Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Basilisa Marie
Posted

As a means of procrastinating on my coursework, I looked up this issue and found these two articles that might interest y'all:

http://ncronline.org/blogs/young-voices/churchs-wage-gap

http://www.uscatholic.org/church/2008/07/does-it-pay-work-church

 

So, why would someone spent $100k to get a degree in theology? I mean, it's one thing if you're going to be a doctor or maybe even a lawyer, but really? 

I find more frustrating the prejudice some priests have. I've encountered more than a few that will only hire married people, preferably married men, or go find a religious sister to fill the role. I've found a good position and plan on keeping it, but it was after dealing with some not-so-great stuff. 

Posted

So, why would someone spent $100k to get a degree in theology? I mean, it's one thing if you're going to be a doctor or maybe even a lawyer, but really? 

That's an excellent question. "Personal fulfillment"? Seems really foolish practically speaking.

In my department, and I believe in my entire university, you will not be accepted to graduate studies if the department cannot fund you (by a teaching/research assistantship and/or fellowship). They feel it's unethical to accept people who will have to take out tens of thousands of dollars in debt when the academic job market is so uncertain. They see accepting unfunded students as "enabling" them in financial ruin, which they're not willing to have on their consciences.

Considering the ministry job market is even more uncertain, I think Catholic institutions that offer degrees in theology and ministry really ought to think about the ethics of their programs as well.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Pursuing academics for its own sake is noble in a way, but you need deep pockets or a magnanimous benefactor to do it.

Posted (edited)

Working for a diocese is often less than ideal. Sadly, the church seems to sometimes not share best practice and instead goes for the basics allowed in a certain region. The issue, I think, is the matter of money among parishes and dioceses in general. It's been practice for a long time for members of parishes to give very little in comparison to members of other churches. The Episcopal church gets more money to play with and it can fund staff and clergy.  We, well, don't. This has worked out OK in Catholic parishes in the past because a single church could survive in a big parish area with lots of people giving small amounts. They could pay the bills, keep a low stipend priest and even have a small surprlus. But as buildings get older, the demographics change, costs increase and the demands for staffing increases there are big problems, including parish closures. Dioceses, like religious orders, have to find ways to pay pensions and look after elderly priests etc.

I find it remarkable that parishes are so self restrained to talk about economic realities and dioceses only do so when it's too late! Those groups calling for married men to be allowed to be priests don't realise that the church simply couldn't afford a priest with dependents at the current levels of income. Theology and customs aside, there is an economic reality that prevents any change in this partiicular area. Where the issue won't go away is when parishes need paid lay staff when there aren't low stipend priests to manage things cheaply. Will the outlay be there for staff to get paid or will the Church close? I think it tends to be the latter. In the meantime posts for lay staff will, on the whole, be with large richer parishes. The number of posts though will, I suspect, get smaller over time.

Edited by Benedictus
Posted

So, why would someone spent $100k to get a degree in theology? I mean, it's one thing if you're going to be a doctor or maybe even a lawyer, but really? 

I find more frustrating the prejudice some priests have. I've encountered more than a few that will only hire married people, preferably married men, or go find a religious sister to fill the role. I've found a good position and plan on keeping it, but it was after dealing with some not-so-great stuff. 

Back when I was a Baptist, my old church refused to hire a man in his late 20s who was single "because he must be gay to not be married"*.  So I'm not surprised.

*He's now married to my cousin.

BarbTherese
Posted (edited)

Wrong thread!

Edited by BarbaraTherese
Posted

This is good advice for everyone not just church employees! I read that about 50% of Americans have no retirement savings at all. I imagine in Canada there is more social support. But I'm sure conditions are similar. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...