Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Anastasia13
Posted

Can people truly be evil? Is it ontologically correct that a person or a group is evil?

BarbTherese
Posted

I believe that we do have the potential for real evil, while for the majority we suppress or repress any such inclination.  People whose thoughts, words and/or actions are truly evil, I believe, are in a real minority by far.

It does beg the question "What is evil?".............."What do I understand as evil?"

Credo in Deum
Posted

People can become evil, but they are not born evil, even though we are born more inclined toward evil/sin due to our first parents sin.  I think groups, however, can be intrinsically evil based on what they support.  

Posted

We are all made in the image and likeness of God. Because of that, no one can ever be evil at their core, even though they might choose evil actions. We are like silver; if we submerge ourselves in mud and muck and dirt then we will become tarnished. If we submerge ourselves in enough dirt it will become impossible even to glimpse the shining material underneath (and even harder to scrape the dirt off). But no matter how many evil acts a person may commit, they still possess that likeness. If a person could be totally evil there would be no hope for them, and there is always hope.

veritasluxmea
Posted

Can people *be* evil itself? Well, can people *be* goodness itself? I think people can be *like* Christ or *like* Satan to the point of total possession of that good spirit or bad spirit, but not be the goodness or evil itself.

truthfinder
Posted

From the depths of the memory of what my elementary religion teacher said, people are inherently and innately good, the crown jewel in the crown of God's Creation.  People are never evil, and cannot become evil although their actions certainly are and those actions merit punishment.  But we are made and image and likeness of God, and God Himself is Good. 

HopefulHeart
Posted

"And God saw everything that he had made, and behold, it was very good." Genesis 1:31

The word of God states that human beings, as creations of God, are good. So, people cannot be inherently evil, though they can perform evil acts.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

Can people truly be evil? Is it ontologically correct that a person or a group is evil?

​our human nature is weakened by original sin  but not evil in substance in terms of - total depravity... it is still good, but weakened and fallen. That's my understanding... ? we are still made in God's image.

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
Posted

The idea of total depravity is Protestant heresy. 

BarbTherese
Posted

I agree that the concept of total depravity as basic to the human being is complete error.  However, I do believe that the potential for real evil does exist in the human being, or those who have committed terrible evils cannot be human beings per se.  We can say that the DNA or genes or whatever (including nurture) are different in some human beings who commit terrible crimes, but that means that in the human being the potential for DNA and genes or whatever (including nurture) to be completely screwed up leading to shocking evil does exist.

BarbTherese
Posted

Can people be evil? Yes, I do believe that they can and that evil leads them to commit shocking crimes.  If this were not so, then grave matter with full knowledge and full consent could not lead that that actual person is condemned to Hell.  This is not to state that the human being is intrinsically evil, rather that the potential for evil does exist in the human being.

truthfinder
Posted

No, people can do evil, but people in their absolute state cannot be evil. 

  • 4 weeks later...
Miss Hepburn
Posted

No, people can do evil, but people in their absolute state cannot be evil. 

​Exactly.

Posted

What about evil people of our time that we can recall, Hitler, Timothy Mcvee , Osama, The Unibomber,  i think after one dies it might be simpler to say that person was evil, as a definitive  because their actions during their life would be proof. There are currently people involved in human trafficking and ISIS,  do we pray for their conversion or their destruction?; and/ or that they be brought to justice ( what ever that means cause it could involve the death penalty or life in prison ).

truthfinder
Posted

What about evil people of our time that we can recall, Hitler, Timothy Mcvee , Osama, The Unibomber,  i think after one dies it might be simpler to say that person was evil, as a definitive  because their actions during their life would be proof. There are currently people involved in human trafficking and ISIS,  do we pray for their conversion or their destruction?; and/ or that they be brought to justice ( what ever that means cause it could involve the death penalty or life in prison ).

​We call these people evil because they do evil things, not because they are evil.  We of course need to pray for their conversion, but this does not preclude bringing them to justice.  There were chaplains at the Nuremburg trials that worked exactly to bring about Nazi conversions while preparing them for the noose.  

Posted

​We call these people evil because they do evil things, not because they are evil.  We of course need to pray for their conversion, but this does not preclude bringing them to justice.  There were chaplains at the Nuremburg trials that worked exactly to bring about Nazi conversions while preparing them for the noose.  

​That part about the chaplains at the N/ Trials is amazing i never knew that.

truthfinder
Posted

​That part about the chaplains at the N/ Trials is amazing i never knew that.

​I read an article on it a while back.  If I can find the link, I'll post it. 

OfNoAccount
Posted

I am supposing that there really are demons.  I understand that they are pure spirit - that means they are not material - and they used to be angels.

Some people call them evil spirits.

Presumably, it is possible for a human being to do the same thing as the angels did at the beginning which was to rebel against God and to be cast out of Heaven.    My understanding is that the mercy of God is being shown to the offspring of our disobedient first parents and we are given time, a lifetime, to decide whether to serve God or to refuse to serve Him.

It will be at the Last Judgement that each of us will be finally elected or rejected - and this will be done by God the Father alone.

We are never to presume on what God judges of any other person, so it is better not to entertain the thought at any time about anybody.

What we are able to do is know if people are a danger to us or those we love and so are allowed to use the wisdom "by their fruits you shall know them" and attempt to avoid or minimise harm to yourself and those you love by responding in a way that protects or removes you.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...