Era Might Posted March 17, 2015 Posted March 17, 2015 Imagine an ad with Christ during the crowning with thorns, very beautiful, but the only difference from traditional iconography...he would be draped in a Dolce & Gabanna cloak. Would that not be a blasphemous ad, regardless of any shallow "pious" context? That is no different from this. The Christ in that ad would not be Christ any more than the family in this ad is a family. They are both antichrist.
Credo in Deum Posted March 17, 2015 Posted March 17, 2015 (edited) No, of course not, the purpose of advertising is to reflect whatever social habits there are. But the subtext of the ad is not just about happy families, it is about happy CONSUMER families. The family is happy and beautiful and ideal not because they are a "traditional family" but because they are a Dolce & Gabbana family. Forget any idea of any ad trying to confirm you in your traditional values, and if an ad does try to do that, it is even more insidious, because then it really becomes propaganda and ideology, it transforms your world into the shell for a brand relationship. That is what marketing is, turning brand relationships into emotional processes, where you don't even have to think about buying from that brand, you do it automatically because the brand has confirmed some emotional connection, but has only done so on a surface level. These ads are targeted toward a market that can buy Dolce & Gabanna products, and the rest of the audience may not be able to afford D&G, but can support the brand's goals by buying into the fantasy being sold, and help share the brand feeling. We are trapped in an antichrist system, all joking aside, what one of my favorite authors calls "Techno-Moloch." This world is in a very bad place. D&G is a company. Companies market and advertise their products in a way to make you want them. This is the point behind marketing! Companies do this because companies need consumers. No company will spend money on advertisements that say "Hey buy D&G, sure it won't change your life and you can live fine without it but please consider buying it anyway." Or for Coke, "Are you thirsty? Well then consider getting a cold Coke. Sure the sodium may not completely quench your thirst, but the sugar will make feel good even though you don't really need this much sugar." Yeah, hmm probably not the best marketing technique. Furthermore anyone who lets a D&G ad shape their entire belief system already has a big problem. I mean if you can't look at their ads and be able to distinguish between the fantasy they're portraying and the reality of everyday life, then that is the scarier story. Heck anyone who would let a D&G ad piss them off so much they interpret that the father is going to plow the mother right when the camera is off them is a scarier story than the stupid ad depicting the obviously unrealistic environments! Lastly people like ads because they give you a chance to escape reality. Edited March 17, 2015 by Credo in Deum
Era Might Posted March 17, 2015 Posted March 17, 2015 D&G is a company. Companies market and advertise their products in a way to make you want them. This is the point behind marketing! Companies do this because companies need consumers. No company will spend money on advertisements that say "Hey buy D&G, sure it won't change your life and you can live fine without it but please consider buying it anyway." Or for Coke, "Are you thirsty? Well then consider getting a cold Coke. Sure the sodium may not completely quench your thirst, but the sugar will make feel good even though you don't really need this much sugar." Yeah, hmm probably not the best marketing technique. Furthermore anyone who lets a D&G ad shape their entire belief system already has a big problem. I mean if you can't look at their ads and be able to distinguish between the fantasy their portraying and the reality of everyday life, then that is the scarier story. Heck anyone who would let a D&G ad piss them off so much they interpret that the father is going to plow the mother right when the camera is off them is a scarier story than the stupid ad depicting the obviously unrealistic environments! Lastly people like ads because they give you a chance to escape reality. I didn't post the ads, simply commented on them. I don't drink Coke, and try to block out advertising in general. And I absolutely reject the entire premise behind Coke, an inhuman product if there ever was one. It's sad that in a Western culture where water is such a primordial symbol, once the symbol of our rebirth in Christ and of spiritual refreshment, has now become a mass-produced concoction of sugar that becomes the fantasy of everyone from third-world Africa to third-grade New York. Our culture and civilization has long ceased to exist, we live as consumers of packaged dreams and services from companies and professionals. It's sad. You find it scary that I take these ads seriously. I find it scary that you don't. Ads do not allow you to escape reality, they are your reality. These ads do not piss me off. I've never even seen a D&G ad before this thread. I'm just interested in how ideology and propaganda work in general. I also work in marketing, and am very interested in what marketing represents. I think it is a form of mass superstition beyond anything you ever found in the most primitive society. We are under the spell of marketers, in the ways you outline and many more. Anyway, I don't spend my days raving at ads. I try to avoid them as much as possible. I prefer the traditional asceticism of the eyes...flee evil, don't fight it.
CatherineM Posted March 18, 2015 Posted March 18, 2015 The purpose of advertising is to sell a product. Their views have made the mainstream because they are famous. That doesn't validate or disprove their opinions. I had had lots of gay clients 25+ years ago. At least back then they didn't want a traditional marriage and family. More than one told me that why would they want to marry when over half end in divorce. The only kids were those born to people before they came out. I'm not sure what happened to change all that. I guess they felt to get accepted by the mainstream they had to join it. D and G are both Italians I think. They probably grew up in traditional families. It's kind of like being raised on butter. You know the real stuff when you taste it, and imitation substitutes just aren't the same no matter how many people settle for it.
Era Might Posted March 18, 2015 Posted March 18, 2015 The purpose of advertising is to sell a product. Their views have made the mainstream because they are famous. That doesn't validate or disprove their opinions. There is no product being sold in the D&G ads. Or rather, I think there is, but the product is the people themselves. D&G does not produce clothing, it produces people who wear its clothing (in other words, it is selling the idea of the D&G brand, not this or that piece of clothing). The product is really irrelevant in advertising. I was listening to the recent Adobe Summit and the main speaker talked about this subject, about how the distinction between "product" and "marketing" has been abolished, because your product is itself the marketing, it is not a static product but a part of a larger digital system that gathers data and directs its own marketing. Even in traditional selling, good salesmen sold the benefits, not the product. Advertising is about selling ideas (the very things you used to be burned at the stake for). Brands are not interested in selling a product, because that's just a one-time transaction. They want to sell their brand as a social institution. The physical product (if there is even a physical product) is not much. With smartphones, for example, the margins on the hardware business are tight and cutthroat. What you have to sell is not a physical smartphone, but an idea of what a smartphone is, an idea around which people will reshape their lives (whether it's music as a digital practice, social media as a normal part of human relationships, etc.). Products are not just generic economic units. They are in an economic sense...it doesn't matter what the product is, an economist just wants to calculate the numbers around X, whether it's a widget or a piece of technology doesn't matter, the economist only measures its economic properties. But for brands and advertising, a "product" is not just a manufactured thing, it is an idea, and that is what they sell. Every piece of advertising is selling you some version of reality. To sell a smartphone you have to sell people on the idea of a world of smartphones...because if they don't buy into that idea, and the practical social and personal adaptations that make the idea possible, then your smartphone is useless. If you go to a primitive village and sell them an iPhone for a bunch of gold bars, you haven't accomplished anything, because you haven't sold them on the idea that will lead them to abandon their primitive life and adopt the ideas on which the smartphone exists and operates. Then there are other "products" that are not physical, but more like services...these, too, are trying to sell you on a sociological and psychological vision, because to sell a service you have to sell someone on the need for a service, and from the outset you are selling them on the idea that they are a person in need, and that to fill that need, they need someone else, that they are incapable of filling their own needs (and these needs, in many cases, have been created by other people selling other ideas). Taking this back to the OP, I wouldn't take anything these people say seriously. Marketing and advertising is a system built on manipulation, it is not philosophy. Marketers ultimately don't care whether you have 10 kids or are a gay couple, they can find a way to fit their product around your terms, but also then reshape your terms around their product (that's literally what marketing is, creating the reality around what is, not what should be).
CatherineM Posted March 18, 2015 Posted March 18, 2015 Glad I never had to take marketing. That made my head hurt.
Era Might Posted March 18, 2015 Posted March 18, 2015 Glad I never had to take marketing. That made my head hurt. lol. It's actually a fascinating area from a philosophical/humanities perspective, because so much is based on human behavior and crosses with so many disciplines (sociology, psychology, etc.). But in a professional sense, marketing is not about understanding human behavior, but understanding how to manipulate it. Marketers are interested in human behavior so that they can integrate it into their business processes, not so that they can understand mankind. That's where I lose interest in marketing, and where it just becomes a bunch of self-serving babble.
Credo in Deum Posted March 18, 2015 Posted March 18, 2015 Marketing is fishing for people. Gotta catch em all!
Cherie Posted March 18, 2015 Posted March 18, 2015 (edited) Those ads are so unrealistic, they make me anxious to look at them. That woman, particularly at her size and healthful glow, giving birth to six kids in, what, six or seven years? Hahahahaha. NOPE. Although, now that I think of it, there is a well-known Catholic blogger wife who is pretty, thin, and stylish and is having #5 before her oldest turns 5. Back to the treadmill for me! Edited March 18, 2015 by Cherie
Not The Philosopher Posted March 19, 2015 Posted March 19, 2015 How dare people try to market and sell me their bread and wine, turning the matter of the most holy Eucharist into a bourgeois foodie fantasy. How dare that carpenter rent out a place in the church bulletin to advertise his skills; he is defaming the Lord's own humble trade. These people are tearing down civilization as we know it.
Ash Wednesday Posted March 21, 2015 Author Posted March 21, 2015 Madonna and Elton John care. Serious business.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now