Basilisa Marie Posted February 20, 2015 Posted February 20, 2015 I'm trying to start up a weekly apologetics class for adults at my work church. These people are in serious need of some basic catechesis, and some have expressed interest in apologetics and being able to give good answers to basic questions (or not so basic questions) about the faith. In all likelihood it's going to be something made from scratch, or mostly scratch, and I'm going to try to get a small team of adults to switch off leading it. I'm thinking part lecture and part discussion/q and a time. I have my own experiences with engaging in apologetics, but I'm wondering if any of you have any ideas? I'm looking for anything - best practices, helpful tips, good resources, unexpected challenges, good topics, the whole enchilada. My primary goal is to use apologetics as a vehicle for teaching them some theology, but I also want them to feel confident in their ability to give a good answer when non-Catholics (or their kids) ask them questions.
Nihil Obstat Posted February 20, 2015 Posted February 20, 2015 Just fire up a Fr. Hesse video. Should be all you need. :|
Ash Wednesday Posted February 20, 2015 Posted February 20, 2015 I prop and applaud your efforts and will keep you in my prayers. Knowing you live in the Seattle area, I'm sure they are in dire need of it.
CatherineM Posted February 20, 2015 Posted February 20, 2015 I've taught one for women for several years. It's empowering. Be prepared for lots of questions about raw family issues.
TheresaThoma Posted February 21, 2015 Posted February 21, 2015 If you know of a solid RCIA program/director near you pick their brains. They probably have some good resources to the most common questions. One of my priests suggested the Beginning Apologetics series as a good resource.
Basilisa Marie Posted February 21, 2015 Author Posted February 21, 2015 Thanks guys. Part of the reason I'm basically making it from scratch is that my boss (the pastor) is kind of picky about the kinds of materials he likes. He's been pretty vocal about what he doesn't like, but not very clear about what he does like. He keeps saying he wants things that are "middle of the road" but I'm only just beginning to understand what he means by that. A lot of the apologetics stuff out there that I know about is stuff I'm pretty sure he'd classify as too conservative. Plus I don't have a lot of time to fully review a bunch of curriculum or video series (I'd rather just spend that time writing a bunch of stuff myself that I know we'll use). And this way I can dance around his objections while still making sure these people get solid catechesis that is neither too academic/historical-critical/spirituality-isn't-for-thinking-people or too jesus-loves-me-that's-all-that-matters/the-church-today-is-exactly-the-way-things-have-always-been Argh. I've been working as a pastoral assistant for just over 4 months now and I'm still at the very beginning stages of building up my own resources and network. I'm probably biting off way more than I can chew. I just want things to be good, ya know?
truthfinder Posted February 21, 2015 Posted February 21, 2015 Hmm, if you're describing your pastor that way, then maybe my suggestion won't be as helpful. Otherwise, I was going to suggest the Didache series, they are 'highschool' level so it could give you the intellectual middle ground, and has a set on history, morality, etc - even if you just add it to your own arsenal of resources. I have used the Didache textbook for the history course as a student. We never used workbooks and I find that once people are older than about middle school, workbooks quickly lose their efficacy and should be replaced by discussion. My $.02 for you.
kyrie eleison Posted February 22, 2015 Posted February 22, 2015 How about this? http://www.kofc.org/un/en/cis/courses/index.html
Ark Posted February 22, 2015 Posted February 22, 2015 Just fire up a Fr. Hesse video. Should be all you need. :| Surprised someone knows of Fr. Hesse here ; )
Ark Posted February 22, 2015 Posted February 22, 2015 Peace be with you Basilisa, I think focusing on the pressure issues of our times: contraception, abortion, homosexual marriage, all-male priesthood, would be the main things to focus on. You can't defend those topics without going over important pieces of theology.
Nihil Obstat Posted February 22, 2015 Posted February 22, 2015 Surprised someone knows of Fr. Hesse here ; ) But of course. ;)
PhuturePriest Posted February 22, 2015 Posted February 22, 2015 Any Priest in his 50s whose hair goes past his shoulders is obviously not worth listening to. :| Also, Fr. Hesse just comes across to me as having been far too abrasive and angry. To answer the question at hand, the best resource I know of for straight-up apologetics questions and answers is The Essential Catholic Survival Guide by Catholic Answers. It goes through every single major issue today raised by protestants, Mormons, atheists, etc. Your pastor may find it too "conservative" because it is Catholic Answers, but there really is nothing "conservative" about it. It's a simple format of "If a Protestant says 'Call no man on earth 'father'', show them these verses."
Ark Posted February 22, 2015 Posted February 22, 2015 Any Priest in his 50s whose hair goes past his shoulders is obviously not worth listening to. :| Also, Fr. Hesse just comes across to me as having been far too abrasive and angry. That's an ad hominem my brother, judge the man's words and not his person.
tinytherese Posted February 22, 2015 Posted February 22, 2015 That's an ad hominem my brother, judge the man's words and not his person. Sometimes a person's tone can be distracting.
tinytherese Posted February 22, 2015 Posted February 22, 2015 What does your priest mean when he says that he doesn't want any "conservative" resources?
PhuturePriest Posted February 22, 2015 Posted February 22, 2015 That's an ad hominem my brother, judge the man's words and not his person. Okay, I will. I particularly judge when Father Hesse said any Catholic who attends or celebrates an OF Mass is a formal heretic, and that every encyclical written since Vatican II is heretical. I judge when he went on to say that, even if you don't attend or celebrate the Novus Ordo, if you are a traditionalist Priest but still accept Vatican II, you are a formal heretic (And he then made it clear that they were formal, not just material, heretics), citing the FSSP and ICKSP specifically. He was an informal schismatic, and it bothers me when non-SSPX traditionalists view him as some hero of the traditionalist cause. He was a perfect example of what the traditionalist movement should be striving to avoid and curb out of our ranks.
Nihil Obstat Posted February 22, 2015 Posted February 22, 2015 Okay, I will. I particularly judge when Father Hesse said any Catholic who attends or celebrates an OF Mass is a formal heretic, and that every encyclical written since Vatican II is heretical. I judge when he went on to say that, even if you don't attend or celebrate the Novus Ordo, if you are a traditionalist Priest but still accept Vatican II, you are a formal heretic (And he then made it clear that they were formal, not just material, heretics), citing the FSSP and ICKSP specifically. He was an informal schismatic, and it bothers me when non-SSPX traditionalists view him as some hero of the traditionalist cause. He was a perfect example of what the traditionalist movement should be striving to avoid and curb out of our ranks. Certainly he did not say that. He knows canon law too well to make that mistake. I will have to see references. Not posted here though; send it on FB.
Basilisa Marie Posted February 22, 2015 Author Posted February 22, 2015 What does your priest mean when he says that he doesn't want any "conservative" resources? What he says is that he wants things that are centrist, but I'm still figuring out what that means. What I've observed is that he seems ideological left of center, really into historical-critical stuff, and seems to be suspicious of anything that he could interpret as overly-pious, blind love of Church authority. He doesn't personally care for any of the "extra" devotions in the faith, like Marian Apparitions, St. Faustina, or even Adoration and the Rosary. Now, I don't believe any of what I said constitutes sinful behavior, and we're all free to have the kind of preferences he seems to have. It's just that he doesn't seem to want to promote that kind of conservative Catholicism. I heard that a few years ago, they used Fr. Barron's Catholicism series, but he doesn't like it, doesn't think it has enough meat, and would only want to use it if we had no other choice. I'm not the biggest fan of Fr. Barron, but I wouldn't describe that series like that. I think what he wants is to develop people into Catholics who are critical thinkers, who test what the Church says against their own reason, and aren't afraid to say something if they disagree. I think he wants people to know about Church history, both the dirty laundry and the clean, and to understand that a lot of things have changed in the Church over the centuries. I can appreciate a lot of that, but my problem with it is that you really need to make sure that someone is well formed and spiritually mature before you can start throwing a lot of that at them. And what I see is a lot of people missing just basic catechesis. Just because someone is an adult, doesn't mean you should start throwing a bunch of hardballs at them. I hope I don't sound condescending to them, because that's not my intention. So I'm trying to figure out how to address the need for solid catechesis in a way that neither lacks critical thinking nor poo-poos strong spirituality. Rock, meet hard place. In the mean time, I figure people on the internet are usually pretty familiar with apologetics, so what better ways to crowdsource than to ask y'all? :)
Ark Posted February 23, 2015 Posted February 23, 2015 Okay, I will. I particularly judge when Father Hesse said any Catholic who attends or celebrates an OF Mass is a formal heretic, and that every encyclical written since Vatican II is heretical. I judge when he went on to say that, even if you don't attend or celebrate the Novus Ordo, if you are a traditionalist Priest but still accept Vatican II, you are a formal heretic (And he then made it clear that they were formal, not just material, heretics), citing the FSSP and ICKSP specifically. He was an informal schismatic, and it bothers me when non-SSPX traditionalists view him as some hero of the traditionalist cause. He was a perfect example of what the traditionalist movement should be striving to avoid and curb out of our ranks. I share Nihil Obstat's skepticism as I'm not aware of Fr. Hesse ever making such claims.
truthfinder Posted February 23, 2015 Posted February 23, 2015 He doesn't personally care for any of the "extra" devotions in the faith, like Marian Apparitions, St. Faustina, or even Adoration and the Rosary. Now, I don't believe any of what I said constitutes sinful behavior, and we're all free to have the kind of preferences he seems to have. I think what he wants is to develop people into Catholics who are critical thinkers, who test what the Church says against their own reason, and aren't afraid to say something if they disagree. I think he wants people to know about Church history, both the dirty laundry and the clean, and to understand that a lot of things have changed in the Church over the centuries. I can appreciate a lot of that, but my problem with it is that you really need to make sure that someone is well formed and spiritually mature before you can start throwing a lot of that at them. And what I see is a lot of people missing just basic catechesis. Sorry, I had to roll my eyes. I get that people don't always find adoration or the rosary easy (I'm pointing directly at myself), but to consider them "extra" would seem a bit much and raise a bit of a red flag for me. But that's neither here nor there in regards to you teaching a class. Critical thinking is great and all that but I too share the concern of having a solid basis (maybe adapt the baltimore catechism - don't tell them you're using it but use it as a guideline - it will definitely touch upon very touchy topics: ie intermarriage, etc and set the tone of why we are here on earth, without that basis, everything just really doesn't make sense). The thing with the buzzword "critical thinker" is that it in reality it comes across as cynical questioning of the faith. As well, it is getting harder and harder to find people who are truly blindly obeying the Church and a very white-washed version of her history. A lot of work needs to be done discussing how the Church was, and actually situate her in the past, both the good and the bad. So much popular history, and a good portion of academic history, is focused on showing how Catholics have been a priest-ridden people. And I'll stop here before I get into a full-blown rant.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now