Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

America's Superiority Complex


Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted

How do you think it started? What led to today's almost unbelievable nationalism and arrogance? What phrases, ideas, and things happened that you think were the seeds to America's superiority complex? I'm quite interested in what people think are the causes.

Posted

How do you think it started? What led to today's almost unbelievable nationalism and arrogance? What phrases, ideas, and things happened that you think were the seeds to America's superiority complex? I'm quite interested in what people think are the causes.

WWII started it, Hollywood ruined it.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Started with all that manifest destiny stuff, and took off from there.  Once you throw a divine mandate behind what you're doing, you're gonna feel unstoppable at any cost. 

 

Also, The Greatest Generation named themselves the Greatest Generation.  So. Yeah. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

Started with all that manifest destiny stuff, and took off from there.  Once you throw a divine mandate behind what you're doing, you're gonna feel unstoppable at any cost. 

 

Also, The Greatest Generation named themselves the Greatest Generation.  So. Yeah. 

 

"Manifest destiny stuff"?

 

I believe it was the great Bono in 1983 whom said "And so we're told this is the golden age/gold is the reason for the wars we wage."

 

It amazes me how people honestly believe America is the greatest country in the history of the world, and then once you dispute that and explain saying that means you think people from other countries are inferior, they just get angry and call you unpatriotic.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

Envy at not being Canada.

Posted

Envy at not being Canada.

justin_bieber_mugshot_0.jpg

 

 

 

I'm good

Posted

I think the idea of American superiority originated with the Puritans.  In an early American literature class that I took, we studied how the Puritans who founded New England in the early 17th century thought of themselves as a "special people, in a special place, doing special things."  They saw themselves as a group especially chosen by God to do his will in a divinely ordained place ("a city on a hill," as John Winthrop wrote).  In my opinion, this heritage of "specialness" has influenced a lot of American history, like with manifest destiny, as Basilisa Marie pointed out.

Posted (edited)

"Manifest destiny stuff"?

 

I believe it was the great Bono in 1983 whom said "And so we're told this is the golden age/gold is the reason for the wars we wage."

 

It amazes me how people honestly believe America is the greatest country in the history of the world, and then once you dispute that and explain saying that means you think people from other countries are inferior, they just get angry and call you unpatriotic.

 

Where do you get that nationalism infers that those who have it think other people are inferior? Explain the "Superiority Complex"? What constitutes a superiority complex in the citizens of a nation? What is the criteria?

 

Where is the evidence of this?

 

 

Edited by socalscout
PhuturePriest
Posted

Envy at not being Canada.

 

Canada is actually a good point, because it reminds me of Bieber, who is perfectly analogous to America's superiority complex. Justin Bieber made videos on Youtube, and then in a matter of no time whatsoever, he became a huge hit sensation. Girls wanted him, he was making millions of dollars, he was touring the world, and he had everything he wanted. Unless you're well-grounded, that type of instantaneous and overwhelming exposure is bound to give someone an ego the size of the sun. Likewise, America's first major act was beating arguably the most powerful empire in the world, and it went on to become of the most rich, powerul, succesful countries in the history of the world. As the country was founded by Freemasons, we didn't really have good grounding, so it only makes sense that America has a Bieber-sized ego.

Posted

"Manifest destiny stuff"?

 

Mid-nineteenth century, there was a belief that God had destined the USA to go from sea to sea. Westward expansion and all that. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

Where do you get that nationalism infers that those who have it think other people are inferior? Explain the "Superiority Complex"? What constitutes a superiority complex in the citizens of a nation? What is the criteria?

 

Where is the evidence of this?

 

When people say "America is the greatest country in the history of the world." First off, that's what is known as nationalism, which is strictly condemned by the Church. Secondly, that's a superiority complex. Why? Because if we're the best in the world, that means every other country is inferior to us. But we must ask ourselves the profound philosophical question: What is a country? It's not a government, as government is merely people in charge. It's not a set of laws, as laws are just ideas that dictate what people can and cannot do, based off what the government thinks is best and most efficient for its people. So what is a country? A group of people. So whether people realize it or not, by saying "We're the greatest country in the history of the world.", they are in fact saying "We as a people are superior to every other group of people in the history of the world." In simple terms, it means if someone from every nation in the world was set side by side and we had to deem who was the best one of them all, the answer would be the American simply based off the fact that he is American. It's illogical, it's dangerous, and it's what leads to things like Nazi Germany, which was notoriously nationalistic.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Mid-nineteenth century, there was a belief that God had destined the USA to go from sea to sea. Westward expansion and all that. 

 

I have never heard of this before. This is so messed up that I can't help but find it endlessly fascinating. I shall immediately learn everything I can about it.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Meh, as an American expat living in Europe, I see plenty of arrogance towards America and Americans that goes the other way just as much. There's a "your country is a mess/everything over here is better" attitude that I hear all the time. Nobody seems to be immune to this sort of thing.

Posted

Calvinist predestination.

Posted

I have never heard of this before. This is so messed up that I can't help but find it endlessly fascinating. I shall immediately learn everything I can about it.


Canada would tend to agree with you as we were a key target. "American dream" has also not helped.
Posted

I think the idea of American superiority originated with the Puritans.  In an early American literature class that I took, we studied how the Puritans who founded New England in the early 17th century thought of themselves as a "special people, in a special place, doing special things."  They saw themselves as a group especially chosen by God to do his will in a divinely ordained place ("a city on a hill," as John Winthrop wrote).  In my opinion, this heritage of "specialness" has influenced a lot of American history, like with manifest destiny, as Basilisa Marie pointed out.

 

 

Calvinist predestination.

 

These two factors go hand in hand.

Posted

 

America is the greatest country in the world. 

Maybe if you are English or French or Indian or whatever, your country has been good to you, so you think England or France or India is the greatest country in the world. More power to you.

 

My father was the first American in his family.

His mother, father, and brother had no country. Nowadays the place they came from has been absorbed by Hungary and Romania. But 60 years ago they had no country.They were displaced by the Nazis and they could not go back because of the Soviets. My grandfather made a deal to serve in the Korean War in exchange for the legal right to bring his wife and son over.  That was the price for American citizenship, and he was willing to pay.

 

And I'm glad he paid it.  If I'd been born over there I would have spent the first 5 years of my life under the iron fist of a genocidal Communist dictator before witnessing his overthrow in a violent revolution on Christmas Day. Instead, I was born in New Jersey and my 5th Christmas involved Santa cupcakes and a rental pony. America, eff yeah. 

 

All the whingers going on about immigration, here's what we do: Anybody who doesn't think America is the greatest country in the world can get the heck out, go find the country that is the greatest. Anybody who thinks America is the greatest country in the world and is willing to risk life and limb for a shot at being a part of it, let them come, as many as want to.

 

With the arrival of all the people who are literally dying to come here being cancelled out by the departure of all the ungrateful people who were born on third base and don't realize they didn't hit a triple, the net migration would probably be zero. Problem solved.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted

Puritanism - the roots of American life, including American political life. "We will build a city on a hill, a light unto the nations. We will show the world how to live" - Cotton Mather.

 

The English idea that they themselves were the pinnacle of civilization, that native peoples were primitive. But this same idea that WE are the pinnacle of all civilization can be found in the French, Spanish, the Portuguese, and other cultures as well. And the fact that the English - and eventually the Americans - did, in fact, kick the butts of the native Americans militarily. 

 

The vast natural resources of North America made people feel like they had everything they needed, as opposed to the countries from which they immigrated. And to a large extent, it was true. 

 

The enslavement of Black Africans - begun by the Portuguese, carried on by the Spanish, French, and English. Further evidence (to the English) that they were the pinnacle of civilization and other peoples are inferior. And the fact that the English - and eventually the Americans - did, in fact, kick the butts of the people they enslaved. 

 

The fact that the English kicked the butts of the French in the French & Indian Wars. 

 

The fact that the Americans kicked the butts of the English in the Revolutionary War. 

 

You win enough wars, you start to feel like God's on your side, so then the whole Manifest Destiny attitude kicked in. 

 

The fact that California was annexed, against the wishes of Mexico. 

 

The fact that the Americans kicked the butts of the Spanish and annexed Texas in the Mexican-American War. 

 

The fact that the Union kicked the butts of the Confederates in the Civil War. 

 

The fact that the Americans kicked the butts of the Spanish and annexed the Philippines in the Spanish-American War. 

 

The fact that, although they didn't exactly kick the butts of the Germans in WWI, they at least ground them to a truce, and then re-drew the boundaries of most of the European nations along with England and France. 

 

The fact that they kicked the butts of the Germans and the Japanese - two of the most effective war machines in human history - in WWII. And liberated the surviving Jews. And saved the world from Nazism. Which England probably couldn't have done on its own. And the Greatest Generation did NOT name themselves that - Tom Brokaw did. Brokaw is the son of Greatest Generation parents. 

 

The fact that the Americans outlasted the Communists - in collaboration with its Nato allies. 

 

The fact that we got to the moon first. 

 

The fact that everybody on earth wants our technology AND our blue jeans. 

 

The fact that we have the most productive economy on the face of the earth. 

 

Things like that. 

 

 

 

I'm not saying I support America's sense of superiority at all. I'm getting to the point where I can't stand this country or its inanity. But I can see where its people could develop a superiority complex. 

Basilisa Marie
Posted

I have never heard of this before. This is so messed up that I can't help but find it endlessly fascinating. I shall immediately learn everything I can about it.

 

Really? Yeah, it's a big part of public school American History education. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...