Ice_nine Posted April 25, 2015 Author Posted April 25, 2015 I'm not close with any priests. When is a good opportunity to hit an only slightly familiar clergyman with a random question?
Nihil Obstat Posted April 25, 2015 Posted April 25, 2015 I'm not close with any priests. When is a good opportunity to hit an only slightly familiar clergyman with a random question? Literally right after Mass just as he starts making a beeline to the coffee machine. Better yet, just before he sits down in the confessional. I find it most convenient to ask simple questions during the after Mass social. If it were very private I would ask him for a short appointment on a different day.
Norseman82 Posted April 25, 2015 Posted April 25, 2015 Well, unless I missed it, I do not know the details of why you feel it would be wrong to attend the wedding. I get from your opening post that she is a lapsed Catholic. But is she getting married in a civil ceremony? To a non-Catholic in a protestant/non-Catholic ceremony (without a proper dispensation)? To someone who is divorced but with no annulment? To a non-Christian? Just as an FYI, I read in the old Baltimore Catechism (typical edition that I could not find online) that Catholics were not only forbidden from attending the weddings of Catholics who were married by protestant ministers, but they were not supposed to even send gifts, as we are not supposed to do anything that could be construed as congratulating or endorsing it. So, there is ample precedent and support for not attending invalid weddings.
Nihil Obstat Posted April 25, 2015 Posted April 25, 2015 If she is Catholic, lapsed or not, and does not observe canonical form, the wedding is presumably invalid.
Ark Posted April 26, 2015 Posted April 26, 2015 As long as it's not an SSPX wedding it's totally cool. :-P
Catlick Posted April 28, 2015 Posted April 28, 2015 As long as it's not an SSPX wedding it's totally cool. :-P Just curious, are SSPX weddings valid?
Gabriela Posted April 28, 2015 Posted April 28, 2015 ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Wow. That is some mighty fine emoticon art right there! Impressive!
Amppax Posted April 28, 2015 Posted April 28, 2015 Just curious, are SSPX weddings valid? http://canonlawmadeeasy.com/2013/08/15/are-sspx-sacraments-valid-part-ii/ Short answer, no. For the sacrament to be valid, it has to be celebrated by the pastor of the parish, or someone he delegates. SSPX can't fall under that, therefore, invalid.
Nihil Obstat Posted April 28, 2015 Posted April 28, 2015 http://canonlawmadeeasy.com/2013/08/15/are-sspx-sacraments-valid-part-ii/ Short answer, no. For the sacrament to be valid, it has to be celebrated by the pastor of the parish, or someone he delegates. SSPX can't fall under that, therefore, invalid. Not to derail or anything, but I have spent a decent amount of time familiarizing myself with arguments both from SSPX and non-SSPX sources, and I have not seen the core SSPX arguments addressed in a particularly thorough or complete manner,
Amppax Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 Not to derail or anything, but I have spent a decent amount of time familiarizing myself with arguments both from SSPX and non-SSPX sources, and I have not seen the core SSPX arguments addressed in a particularly thorough or complete manner, Yeah, I haven't had a chance to go through all their arguments on this matter. Be that as it may, their validity is at least questionable.
Ark Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 Just curious, are SSPX weddings valid? Yes, of course. Why wouldn't they be?
Ark Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 Yeah, I haven't had a chance to go through all their arguments on this matter. Be that as it may, their validity is at least questionable. The Church supplies jurisdiction in cases of doubt.
Ark Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 Not to derail or anything, but I have spent a decent amount of time familiarizing myself with arguments both from SSPX and non-SSPX sources, and I have not seen the core SSPX arguments addressed in a particularly thorough or complete manner, You seem restrained in your speech, my brother. The phishy tag ain't all that bad
Nihil Obstat Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 You seem restrained in your speech, my brother. The phishy tag ain't all that bad Restrained... prudent... I say only what I mean, and I have no intention to say or imply something beyond my understanding or competency. Canon law is certainly beyond my competency. I can only read and assess what others have written.
Ark Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 Restrained... prudent... I say only what I mean, and I have no intention to say or imply something beyond my understanding or competency. Canon law is certainly beyond my competency. I can only read and assess what others have written. We live in a strange and unprecedented era. Not much is certain anymore but thankfully God supplies.
Nihil Obstat Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 We live in a strange and unprecedented era. Not much is certain anymore but thankfully God supplies. Agreed. God always provides.
Amppax Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 The Church supplies jurisdiction in cases of doubt. It's debatable whether that applies.
Ark Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 It's debatable whether that applies. It's debatable whether a Priest that says "for all" in place of pro multis validly consecrates the Sacrament. And this doesn't factor the issue of intention, and what happens if a Priest doesn't believe in the transubstantiation or believes the Mass is just the Lord's supper. Such are the times we live in. Do I think the Mystical Body of Christ supplies jurisdiction for Roman Catholics simply trying to be traditional at an SSPX chapel? Yes of course.
Ash Wednesday Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 (edited) Well, that's just, like, your opinion, man. No Catholic vs. Catholic debate please, that is not allowed on here. Thank you. Edited April 29, 2015 by Ash Wednesday
Lilllabettt Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 Thanks y'alls. I feel kind of stupid asking for life advice on the interwebs I never make a significant life choice without first consulting phatmass. Phatmass is my Samurai Master.
Recommended Posts