Anomaly Posted January 7, 2015 Posted January 7, 2015 I'm surprised nobody had started a Topic on the attack in Paris. A consequence of their own actions? Too much outrage? An example if the fundamental intolerance of Islam? Je Suis Charlie just another trendy Western fad? Any way similar to North Korea's attack on Sony Pictures? How important is freedom of speech when it's rude, crass, or offensive?
Lil Red Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 I haven't read much (read: anything) about it and I doubt I will tonight, but I did come across this buzz feed article: http://www.buzzfeed.com/ryanhatesthis/heartbreaking-cartoons-from-artists-in-response-to-the-ch#.don8yda83
ChristianGirlForever Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 I don't want to have a debate about it, but I read everything The NYT had about it today. I'm praying for all concerned.
Era Might Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 Ideology is always dangerous, whether it's wielded by presidents, terrorists, or alienated individuals.
veritasluxmea Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 (edited) I've heard people saying Je Suis Charlie doesn't have the right to freedom of speech because of its islamophobic and homophobic publications. I strongly disagree. Freedom of speech means you have the right to say, even write down or publish, what ever viewpoints you want without the fear of being killed. You can boycott, protest, argue against, protect children from, and ask for such publications to shut down, but you can never hurt or kill someone over it. Period. That is freedom of speech. As for Islam in general or intolerance or whatever, I think it's obvious there are issues with violence in the name of that religion. Whether their religious interpretations are technically wrong or not doesn't matter; such violence in the name of religion shouldn't be tolerated either. I have no idea how to help solve the issue, just saying. Edited January 8, 2015 by veritasluxmea
Kia ora Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 (edited) i think god is great. but i don't think god was happy today with his children as they ran down the street shouting that god is great. it seems to me that the real blasphemy was committed by his so called defenders. is this how the prophet of god would have wanted to be remembered? is this his legacy? god forgive us for our sins. Edited January 8, 2015 by Kia ora
puellapaschalis Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 As an update: there's been another shooting today (Thursday), killing a policewoman.
Amppax Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 I'm surprised nobody had started a Topic on the attack in Paris. A consequence of their own actions? Too much outrage? An example if the fundamental intolerance of Islam? Je Suis Charlie just another trendy Western fad? Any way similar to North Korea's attack on Sony Pictures? How important is freedom of speech when it's rude, crass, or offensive? Come on, why would we talk about international incidents? We have a drama thread running full steam!
Amppax Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 Also, Bill Donohue's being his usually whiny self, only now he's got everybody mad at him.
beatitude Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 (edited) I'm surprised nobody had started a Topic on the attack in Paris. A consequence of their own actions? Too much outrage? An example if the fundamental intolerance of Islam? Je Suis Charlie just another trendy Western fad? Any way similar to North Korea's attack on Sony Pictures? How important is freedom of speech when it's rude, crass, or offensive? To be honest, I think most of the people announcing 'Je suis Charlie' had never really heard of Charlie Hebdo before the murders, or if they had heard of them, hadn't taken much notice of the kind of things they publish. I remember when they ran a cartoon of the Christian girls who were kidnapped by Boko Haram. They portrayed them as ugly and pregnant, bawling that they wanted welfare money - expectant black mothers expecting the state to pay their way, basically. I don't think the rest of Charlie Hebdo's cartoons have been any better, so no, je ne suis pas Charlie. I appreciate satire, I think it has a vital place politically, but it's not necessarily satirical to make malicious fun of people in the way that publication repeatedly does. Satire punches up, not down. That said, people have a right to be rude, crass, and offensive. If that's how they want to waste their time on this earth, let them go ahead. For this reason, the murders can't be a consequence of Charlie Hebdo's own actions - there is a huge difference between being tasteless or even malicious and actually taking a human life. But even so, we shouldn't act as though Charlie Hebdo is some bastion of moral principles that we can all identify with. You can condemn the killings without behaving as though Hebdo itself is something marvellous. Edited January 8, 2015 by beatitude
Basilisa Marie Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 (edited) I don't stand with Charlie, but I do stand with freedom of speech. That magazine is disgusting and offensive on so many levels. But they don't deserve to be murdered over it, and tolerating their murder or saying that they brought it on themselves just sets a dangerous precedent. Freedom of speech means that tripe like Charlie Hebdo is free to publish without fear for their freedom and safety, and it's something I'm willing to live with. Speech is never deserving of death, no matter how bad it is. Edited January 8, 2015 by Basilisa Marie
Lil Red Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 Also, Bill Donohue's being his usually whiny self, only now he's got everybody mad at him. I could not possibly convey how much I loathe him.
Anomaly Posted January 9, 2015 Author Posted January 9, 2015 There will be riots in France this year. JSC represents many viewpoints and ideas that are serious socio-political conflicts in France. I think it's the beginning of a coming violent debate for the future of French society.
Era Might Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 There will be riots in France this year. JSC represents many viewpoints and ideas that are serious socio-political conflicts in France. I think it's the beginning of a coming violent debate for the future of French society. We have the Boston marathon bombing trial coming up here tooo. Something strange about the whole spectacle, the plastering of a young man's face constantly, something self-loathing about "justice" and our need to vent our hate on social misfits, who are still part of us, they aren't "other" than us. Riots, it seems, are just another, less civilized, form of that self-destruction. I'm not sure what to make of all these guerilla/terrorist outbursts, but I don't think a "clash of civilizations" or even "justice" is going to resolve it. I was watching Slavoj Zizek talking about the youth riots in England a few years back, arguing that far from being anti-social, their destruction of stores/property/etc. was itself a frustrated expression of capitalism, the only way they knew how to rebel was to loot and steal what they would otherwise buy and sell. Whatever we take from these events, it can't make us a smaller society. I don't think "free speech" in itself enlarges our freedom, there has to be a serious reflection on what are we using it for, which is not to say they "had it coming to them" but just to say, if we're going to risk death, is lampooning Muhammad really the hill we want to die on?
Anomaly Posted January 9, 2015 Author Posted January 9, 2015 Hebdo lampooned everything. All religions, politics, and economic systems. Freedom of speech is ultimately freedom to disagree. Violent disagreement is what diminishes humanity. I would argue that stifling speech is violence against ideas.
Era Might Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 Hebdo lampooned everything. All religions, politics, and economic systems. Freedom of speech is ultimately freedom to disagree. Violent disagreement is what diminishes humanity. I would argue that stifling speech is violence against ideas. I agree, but freedom of speech is specific to our social context. I don't think freedom of speech, in our sense, is anything natural, it's something we've created in the context of a society where the only "real" thing is the technical functioning of a system. Our idea of government/society is as a neutral technique, not to accomplish anything, but simply to keep everything flowing and functioning smoothly (speech, commerce, etc.). And even then, we still have limits to freedom of speech, but we do the policing ourselves...through the media we acknowledge, through who we publish/recognize, etc. Freedom of speech is a structure, not anything in itself...how we use it is the only thing that determines what kind of society/culture we have. I don't think we view freedom of speech as a vehicle to welcome everything, but simply as a technique to prevent slaughter, whether of this sort in Paris, or of older sorts, of the ancien regime.
Era Might Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 (edited) I'm just thinking out loud, not sure what I'm saying. I think my main point is just that I am not Charlie, I don't believe in communication as an irrelevant thing and "freedom of speech" the only value. To speak anything is to make a claim in the world, and I don't think "freedom of speech" is much of an answer to any of this, except on the level of law/rights. There's an episode of "Arrested Development" where they go to protest a military base, and they get stuck in a fenced in area where they're just protesting to the wind...that's freedom of speech, I guess, but without a real-world context, where the purpose is to affect the world, I don't know what value that has except to uphold the general right to speak. Edited January 9, 2015 by Era Might
Winchester Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 Freedom of speech simply means it is not legal for anyone to attack you over mere words. It doesn't mean people won't. It doesn't mean that if you taunt psychopaths that they won't kill you. Only that it won't be legal to do so.
Era Might Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 Freedom of speech simply means it is not legal for anyone to attack you over mere words. It doesn't mean people won't. It doesn't mean that if you taunt psychopaths that they won't kill you. Only that it won't be legal to do so. But what is speech except premeditation to action. To lampoon anything is to lay the ideological groundwork for a world where those things are irrelevant and destroyed. To lampoon Muhammad is to call for the destruction of Islam as a social idea (as is lampooning the Pope, for example, to destroy the Papacy as a social idea). To put down someone/something with words is to attempt to affect their being in the world (to make them be inferior in society, etc.). To defend/propose revolution is to commit revolution, no? It seems like Freedom of Speech, while it has opened up a neutral space to speak, has also made speech meaningless, just decoration to the "real" business of society which is law and order. In the context of religion, it's true that Catholics generally don't kill to defend the Pope, but that's mainly because they have already accepted the irrelevancy of the Papacy, they only believe it on on an abstract level. Back in the old days, when they did believe in it, the honor of the church was worth killing and dying for, as Islam remains to many.
Winchester Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 Speech leaves open exercise of the will. It is not the same thing as a gun in the ribs.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now