Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Humanoid Robots - Are they ethical?


Recommended Posts

Not A Mallard
Posted (edited)

This video is currently trending on Facebook:

http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/04/20/us-japan-robot-store-idUSKBN0NB1OZ20150420

Not only is this robot 2spooky4me, but it makes me wonder how moral it is for human beings to build robots in the image and likeness of ourselves since we're made in the image and likeness of God. It's basically creating artificial humans. Sure, the robot in the video has limited human capabilities, and it won't keep its job at the department store for long, but what if technology develops further? I can't picture any practical or moral use for humanoid robots except to use them as stunt doubles for movies or plays.

Edited by Not A Mallard
MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

This video is currently trending on Facebook:

http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/04/20/us-japan-robot-store-idUSKBN0NB1OZ20150420

Not only is this robot 2spooky4me, but it makes me wonder how moral it is for human beings to build robots in the image and likeness of ourselves since we're made in the image and likeness of God. It's basically creating artificial humans. Sure, the robot in the video has limited human capabilities, and it won't keep its job at the department store for long, but what if technology develops further? I can't picture any practical or moral use for humanoid robots except to use them as stunt doubles for movies or plays.

I don't feel comfortable with this for the same reason as you... It also might give an impression that robots can have consciousness (since they look human) but they don't have souls and are not alive

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Automatons are nothing new. There's no problem here. Move along, move along.

Posted

​Actually, that dental patient robot seems pretty practical, even though its skin is made from a company that makes "love dolls" (which is another concern I have about humanoid robots).

​:|

I had not even considered that. And still wish I hadn't.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I think the question of AI is a more interesting one than androids per se, to be honest.

veritasluxmea
Posted

how moral it is for human beings to build robots in the image and likeness of ourselves since we're made in the image and likeness of God. It's basically creating artificial humans. 

​lol. Are portraits of humans ok? what about sculptures? How is a human looking robot different? It's a robot. Just because it looks creepy doesn't mean it's evil.

And about the whole job thing... we're going need a better solution than just stopping technology. It's like self-serve checkouts and computers. Technically, both, especially computers, replace jobs. Did you file your taxes online? You could of gone to a person and created a job instead. Heck, if we really want to create jobs, we should get rid of registers and hire people to work it out by hand! It's like that old story: 

Milton Friedman recalled traveling to an Asian country in the 1960s and visiting a worksite where a new canal was being built. He was shocked to see that, instead of modern tractors and earth movers, the workers had shovels. He asked why there were so few machines. The government bureaucrat explained: “You don’t understand. This is a jobs program.” To which Milton replied: “Oh, I thought you were trying to build a canal. If it’s jobs you want, then you should give these workers spoons, not shovels.”

Not A Mallard
Posted (edited)

I think the question of AI is a more interesting one than androids per se, to be honest.

I know where that'll get us.

​

Edited by Not A Mallard
Posted

You cannot verify that others are not philosophical zombies. It's impossible to determine if they truly have internal lives.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

You cannot verify that others are not philosophical zombies. It's impossible to determine if they truly have internal lives.

​Yes, that is true of everyone, robot or not. Therefore nobody has rights. You are the only moral agent in the universe. Go enjoy yourself!

Posted

​Yes, that is true of everyone, robot or not. Therefore nobody has rights. You are the only moral agent in the universe. Go enjoy yourself!

I suppose that's one choice you could make from that fact.

Posted
 

​lol. Are portraits of humans ok? what about sculptures? How is a human looking robot different? It's a robot. Just because it looks creepy doesn't mean it's evil.

And about the whole job thing... we're going need a better solution than just stopping technology. It's like self-serve checkouts and computers. Technically, both, especially computers, replace jobs. Did you file your taxes online? You could of gone to a person and created a job instead. Heck, if we really want to create jobs, we should get rid of registers and hire people to work it out by hand! It's like that old story: 

​I would say that robots differ from Portraits and statues because they can be aware of the world around them and depending on how advanced their programming is semi-sentient and thinking on it's own. So I do think that @ Not A Mallard has an interesting inquiry.

As to the Job part I agree innovation is inevitable without all becoming Neo-Luddites.  Just because I am a YouTube Nerd I'm going to leave this Video here about Technology and the ever changing Job market.

 


Nihil Obstat
Posted

I suppose that's one choice you could make from that fact.

​I have not made any choice, because I do not exist. Only you exist. And all you are is a brain in a vat.

Posted

I suppose if what you want from life is to move undisturbed by other people between your house bubble and your garage bubble and your car bubble to a department store bubble, then replacing human service workers with robots is a wonderful idea. But I think there's enough isolation and loneliness in America already, and supermarket checkout computers don't help with that.

So it's not just about the jobs—though it is also about the jobs. It's about what we think those jobs really consist of, and what we think their real role in and impact on our society is. If you think that checking people out at the grocery store or giving people suggestions in a department store is all just routinized work that requires no real skill or humanity, then yay robots. But I think that's a gross oversimplification of those jobs, of the interactions they create among people, and of their actual (unrecognized) importance in our society.

Posted

Putting a face on robots is just marketing. The root of the problem is our entire technical civilization, and values/principles such as automation, efficiency, reproduction, manufacturing, etc. Technology is only the means by which we put into practice ideas. I find technology mildly interesting in itself, but I don't generally share the ideas/values behind them, so I'm usually just like, "Oh, I see how that works, why would I want to buy one of those?" One of my annoyance is the k-cup machines. I'm not against coffee machines in general, but the absurd drive toward more and more ease just annoys me. I can't grow my own food, but can I at least pour out a little coffee into the machine, smell it, take a few minutes to brew. For me, the ethical imperative is not to shun technology for the sake of shunning, but to consciously find limits to how we use technology, to maintain what is human. Those limits will be different for everyone, but I think we don't even try to live within human limits, technology has become one big superstitious ritual for us. And I think human-faced robots are anti-human, but they're just the tip of the iceberg.

Posted (edited)

Putting a face on robots is just marketing. The root of the problem is our entire technical civilization, and values/principles such as automation, efficiency, reproduction, manufacturing, etc. Technology is only the means by which we put into practice ideas. I find technology mildly interesting in itself, but I don't generally share the ideas/values behind them, so I'm usually just like, "Oh, I see how that works, why would I want to buy one of those?" One of my annoyance is the k-cup machines. I'm not against coffee machines in general, but the absurd drive toward more and more ease just annoys me. I can't grow my own food, but can I at least pour out a little coffee into the machine, smell it, take a few minutes to brew. For me, the ethical imperative is not to shun technology for the sake of shunning, but to consciously find limits to how we use technology, to maintain what is human. Those limits will be different for everyone, but I think we don't even try to live within human limits, technology has become one big superstitious ritual for us. And I think human-faced robots are anti-human, but they're just the tip of the iceberg.

 

kfc3vl.jpg

Edited by Gabriela
Not A Mallard
Posted

Putting a face on robots is just marketing. The root of the problem is our entire technical civilization, and values/principles such as automation, efficiency, reproduction, manufacturing, etc. Technology is only the means by which we put into practice ideas. I find technology mildly interesting in itself, but I don't generally share the ideas/values behind them, so I'm usually just like, "Oh, I see how that works, why would I want to buy one of those?" One of my annoyance is the k-cup machines. I'm not against coffee machines in general, but the absurd drive toward more and more ease just annoys me. I can't grow my own food, but can I at least pour out a little coffee into the machine, smell it, take a few minutes to brew. For me, the ethical imperative is not to shun technology for the sake of shunning, but to consciously find limits to how we use technology, to maintain what is human. Those limits will be different for everyone, but I think we don't even try to live within human limits, technology has become one big superstitious ritual for us. And I think human-faced robots are anti-human, but they're just the tip of the iceberg.

​

Not The Philosopher
Posted

Generally I would argue that the use of technology is just part of human nature. The use of tools to interact with the world flows out of being an embodied rational being (as opposed to being an angel whose intellect can operate directly on things). Furthermore, God's command to be fruitful and multiply is linked with the one to cultivate the earth and have dominion over it.

Obviously, this capacity can be put to disordered use, like any other human faculty. And no technology is without its side effects on human life. But I don't think you can really make blanket statements about technology somehow threatening our humanity or some such thing.

W/regard to the particular topic, I see nothing intrinsically wrong with making robots, although the one in the OP's article is indeed rather creepy looking, and, again, these things can be put to evil uses (much like this fancy internet thing that we're using right here). It's not like you're subverting natural law in the way that practices like cloning and reproductive technologies do.

I mean, I am building my own private robot army for the purposes of world domination, but my moral evaluation still stands.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...