Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey all.

 

I've had an interesting question pop up in my mind over the last few days, and was hoping this might generate discussion/debate:

 

I don't see how drinking diet cola is any different than contraceptive sex.  Granted, they're obviously different in gravity.  Foods/beverages are supposed to have two purposes to nurture us physically and provide some sort of taste.  Diet soda does nothing to nurture us, and only provides some sort of taste.  Similarly, contraceptive sex divorces the two parts of sex (unitive, procreative).  How, other than magnitude, are these two things different?

Posted

Because one (contraception) completely goes against the very purpose of the action at hand. The other (diet soda) isn't all that good for you, sure, but it isn't preventing your body from working properly or in accord with its natural purpose of digestion.

Posted

I think socks are sinful

Posted
Foods/beverages are supposed to have two purposes to nurture us physically and provide some sort of taste.

 

I disagree with your premise from the get go.

Posted

I disagree with your premise from the get go.


Yes, I can't say I agree with the premise at all, either.

I understand what you're trying to say, but it's like comparing apples and Mount Everest, IMO! ;)
veritasluxmea
Posted

 

I don't see how drinking diet cola is any different than contraceptive sex.  

Can+t+tell+if+photoshop+or+autism+_c9db8

Posted

I just threw up in my mouth.

 

Not really relevant to the thread I just wanted to share <3

Not A Mallard
Posted

I remember there was a Mythbusters episode that dealt with Coke myths and one of them was about Coke being used as a spermicide (don't ask me how because I don't remember that part, and I probably don't want to either).  I thought this thread was going to be about that.

Posted

I think socks are sinful

 

Only if you're wearing them with sandals.  Come on people.

 

I disagree with your premise from the get go.

 

Okay, I'm not sure I agreed with myself after typing it out, but thought it was worth the post anyway.  The thought I came to is, I guess, what is the purpose of food then?

 

I understand what you're trying to say, but it's like comparing apples and Mount Everest, IMO! ;)

 

Yeah, I did a pretty poor job of writing what I meant.  I think I'll try again here in a bit.

Posted

Only if you're wearing them with sandals.  Come on people.

 

You  make a valid point

Posted

Because one (contraception) completely goes against the very purpose of the action at hand. The other (diet soda) isn't all that good for you, sure, but it isn't preventing your body from working properly or in accord with its natural purpose of digestion.

 

This is the rebuttal I was looking for. Makes a whole lot of sense.  Thank you.

 

(sorry, I read the posts from bottom to top)

Posted

Only if you're wearing them with sandals.  Come on people.

I confess to doing this on monastic retreats :hehe2: But I think wearing sandals with socks is a lesser evil than exposing rhino feet to the world. This didn't apply to me though -  I was just sinning by wearing socks and sandals :saint:

Credo in Deum
Posted

This thread is Lame Board material!

Posted

This thread is Lame Board material!

Boo

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...