Era Might Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 I don't like this painting, anyone know who painted it? I refuse to believe this is what Thomas Aquinas looked like. Nothing brilliant in the face, looks like a provincial bishop posed for it.
Not A Real Name Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 What does a brilliant face look like?
veritasluxmea Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 lol. I feel you on that, and a lot of other pictures of saints. I'm pretty certain it's a documented fact he was overweight. Other than that, who knows? If you go to the wiki page and look at all the icons, they look pretty similar- softer, rounder face, kind of closer set eyes, similar nose. So that's probably close to what he looked like.
Era Might Posted January 13, 2015 Author Posted January 13, 2015 I think mainly it's the eyes. "The eyes are the windows of the soul." They have to have some life in them. And also the angry lips. This one I can see. Look at the eyes, they have some reflective anger in them, someone who's been wrestling with big questions. This one looks like a schoolboy, but I can imagine him having a hidden genius: This one probably is the best I could imagine, far-off gaze in the eyes looking to big things, but also a commanding face of a scholar: The original picture to me just looks like a corrupt Cardinal plotting against the Pope.
Not The Philosopher Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 There's a reason Aquinas' contemporaries nicknamed him The Dumb Ox. He didn't look very impressive, evidently.
Not A Real Name Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 No offense, but you have some strange observations. I mean have you seen a lot of cardinals plotting against the Pope? I personally think the original picture you posted is probably closer to what he actually looked like because it isn't flattering.
veritasluxmea Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 Naw, in the first picture he looks really sad, not evil, just ugly. Like he just lost someone close to him and he's wondering, "why?" But I think people are more inclined to think ugly people are mean or bad. Wasn't there a study done on that?
Not A Real Name Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 It's interesting to see the different observations others have. When I view the first one I don't see a sadness in his face. To me it looks like he's contemplating some Divine Mystery and that the Church bell tower has either sparked a new thought or has drawn him deeper into thought. As if he is piecing together a puzzle or going over all of the information in his head trying to arrange it. Maybe the pinnacle of the Church makes him think about how he is contemplating mysteries which are above him.
veritasluxmea Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 Maybe it's none of the above. Maybe his face is neutral. Maybe we're all projecting our subconsciousness on his face. Maybe it's maybelline. Maybe he needs some maybelline...
Nihil Obstat Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 I have heard it said that while he was overweight, he was overweight in an imposing, impressive sort of way.
PhuturePriest Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 I have heard it said that while he was overweight, he was overweight in an imposing, impressive sort of way.
truthfinder Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 I have heard it said that while he was overweight, he was overweight in an imposing, impressive sort of way. Yes, in the "we'll-need-a-crane-to-get-him-out" way. (I'm personally working on the theory that if you're called a nickname in the bovine family, you're doing good. It worked for both Thomas and Jean Brebeuf.)
Luigi Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 (edited) I don't like this painting, anyone know who painted it? I refuse to believe this is what Thomas Aquinas looked like. Nothing brilliant in the face, looks like a provincial bishop posed for it. Carlo Crivelli - 1476. It's part of the Demidoff Altarpiece in San Domenico church in Ascoli Piceno, central Italy. Crivelli was a Venetian; some art historians consider Venetian Renaissance art of lower quality than what was produced in Florence, Rome, and other areas of Western Italy. I don't. I like a lot of the Venetian work. Constantinople fell to the Turks in 1453, and a number of its citizens (including artists) fled to Italy, to the nearest city of any size on the east coast, Venice, so Byzantine art had some influence on Venetian art. They took more of an iconographic approach, part of which includes depicting exaggerated features. In this case, look at the unnaturally long, slender fingers; the emphasis on details, with some exaggeration of them, is also evident in the ear, the facial lines, the vein between the hair and the ear, the details in the church, and the richly detailed background patterns. No portraits of saints (except the more modern ones) were accurate likenesses. So artists worked from written descriptions and took whatever license they desired to fill in the details. That license was also artistic; the holding of a church was a common element of saints' portraits, indicating that they were defenders of The Church or of a particular church. (Some saints are shown holding cities, meaning they were defenders of that city.) This particular church building is supposed to represent The Church, and it reveals the rather sorry state of The Church at Aquinas' time - the chipped masonry and the plants growing on the masonry represent the fact that The Church was in disrepair. As to the facial expression, I read it as depicting this man's particular character, but also a person lost in thought (read: Contemplating). The mouth, as well as the dark lines under his eyes (it almost looks like mascara), depict sadness (for The Church he is holding). The wrinkles leading from the nose to the forehead, and the wrinkles around his eyes, depict concern (for The Church, and for the incorrect ideas his writings addressed). And yet his expression seems peaceful, accepting of whatever he's contemplating. In general, I like it. Edited January 13, 2015 by Luigi
ST BERNARD Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 This one is probably way too romanticized, as he doesn't look like a 'dumb ox' in it, but I like it. It is called the Apotheosis of St Thomas Aquinas, an altarpiece painted by Francisco de Zurbaran.
Not A Real Name Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 Maybe it's none of the above. Maybe his face is neutral. Maybe we're all projecting our subconsciousness on his face. Maybe it's maybelline. Maybe he needs some maybelline... This is what I love about art. While we speculate and come to our own conclusions, we at the same time acknowledge that the true meaning behind the painting is known only to the artist and can only be revealed to us by the artist. It makes me think of how God is mysterious in His creation and that unless He reveals Himself to us (through Divine Revelation) we can only know certain things through the use of reason (by way of investigation and science), but only a very little of who He is, why He does what He does, and why He created what He created. The other fun thing about art is in it we get to kind of play God in the sense that we take an immaterial thing like a thought, and wrap it in canvas and paint, and make it in a sense come to life. We can take something spiritual and join it with something material, like how God created us body and soul.
Amppax Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 (edited) Carlo Crivelli - 1476. It's part of the Demidoff Altarpiece in San Domenico church in Ascoli Piceno, central Italy. Crivelli was a Venetian; some art historians consider Venetian Renaissance art of lower quality than what was produced in Florence, Rome, and other areas of Western Italy. I don't. I like a lot of the Venetian work. Constantinople fell to the Turks in 1453, and a number of its citizens (including artists) fled to Italy, to the nearest city of any size on the east coast, Venice, so Byzantine art had some influence on Venetian art. They took more of an iconographic approach, part of which includes depicting exaggerated features. In this case, look at the unnaturally long, slender fingers; the emphasis on details, with some exaggeration of them, is also evident in the ear, the facial lines, the vein between the hair and the ear, the details in the church, and the richly detailed background patterns. No portraits of saints (except the more modern ones) were accurate likenesses. So artists worked from written descriptions and took whatever license they desired to fill in the details. That license was also artistic; the holding of a church was a common element of saints' portraits, indicating that they were defenders of The Church or of a particular church. (Some saints are shown holding cities, meaning they were defenders of that city.) This particular church building is supposed to represent The Church, and it reveals the rather sorry state of The Church at Aquinas' time - the chipped masonry and the plants growing on the masonry represent the fact that The Church was in disrepair. As to the facial expression, I read it as depicting this man's particular character, but also a person lost in thought (read: Contemplating). The mouth, as well as the dark lines under his eyes (it almost looks like mascara), depict sadness (for The Church he is holding). The wrinkles leading from the nose to the forehead, and the wrinkles around his eyes, depict concern (for The Church, and for the incorrect ideas his writings addressed). And yet his expression seems peaceful, accepting of whatever he's contemplating. In general, I like it. Dang, I vote Luigi for the title of resident art historian, if he didn't have it already. Forget scapgegoat of the month. Major props. :like: Edited January 13, 2015 by Amppax
HopefulHeart Posted January 13, 2015 Posted January 13, 2015 I personally like this painting of Aquinas best, but the first one has a pensive quality that I think also fits Aquinas. Interesting fact: In the first painting, there is a tiny figure in the doorway of the church that Thomas is holding. If you zoom into the painting on this site (http://www.nationalgallery.org.uk/paintings/carlo-crivelli-saint-thomas-aquinas) you can see the figure. I wonder who it is. Aquinas, the artist himself, or someone else?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now