Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

julianneoflongbeach
Posted

 

1. God is a jerk who hates us, but claims to love us. (Another issue he struggles with is how God treated Job. He thinks he tortured him just to prove a point.)

 

Job didn't exist... Job is a Hebrew book of poetry a la song of songs. But it is powerful in how it shows the relation between God and evil. God didn't cause anything bad to happen to Job, but He allowed it in order to purify Job's faith.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I agree with the rest but I believe Job existed..

Posted

1. God is a jerk who hates us, but claims to love us. (Another issue he struggles with is how God treated Job. He thinks he tortured him just to prove a point.)

 

2. God does not exist.

 

3. You can't know 100% for sure whether God exists or not, so why bother trying?

Well if #1 is true we had better get our act together anyway. Whether or not God loves us or is "a jerk", if Hell exists it would be best that we do whatever we need to do to stay up out of that piece.

#2 #3 - if anything exists then God exists. The proofs that Aquinas set forth have not been refuted. And folks like William Lane Craig easily show that it is more rational to believe in God than to be an agnostic/atheists.

Besides - if not having 100% certainty is an excuse, then it is an excuse for anything.  Can he prove that he is not a brain in a vat? That we are not in the Matrix? That our bodies and the planet actually exist?  Not having 100% certainty seems like a huge cop-out to me.

So endeth my rant.

My younger brother is an atheist and their arguments are frustrating, by the way. If you just want to live your life and do what you want to do regardless of what God thinks, be a man and admit it. That it is what it really comes down to. Don't come up with all of these lame arguments about God not existing or being a jerk and so forth just because you don't like the idea of being under authority.

tinytherese
Posted

My brother's opinion on Job unfortunately was influenced by watching South Park. <_< I wish he stopped watching that trash.

The story is presented as God bragging to Satan about how wonderful Job is and Satan arguing back that he's only holy because God has blest him with so many good things. God responds that they'll see about that after he takes them away. Job still praises the Lord and God wins the challenge. A character on the show says it's the worst story he ever heard and that God just tormented Job to make a point. :ohno:

Credo in Deum
Posted

My brother's opinion on Job unfortunately was influenced by watching South Park. <_< I wish he stopped watching that trash.

The story is presented as God bragging to Satan about how wonderful Job is and Satan arguing back that he's only holy because God has blest him with so many good things. God responds that they'll see about that after he takes them away. Job still praises the Lord and God wins the challenge. A character on the show says it's the worst story he ever heard and that God just tormented Job to make a point. :ohno:

Yes, that sounds typical of South Park, but hey you're not going to change their minds and depending on your brother's age you probably won't be able to help influence his thoughts either.  

In anycase you can tell your brother that the exchange between the devil and God is to illustrate that God is in control, not satan.  That when things befall us, whether they be good or bad, that God has willed them either by ordaining them or by permitting them. This is usually a tough thing even for Catholics to grasp and accept.

Credo in Deum
Posted

There.  Much better.

julianneoflongbeach
Posted

...I concur. :oops: Sorry.

CountrySteve937
Posted

The USCCB has a general introduction to the book on its website

http://www.usccb.org/bible/job/

"This is a literary composition, and not a transcript of historical events and conversations."

 

 

 

 

BarbTherese
Posted

http://www.catholic.com/magazine/articles/is-everything-in-the-bible-true

Genre and the Principle of Assertion

"When interpreting the "literal sense" of the Bible, we must distinguish between the narration and the form of narration, also known as genre. Narration is the telling of things that happened and genre is the style used to tell what happened. In all cultures, many different styles and methods are used to communicate messages.

Scholars have listed nine kinds of literary forms in the narrative literature or historical books of the Old Testament: fable, parable, historical epic, religious history, ancient history, popular tradition, liberal narrative, Midrash (commentary), and prophetical and apocalyptical narrative (John E. Steinmueller, A Companion to Scripture Studies, 33). Whatever genre is used, the question that must be considered is what the author asserted or intended to communicate by using this style of narration. The answer to this question will supply the literal sense of the passage.

For example, in Micah 3:2-3, we read, "You that hate good, and love evil; that violently pluck off their skins from them, and their flesh from their homes? Who have eaten the flesh of my people, and have flayed their skin from off them: and have broken, and chopped their bones as for the kettle, and as flesh in the midst of the pot." Does the author mean that the enemies of God’s people were cannibals? No: He is asserting that the enemies of God persecuted the people of God. The passage represents a common Hebraic style of writing employed to assert the reality of persecution and war (see also Deut. 32:42; Ezek. 39:17-18; Rev. 17:6, 16). To interpret this passage without considering the Hebrew genre, one would have to conclude that flesh was actually being eaten and blood actually being drunk.

The principle of affirmation or assertion is the key element in Biblical interpretation. The Catechism of the Catholic Church states, "the reader must be attentive to what the human authors truly wanted to affirm and to what God wanted to reveal to us by their words" (CCC 109). Furthermore, "in order to discover the sacred authors’ intention," the Catechism states "the reader must take into account the conditions of their times and culture, the literal genres in use at that time, and the modes of feeling, speaking, and narrating then current" (CCC 110). Notice that the Catechism implies there are different modes of narrating, i.e., genres. The reason for the variety of genres is found in Dei Verbum, which states, "For the fact is that truth is differently presented and expressed in the various types of historical writing, in prophetical and poetical texts, and in other forms of literary expression" (12).

Therefore, when we engage in the difficult task of interpretation, the principle of affirmation or assertion, which is connected to genre, must be the guiding principle for the literal sense. The interpretation guidelines for the spiritual sense of Scripture can be found in paragraphs 111-117 of the Catechism.

Further Reading

  • Fr. William G. Most, Free From All Error, second ed. (Prow, 1990)
  • The Pontifical Biblical Commission, The Interpretation of the Bible in the Church, available at www.ewtn.com.
  • Pope Benedict XV, Spiritus Paraclitus. Available at www.ewtn.com."

My brother's opinion on Job unfortunately was influenced by watching South Park. <_< I wish he stopped watching that trash.

The story is presented as God bragging to Satan about how wonderful Job is and Satan arguing back that he's only holy because God has blest him with so many good things. God responds that they'll see about that after he takes them away. Job still praises the Lord and God wins the challenge. A character on the show says it's the worst story he ever heard and that God just tormented Job to make a point. :ohno:

Sometimes we are the sower who goes out to sow and our seed falls amongst rocks.  I have reasoned that the wind(Holy Spirit) just could carry it to good and fertile soil since I have at times planted my seed so to say to have it completely rejected - and then years down the line find out that it actually flowered.

The other interesting point about the Parable of The Sower for me, is that the sower does not search around for good and fertile soil.  He simply goes out and casts his seeds, fall wherever they may.  Sow prayerfully and with detachment depending on The Lord who along can bring forth flowering. 

I know that sowing can be a frustrating type of labour and even a grief filled labour.  The fruits of The Holy Spirit are : CCC - 1832 The fruits of the Spirit are perfections that the Holy Spirit forms in us as the first fruits of eternal glory. The tradition of the Church lists twelve of them: "charity, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, generosity, gentleness, faithfulness, modesty, self-control, chastity."

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...