti! And thanks for your input! :)

 

Thanks!  You guys have a nice group here.  Thought I'd join in.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Notre Dame is a great place for learning how to think. It is not the place to go if you have a significant need for school to show you what to think.

 

This is a really good statement for any graduate theology program.  It might sound a little harsh, but you really shouldn't be learning out of the catechism for graduate level theology (you should know the catechism already!). Grad school challenges your ideas, and makes you examine your own beliefs. :) 

Posted

My girlfriend is there, studying theology. She seems to think it is solid, although a couple professors are iffy. 

Posted

please no one take it that I am knocking people who want to go to school to learn what to think re: the contents of their religion. People have all kinds of reasons for going to school; more power to them all. But different schools are good for different things. Some schools are good for people who want to fill up their bucket, others are geared towards expanding the size of the bucket. You may or may not fill it up more in the process but that's not the main point.

God the Father
Posted

Notre Dame is perfectly safe as long as you stay away from the FroYo machines. Changed a lot of women's lives for the worse

Sponsa-Christi
Posted

I don't know too much about Notre Dame, so I can't really answer the original question. But I would tend to disagree with the going opinion here.

 

I think that when you're just starting out in theology (as opposed to when you are a seasoned grad student), you really do need to find a place where you can be truly formed, or "told how to think" to a certain extent. Learning to "think with the Church" in academic theology is a different thing from just being properly catechized. A lot of theology is based on certain paradigms, presuppositions, or fundamental ways of interpreting reality. These presuppositions can be very subtle, and you won't really be able to tell how important they are or be able to criticize "wrong" paradigms until you're much farther along in your studies.

 

So when you're a novice theology student, you need to find a place where you can trust your professors to lead you. I don't think this necessarily means that every single faculty member of your university has to be 100% totally orthodox on everything, but you should find a place where at the very least you can find a couple of good mentors. 

 

Posted

In another thread, you mention that you carry a gun. 

 

I think you will be safe studying theology while carrying a gun. In any college. 

Posted

Obama studied there and became the handsomest and smartest man in the whole country! So what are you waiting for?

Posted

Wait. Wha? Obama studied at ND?!

Catherine Therese
Posted

It's interesting that you have posed your question the way that you have. 

To me, it indicates a real desire to know Him more, and a real fear of being led astray. A few things from scripture worth mentioning: "The Truth will set you free" and "Perfect love casts out fear"... having put that on the table, though, it is nevertheless prudent to explore this possibility before jumping in... approaching it as a mini-discernment, really. Is HE the one calling you to pursue Him via an intellectual route? 

 

A few things to ask yourself (and Him) as you discern:

 

1. What do you seek? 

 

2. How strong/reliable is your own personal sensus fidei? Can you smell a rat? Could you identify when something didn't quite gel with Church teaching?

 

3. Do you have access to trusted priests and perhaps to other scholars or friends whom you know are faithful to Church teaching and live their faith actively? 

 

4. What is your reason for studying theology? Is it with a career direction in mind? Is it with personal growth in faith in mind? Will a theology degree give you what you seek?

 

5. Assuming you understand your own temperament and quirks and perks... are you the kind of person who recognises and loves God intellectually, emotionally, creatively or some other way? (Or some hybrid of the above?)

 

In posing these questions, I haven't imposed my opinion on how to interpret whatever your answers might be to the questions and therefore what decision you should make. But some of them might be helpful as you pray about your decision. 

God bless :)

Posted

What do you intend to do with your masters in theology? If it's to prepare yourself for a career as a catechist, then I wouldn't recommend it because those jobs are so few.

Posted

No.  Leprechauns periodically appear and punch the students and faculty.  They can jump too.

Posted

Thank you very much to everyone for your feedback. :)

 

I am considering the Master's because I'm getting a doctorate in communication and want to be able to teach homiletics in seminaries. Even if I can't get one of those (very sparse) jobs, though, I figure a Master's in theology would give me an edge in applications to small Catholic liberal arts colleges, too. So even though I'm really looking forward to studying theology, I'm doing it for primarily utilitarian purposes: to be able to teach my students better, and to get the job in the first place.

 

I really hope for the side perk of growing my faith, too, though. ;)

Posted

Wait. Wha? Obama studied at ND?!


No, the school just gave him an honorary degree when he visited there.

I'd recommend visiting the campus and interviewing the students and professors of the graduate theology program. I've heard that there are some orthodox professors there.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...