Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

the Church and homosexuals


Recommended Posts

franciscanheart
Posted

You went wrong at the very start and now I'm afraid to finish reading. Homophobia is not a real phobia. Take ANY psych class and you will learn that homophobia is not a real phobia but a prejudice. Obviously no rational person believes homophobia is an actual phobia. :ohno:

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

You went wrong at the very start and now I'm afraid to finish reading. Homophobia is not a real phobia. Take ANY psych class and you will learn that homophobia is not a real phobia but a prejudice. Obviously no rational person believes homophobia is an actual phobia. :ohno:

that is what they say today.. I meant it more in a linguistic sense because the way its used today can easily be applied to a Catholic who disagrees with homosexuality. In the blog post I tried to differentiate between disagreement with homosexuality and hatred of the people themselves. That is the main idea, not about the phobia part. That could even be taken out and it wouldn't change the point. I could add the part about prejudice but honestly that can easily be twisted to say that that disagreement is prejudice... Can it not? I'll try to clarify more but in many psych classes today they might also say that disagreements with the actions are prejudice therefore homophobia. I think the term is easily misused and I think it needs a lot of clarification. 

franciscanheart
Posted

that is what they say today.. I meant it more in a linguistic sense because the way its used today can easily be applied to a Catholic who disagrees with homosexuality. In the blog post I tried to differentiate between disagreement with homosexuality and hatred of the people themselves. That is the main idea, not about the phobia part. That could even be taken out and it wouldn't change the point. I could add the part about prejudice but honestly that can easily be twisted to say that that disagreement is prejudice... Can it not? I'll try to clarify more but in many psych classes today they might also say that disagreements with the actions are prejudice therefore homophobia. I think the term is easily misused and I think it needs a lot of clarification. 

No, I don't think it can be twisted to mean disagreement. Here's the definition:

prej·u·dice
ˈprejədəs/
noun
 
  1. 1.
    preconceived opinion that is not based on reason or actual experience.
    "English prejudice against foreigners"
    synonyms: preconceived idea, preconception, prejudgment
    "male prejudices about women"
    •  
       
       
       
       
  2. 2.
    LAW
    harm or injury that results or may result from some action or judgment.
    "prejudice resulting from delay in the institution of the proceedings"
    synonyms: detriment, harm, damage, injury, hurt, loss
    "without prejudice to the interests of others"
verb
 
  1. 1.
    give rise to prejudice in (someone); make biased.
    "the statement might prejudice the jury"
    synonyms: bias, influence, sway, predispose, make biased, make partial, color
    "the article could prejudice the jury"
  2. 2.
    LAW
    cause harm to (a state of affairs).
    "delay is likely to prejudice the child's welfare"
    synonyms: damage, be detrimental to, be prejudicial to, injure, harm, hurt, spoil,impair, undermine, hinder, compromise
    "this could prejudice his chances of victory"

As a gay Catholic, I can tell you that the big C Church's teaching does not trickle down very well to the little c church action. So, I don't really fault people for not understanding how the Church really feels when the church can't seem to get it together in the area of treating homosexuals like people before sexual actions. Make sense?

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I changed it a bit, what do you think about it now? I actually heard the "phobia" argument somewhere that's why I used it.

Posted

Homophobia is a phobia. Gays are extremely scared of my heterosexuality. They are afraid if they associate with me they might go straight.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I changed it again because I realized I was thinking of active homosexuals who disagree with the Church, not Catholics. I made a clarification about that later in the post. ...I know this is a complex issue. By no means am I saying that my post is perfect. If anything is very unclear or unhelpful let me know :)

franciscanheart
Posted

I changed it a bit, what do you think about it now? I actually heard the "phobia" argument somewhere that's why I used it.

Yeah, I've seen it a couple places too. It's weak since homophobia isn't listed anywhere as a legitimate phobia. We all know you aren't afraid of gays, you just have a prejudice against them. (No YOU YOU. The general you. You know what I mean. You.)

Homophobia is a phobia. Gays are extremely scared of my heterosexuality. They are afraid if they associate with me they might go straight.

:huh:

Posted (edited)

As a gay Catholic, I can tell you that the big C Church's teaching does not trickle down very well to the little c church action. So, I don't really fault people for not understanding how the Church really feels when the church can't seem to get it together in the area of treating homosexuals like people before sexual actions. Make sense?

This was my biggest struggle as a Catholic  before I fell away and I still struggle with it when Im around Catholics. It never seemed to me that the Church (big C) ever condoned poor treatement, neglect, or whathaveyou of the LGTBQ+ community, but like you said, the "love" doenst translate very far down to the general Catholic public. I have witnessed it countless times in my experiences around some of my Catholic friends who are rigid in their defense of traditional marriage. Numerous times the LGTBQ+ persons have been refered to as "those people" with snippy tones, or "how dare the partner of my homosexual patient kiss and comfort his sick loved one in front of me" or "God is on OUR side" somehow implying that God has forsaken the LGTBQ+ community or some nonesense.

I dunno I dont get it. The words are there "We love all people but we hate sin" but the actions arent there. I see a lot of stuff about how we dont want to go to their weddings, we dont want them to come to ours, we dont want them to be around our kids, we dont want them to be involved in our lives. Essentially saying we love them, but we cast them away. 

Jesus ate with lepers, tax collectors, and sinners. He welcomed them into his home. I just dont see the general Catholic community doing much to show their love for their homosexual brothers and sisters so I have a hard time accepting long posts like the OP's blog that tries to explain it. Good intentions only go so far if they dont make it out on the pavement. 

Edited by CrossCuT
franciscanheart
Posted

This is going to end up in the Debate Table. I can feel it in my bones.

"The Church fits in this category: intolerant of error, tolerant to people even if they commit the error. Meaning: it waits patiently and prays for their finding of the truth."

Hmmm. Big C Church, yes. Little c church, no.

"We don’t need to reject seeking truth to be loving people. And I think its way better to seek the TRUTH rather than ask “what is most popular? Relevant? Progressive? Modern?”. Would you like a person thinking this way in Germany at the time of Hitler, or prefer the approach of another who seeks the truth whatever it is?"

Two things: 1. Do you really think that every person on the earth who believes that homosexuals can be bound in relationships (which include sex) without committing sin, believe so because it's modern and progressive? You don't think those people have searched their minds and hearts for the answer to whether it is okay or not? Do you REALLY think you're the only one who has thought long and hard about this in the context of God and what He wants for His people? REALLY? 2. Terrible idea to compare anything like this to supporters of Hitler, genocide, abortion, etc. Really terrible, very bad, completely awful idea.

Amor vincit omnia
Posted

No, I don't think it can be twisted to mean disagreement. Here's the definition:

prej·u·dice
ˈprejədəs/
noun
 
  1. 1.
    preconceived opinion that is not based on reason or actual experience.
    "English prejudice against foreigners"
    synonyms: preconceived idea, preconception, prejudgment
    "male prejudices about women"
    •  
       
       
       
       
  2. 2.
    LAW
    harm or injury that results or may result from some action or judgment.
    "prejudice resulting from delay in the institution of the proceedings"
    synonyms: detriment, harm, damage, injury, hurt, loss
    "without prejudice to the interests of others"
verb
 
  1. 1.
    give rise to prejudice in (someone); make biased.
    "the statement might prejudice the jury"
    synonyms: bias, influence, sway, predispose, make biased, make partial, color
    "the article could prejudice the jury"
  2. 2.
    LAW
    cause harm to (a state of affairs).
    "delay is likely to prejudice the child's welfare"
    synonyms: damage, be detrimental to, be prejudicial to, injure, harm, hurt, spoil,impair, undermine, hinder, compromise
    "this could prejudice his chances of victory"

As a gay Catholic, I can tell you that the big C Church's teaching does not trickle down very well to the little c church action. So, I don't really fault people for not understanding how the Church really feels when the church can't seem to get it together in the area of treating homosexuals like people before sexual actions. Make sense?

Thank you for posting this response. As another Gay Catholic I 100% agree with you with how the Church can't seem to get it together in understanding that before anything I am a human being!

Posted

While it should not be a sovereign judge, prejudice is often a good adviser. 

Posted

I understand better why you think white people should prefer white people over black people. 

I have never said that. Please stop spreading the obnoxious lie that I am a racist. I have never been one and will never be. 

Posted

I think the treatment of homosexuals by the "little c" church can be attributed somewhat to the nature of arguments.

What I mean by this is, when there are two sides of an issue, both sides try to make their points known. Our human nature doesn't just allow us to make our rational points, and move on--if we feel like the other side isn't "getting it", we make our points stronger. In turn, this makes the other side make their point stronger. The end result is two extremes of a spectrum (see liberal vs conservative politics). What naturally happens is now you are only hearing the very loudest of each side of the issue--who are usually not the people who you want representing your issue in the first place.

franciscanheart
Posted

I think the treatment of homosexuals by the "little c" church can be attributed somewhat to the nature of arguments.

What I mean by this is, when there are two sides of an issue, both sides try to make their points known. Our human nature doesn't just allow us to make our rational points, and move on--if we feel like the other side isn't "getting it", we make our points stronger. In turn, this makes the other side make their point stronger. The end result is two extremes of a spectrum (see liberal vs conservative politics). What naturally happens is now you are only hearing the very loudest of each side of the issue--who are usually not the people who you want representing your issue in the first place.

I hear a lot of those people here at Phatmass, which makes me sad.

veritasluxmea
Posted (edited)

I think the treatment of homosexuals by the "little c" church can be attributed somewhat to the nature of arguments.

What I mean by this is, when there are two sides of an issue, both sides try to make their points known. Our human nature doesn't just allow us to make our rational points, and move on--if we feel like the other side isn't "getting it", we make our points stronger. In turn, this makes the other side make their point stronger. The end result is two extremes of a spectrum (see liberal vs conservative politics). What naturally happens is now you are only hearing the very loudest of each side of the issue--who are usually not the people who you want representing your issue in the first place.

I think it comes out more on the internet too because we're only communicating with writing, concepts, and ideas, not personal, conversational interaction. 

Edited by veritasluxmea
Credo in Deum
Posted (edited)

This was my biggest struggle as a Catholic  before I fell away and I still struggle with it when Im around Catholics. It never seemed to me that the Church (big C) ever condoned poor treatement, neglect, or whathaveyou of the LGTBQ+ community, but like you said, the "love" doenst translate very far down to the general Catholic public. I have witnessed it countless times in my experiences around some of my Catholic friends who are rigid in their defense of traditional marriage. Numerous times the LGTBQ+ persons have been refered to as "those people" with snippy tones, or "how dare the partner of my homosexual patient kiss and comfort his sick loved one in front of me" or "God is on OUR side" somehow implying that God has forsaken the LGTBQ+ community or some nonesense.

I dunno I dont get it. The words are there "We love all people but we hate sin" but the actions arent there. I see a lot of stuff about how we dont want to go to their weddings, we dont want them to come to ours, we dont want them to be around our kids, we dont want them to be involved in our lives. Essentially saying we love them, but we cast them away. 

Jesus ate with lepers, tax collectors, and sinners. He welcomed them into his home. I just dont see the general Catholic community doing much to show their love for their homosexual brothers and sisters so I have a hard time accepting long posts like the OP's blog that tries to explain it. Good intentions only go so far if they dont make it out on the pavement. 

From my experience when Catholics have said "we" when referring to homosexuals, it was in reference to those who obstinately oppose Church teaching and who are active in spreading an agenda which is contrary to the Catholic Faith.  I'm not saying that there aren't Catholics who have done what you said, but I do not see them as the majority within the Church. 

Also Christ never had a home.  He did not invite anyone and everyone into His home.  He did, however, go out to the homes of those who were sinners, sick, and who held jobs that were considered to be 'traitorous' in the eyes of the Jewish people.  His visits were not proof that He was indifferent to how they lived their lives.   Rather His visits all stressed two major things; Mercy and Conversion.  

Edited by Credo in Deum
Posted

I have never said that. Please stop spreading the obnoxious lie that I am a racist. I have never been one and will never be. 

Maybe if you didn't write things that sound really racist, people wouldn't think you're racist. Tips for life!

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

Sorry if my post was unhelpful to anyone. The whole idea in it was that we are to treat homosexuals as persons and that this is the Church teaching... And that disagreement with the actions doesn't - shouldn't - mean we should treat someone with less love. For those who said that many Catholics aren't loving in practice - that is sad, but I think there are many who do they just don't make a show. I have ways to grow in this for sure. But I have friends who have very different views and lifestyles from mine. I disagree with their views and its not unloving, but loving to pray fortheir conversion. But they are genuiely my friends. I'd say many other Catholics have friends like this too :) so I tried to say in my post that we can treat people who disagree with the Church with charity and patience while having strongbeliefs. I'm referring to those who disagree. A Catholic with SSA agrees and we're both Catholic. 

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Maybe if you didn't write things that sound really racist, people wouldn't think you're racist. Tips for life!

Maybe if Americans didn't see racism in even the slightest dissent from the liberal anti-racism paranoia, people wouldn't think I'm racist. 

Talking with Americans on racial differences is like talking with North-Korean communists on income differences. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...