Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What do you think about this picture?


Recommended Posts

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

I recently made a picture of the Blessed Virgin Mary (in pencil and some watercolour). I'm still learning how to draw Our Lady so I used a reference image on the internet.. I'm not sure if it's old and if it's public domain or not. I started just copying the image, to learn - which is very common for beginning artists (and advanced artists too). However, as I kept drawing, it began to look different.. her head is turned a different direction, her expression is kind of different, and I changed parts of the face - though not others. The proportions are pretty much the same. I also added a crown of flowers and the original image has her hands, which I didn't include.

The problem is now I have no idea if this is a "derivative" work or not.. I read that you can copy other pictures for personal study, but if you want to really share them with others, they shouldn't be copies or derivative works. The test seems to be if it looks like a derivative work. Although I meant it to be like that at first, later I changed my mind and made sort of my own picture. I don't know if it looks different enough.. I mean every picture of Mary looks "sort of" similar, just like with Our Lord. I was wondering if anyone knows anything about this and maybe I could try posting the pictures and you can tell me if they look similar or like different pictures :)

Here's the original: http://www.bing.com/images/search?q=Blessed+Virgin+Mary&view=detailv2&&&id=93A54D048ED9B0CFED101F65D153A6DB5DFEDE65&selectedIndex=0&ccid=VNZDqSap&simid=608005805917212118&thid=JN.%2fCCdBrXnE4495iLFMTm6hA

Here's my version (the original is black and white without the background, that was something I added later on my phone when I took the picture.. I also made it a close up because I liked that more) http://i1148.photobucket.com/albums/o564/littleflower11/IMG_20150531_230312_zpsfgempycd.jpg 

thanks! :)

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
PhuturePriest
Posted

Very nice! I particularly like the larger eyes, but that preference is due to having watched too many animes. :P

truthfinder
Posted

It's lovely! and I certainly wouldn't worry about the derivative issue.  

Posted

Honestly the two look nothing alike, your drawing Mary looks older (older teen vs young teen) maybe due to the slimness in the face.  The eyes are bigger and more winsome.  The first picture Mary's head is tilted, in yours the neck is simply turned. 

By all of this I don't mean to say yours is not pretty, it's quite pretty, though I'd like to see the rest of the head, neck, sholders and hands like the first, but it's simply different.  There's only so many way that one can draw a young, innocent white girl with veil (Mary was really middle eastern) so I think if you're in danger of derivative issues so are 90% of the people drawing Mary would have to not share their work becuase of derivative stopping.  Plus most well known religious is public domain

PhuturePriest
Posted

I recently made a picture of the Blessed Virgin Mary (in pencil and some watercolour). I'm still learning how to draw Our Lady so I used a reference image on the internet.. I'm not sure if it's old and if it's public domain or not. I started just copying the image, to learn - which is very common for beginning artists (and advanced artists too). However, as I kept drawing, it began to look different.. her head is turned a different direction, her expression is kind of different, and I changed parts of the face - though not others. The proportions are pretty much the same. I also added a crown of flowers and the original image has her hands, which I didn't include.

The problem is now I have no idea if this is a "derivative" work or not.. I read that you can copy other pictures for personal study, but if you want to really share them with others, they shouldn't be copies or derivative works. The test seems to be if it looks like a derivative work. Although I meant it to be like that at first, later I changed my mind and made sort of my own picture. I don't know if it looks different enough.. I mean every picture of Mary looks "sort of" similar, just like with Our Lord. I was wondering if anyone knows anything about this and maybe I could try posting the pictures and you can tell me if they look similar or like different pictures :)

Here's the original: http://www.bing.com/images/search?q=Blessed+Virgin+Mary&view=detailv2&&&id=93A54D048ED9B0CFED101F65D153A6DB5DFEDE65&selectedIndex=0&ccid=VNZDqSap&simid=608005805917212118&thid=JN.%2fCCdBrXnE4495iLFMTm6hA

Here's my version (the original is black and white without the background, that was something I added later on my phone when I took the picture.. I also made it a close up because I liked that more) http://i1148.photobucket.com/albums/o564/littleflower11/IMG_20150531_230312_zpsfgempycd.jpg 

thanks! :)

​I didn't read the full post and so didn't catch the original.

In all honesty, I like yours a lot more than the original! Yours is closer to the Virgin Mary as I envision her, and I very much like it. 

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

Thank you for the replies! :) I'm glad you like the picture- I was never able to draw Mary in detail before and I believe Our Lady helped me with it :) I can't wait to see the real Mary someday - she must be infinitely more beautiful than any image made by people.

I hope this one expresses something about her... God bless!

Edited by MarysLittleFlower

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...