Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Beautiful video of our Holy Father washing female prisoner's feet


Recommended Posts

Nihil Obstat
Posted

164253_176758395807244_2080682809_n.jpg

​It is not our fault the Pope did something which is illicit for every other priest.

puellapaschalis
Posted

Nor if, subsequently, everyone then says it's fine and dandy because, yannow, the Pope did it. Hagan lio!*

 

*Language nerd disclaimer

BarbTherese
Posted

I read the following:

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/pope-francis-female-foot-wash-upsets-traditionalists-article-1.1303260

Vatican spokesman Federico Lombardi said there was nothing wrong with showing women sole support.

“Here, the rite was for a small, unique community made up also of women,” Lombardi wrote in an email. “Excluding the girls would have been inopportune in light of the simple aim of communicating a message of love to all, in a group that certainly didn’t include experts on liturgical rules.”

I also found the following an interesting statement on New Advent :

 http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/13216a.htm It is true that many others admit the distinction between preceptive and directive rubrics, as De Herdt does, but they write from the standpoint of conscience, and when they excuse infractions of the rule it is in virtue of special reasons due to circumstances.

But all things being said, I am not one personally to demand in all circumstances that the letter of the law must apply absolutely.

Posted

Okay, hopefully this isn't going to start a flame war or tick people off as irrelevant, cuz I can't help but see the connection between this topic and the all-male priesthood itself. Which brings up something that's been bothering me. So I'm going to ask here.

DISCLAIMER: I am not for women priests. But...

I'm surrounded by feminists all day, almost every day. And when they ask about why Catholics won't have female priests, I tell them it's because Christ selected only male apostles, so we do what Christ did. I tell them that because it's the only argument I've ever heard for the all-male priesthood, but no lies, y'all, it's a terrible argument. So my question is: Is that the only reason we have for the all-male priesthood? Cuz if we've got better ones, I would really like to know them!

Posted

 

I tell them it's because Christ selected only male apostles, so we do what Christ did. I tell them that because it's the only argument I've ever heard for the all-male priesthood, but no lies, y'all, it's a terrible argument. So my question is: Is that the only reason we have for the all-male priesthood? Cuz if we've got better ones, I would really like to know them!

​The priesthood is a covenant, like a marriage. The Church is the bride, and Christ is the bride groom. Since priests are representing Christ, the masculine role, married to the Church, the feminine role, having a woman priest would be like having two brides.

Posted

​The priesthood is a covenant, like a marriage. The Church is the bride, and Christ is the bride groom. Since priests are representing Christ, the masculine role, married to the Church, the feminine role, having a woman priest would be like having two brides.

​Okay, that's better. Thank you, dUSt!

What else have we got?

Posted

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/pope-francis-female-foot-wash-upsets-traditionalists-article-1.1303260

Vatican spokesman Federico Lombardi said there was nothing wrong with showing women sole support.

“Here, the rite was for a small, unique community made up also of women,” Lombardi wrote in an email. “Excluding the girls would have been inopportune in light of the simple aim of communicating a message of love to all, in a group that certainly didn’t include experts on liturgical rules.”

Sounds reasonable. ​Being a man or a woman doesn't tell you who you are, only what you are. If anyone needs to know they are a "who" and not just a "what," it's prisoners.

Posted

​The priesthood is a covenant, like a marriage. The Church is the bride, and Christ is the bride groom. Since priests are representing Christ, the masculine role, married to the Church, the feminine role, having a woman priest would be like having two brides.

Sorry, but that's an even worse argument for an all make priesthood. 

I see no justification for ascribing "gender" roles to a relationship or promise.  

Relegating female/bride characteristics are nonsensical other than to bolster the idea that males are more able and females are inherently incapable to fulfill a promise.  

 

Posted

Sorry, but that's an even worse argument for an all make priesthood. 

I see no justification for ascribing "gender" roles to a relationship or promise.  

Relegating female/bride characteristics are nonsensical other than to bolster the idea that males are more able and females are inherently incapable to fulfill a promise.  

 

​I think it's better because it situates the status quo in the context of a larger relational metaphor that is unobjectionable (and timeless) to Catholics. Whereas the "Jesus only chose male Apostles" argument could easily be countered with the claim that of course He did, because women would have been shunned as "public figures" roaming about in ancient times (and were totally without credibility to Jews), whereas nowadays women are accepted as credible and legitimate public figures and so there's no reason not to ordain them.

However, I do think that we need an arsenal of arguments for this situation (of only-male priests), because a "cumulative case" is always stronger than just one or two reasons. So I would like to continue hearing arguments, if others know of any.

Also, Nihil: Because I respect your opinion so much, I'm curious what your view is on the bit posted above:

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/pope-francis-female-foot-wash-upsets-traditionalists-article-1.1303260

Vatican spokesman Federico Lombardi said there was nothing wrong with showing women sole support.

“Here, the rite was for a small, unique community made up also of women,” Lombardi wrote in an email. “Excluding the girls would have been inopportune in light of the simple aim of communicating a message of love to all, in a group that certainly didn’t include experts on liturgical rules.”

KnightofChrist
Posted

Today in the Church ignoring the rubrics of the Mass or a traditional ritual is fairly widespread, many times with the best of intentions. I wish the Pope would change the law rather than simply ignore it. If a King ignores his own laws why should his people obey them? Anyway, whatever.

Posted

Sorry, but that's an even worse argument for an all make priesthood. 

I see no justification for ascribing "gender" roles to a relationship or promise.  

Relegating female/bride characteristics are nonsensical other than to bolster the idea that males are more able and females are inherently incapable to fulfill a promise.  

 

​It's only a worse argument if you support same sex marriage, and think there is no validity in maintaining that marriage is between a man (masculine) and woman (feminine). That is an entirely different debate though.

Posted

Today in the Church ignoring the rubrics of the Mass or a traditional ritual is fairly widespread, many times with the best of intentions. I wish the Pope would change the law rather than simply ignore it. If a King ignores his own laws why should his people obey them? Anyway, whatever.

​Isn't that what the Pharisees said to Jesus? (Not calling you a Pharisee, just saying that he very explicitly broke the law, on the grounds that the law was made for man, not the other way around).

Posted

​It's only a worse argument if you support same sex marriage, and think there is no validity in maintaining that marriage is between a man (masculine) and woman (feminine). That is an entirely different debate though.

I think the Church would have better served the concept of sacramental marriage if it had maintained the importance of lifelong commitment and not simply subfugated it as a mere fertility effort. In that sense it addresses the easy divorce mentality, hetero sexual fidelity, stable social element for children and family, etc.  the mutually supporting and sacrificial elements of marriage are more important than a faith breeding pair (Duggar). ;)

KnightofChrist
Posted

​Isn't that what the Pharisees said to Jesus? (Not calling you a Pharisee, just saying that he very explicitly broke the law, on the grounds that the law was made for man, not the other way around).

There is a big difference between the law of the Pharisees and the laws and rubrics of the Catholic Church. So the answer is no. I dislike how Catholic laws and rubrics are so often compared to the law of the Pharisees. But I've had that discussion with Protestants (even some not so traditionally minded Catholics) far too much in the pass to want to discuss it again. I'll just go with that's an unfair and unwarranted comparison. Also Christ did change or rebuke those laws of the Pharisees rather than simply ignore them. He condemned the law that allowed divorce, condemned the law that allowed stoning, and condemned others as well.

Posted

At that time Jesus went through the corn on the sabbath: and his disciples being hungry, began to pluck the ears, and to eat. [2] And the Pharisees seeing them, said to him: Behold thy disciples do that which is not lawful to do on the sabbath days. [3] But he said to them: Have you not read what David did when he was hungry, and they that were with him: [4] How he entered into the house of God, and did eat the loaves of proposition, which it was not lawful for him to eat, nor for them that were with him, but for the priests only? [5] Or have ye not read in the law, that on the sabbath days the priests in the temple break the sabbath, and are without blame? [6] But I tell you that there is here a greater than the temple. [7] And if you knew what this meaneth: I will have mercy, and not sacrifice: you would never have condemned the innocent. [8] For the Son of man is Lord even of the sabbath. [9] And when he had passed from thence, he came into their synagogues. [10] And behold there was a man who had a withered hand, and they asked him, saying: Is it lawful to heal on the sabbath days? that they might accuse him. [11] But he said to them: What man shall there be among you, that hath one sheep: and if the same fall into a pit on the sabbath day, will he not take hold on it and lift it up? [12] How much better is a man than a sheep? Therefore it is lawful to do a good deed on the sabbath days. [13] Then he saith to the man: Stretch forth thy hand; and he stretched it forth, and it was restored to health even as the other. [14] And the Pharisees going out made a consultation against him, how they might destroy him. [15] But Jesus knowing it, retired from thence: and many followed him, and he healed them all.

Breaking the law is part of Christian tradition. Not the only part, but an important one. But, ultimately, the Pope washed people's feet, regardless of what anyone thinks about it. I'm sure those people will never forget it.

KnightofChrist
Posted

Breaking the law is part of Christian tradition. Not the only part, but an important one. But, ultimately, the Pope washed people's feet, regardless of what anyone thinks about it. I'm sure those people will never forget it.

​Unjust laws yes, just laws no. But yes, I'm sure they'll never forget.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...