Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Man Who Was Thursday


Recommended Posts

Ancilla Domini
Posted

Have any of you read this book? I just finished reading it, and I thought it would be nice if we could have a discussion on what in the name of sanity this book means! :hehe:

Posted

Wasn't that the one about a guy who was Thursday instead of Friday?

Ancilla Domini
Posted

Wasn't that the one about a guy who was Thursday instead of Friday?

​Oh my goodness yes! How did I not get that?!

PhuturePriest
Posted

The question is, rather, why was he not Sunday, the Lord's day? He is rather named after the day of Christ's suffering in Gethsamane, clearly meaning he suffers from great emotional affliction and internal strife.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Excellent book. :) I think one of the big themes was along the lines of hysteria or moral panic.

Posted

I have a friend named Sunday. I used to see her about once a week, usually on a Saturday, so I saw Sunday on Saturday.

 

True business.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

The Man Who Was Thursday is one of my favorite books.

I think one good way to see it is to look at it in terms of the problem of evil, and God's providence (read the last chapter carefully!).

On a more narrow level, it works as a good, "take that!" to all trendy philosophies that disparage reason and civilization.

HopefulHeart
Posted (edited)

This is such a great book. When I read it last summer, I jotted down some initial impressions about the book's idea of anarchy and chaos:

For me, one of the overarching themes is the apparent disorder, yet ultimate harmony, that is intrinsic to the human condition and to the universe itself. The idea of anarchy reminded me of an activity I did in a physics lab last year, using a computer program that plotted dots on a grid according to a sort of algorithm. At first the dots seemed like a chaotic mass, but they eventually formed intricate patterns. This "chaos game" was supposed to show that order sometimes results from seeming chaos. Similarly, I think Chesterton is showing that apparent disorder (such as in the crazy plot twists) is actually ordered when we consider it from an eternal, divine perspective. From God's point of view, everything is order, even what appears to us as chaotic. 

I think the book shows that chaos in the universe becomes wondrously and divinely ordered when it is considered from the Christian perspective.

Edited by HopefulHeart
veritasluxmea
Posted

Ya'll are smart. I couldn't get past the first chapter. :sleep2: 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Ya'll are smart. I couldn't get past the first chapter. :sleep2: 

​The book is so short! :P Take three hours to yourself, get a snack, and just power through. It is very funny, and very clever.

Posted

 I managed to read it a few years ago... the ending really tripped me out.  It became a real page turner for me as the days were revealed to me for who they really were…

Somebody competent should make a movie-- or is there a movie that I don't know about?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Sounds like it has been adapted as stage and radio plays, but never on screen. You are right, I think it could make an amazing movie.

Definitely cast Robert Downey Jr. as Sunday.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

Sounds like it has been adapted as stage and radio plays, but never on screen. You are right, I think it could make an amazing movie.

Definitely cast Robert Downey Jr. as Sunday.

​Sunday is supposed to be rather hefty, though, no? It'd be an ideal role for Orson Welles if he were still alive; he even already did one of the radio plays.

Not A Mallard
Posted

That man was Thursday? THEN WHO WAS PHONE?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

​Sunday is supposed to be rather hefty, though, no? It'd be an ideal role for Orson Welles if he were still alive; he even already did one of the radio plays.

​True. Perhaps a convincing fat suit... I just feel like he has the right personality for that. :hehe:

veritasluxmea
Posted

​The book is so short! :P Take three hours to yourself, get a snack, and just power through. It is very funny, and very clever.

​But then I'd have to get off Phatmass :/ 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

​But then I'd have to get off Phatmass :/ 

​You say that like it is a bad thing. :|

HopefulHeart
Posted

​Sunday is supposed to be rather hefty, though, no? It'd be an ideal role for Orson Welles if he were still alive; he even already did one of the radio plays.​

I also thought of Orson Welles as a good candidate. I imagine Sunday as having the charisma of Welles and the appearance of actor Sydney Greenstreet (image below).

o4il5FU.jpg

Ancilla Domini
Posted

I also thought of Orson Welles as a good candidate. I imagine Sunday as having the charisma of Welles and the appearance of actor Sydney Greenstreet (image below).

o4il5FU.jpg

​Oh, Sydney Greenstreet and Orson Welles would both be good! I think Sydney Greenstreet, though, because I just can't imagine Orson Welles on the back of an elephant, or in a balloon. xD

What about Thursday?

HopefulHeart
Posted

​What about Thursday?

Hm, I don't know. To be honest, I don't clearly recall the details of Thursday's personality. He was supposed to be rather poetic, right? Maybe a blond George Sanders...?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...