Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Seriously. Define it please.

A few questions for the Greek readers among you.

1)  From what I understand there are 3 words that are translated in the Bible as "love".  When Jesus says "Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and with all your strength.’ The second is this: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself" - could someone here explain to me what words for "love" are used there - and what they mean?

2)  When I think of the word "love" in relation to a person - I typically define it as "Doing whatever is best for the other person." What is your own personal way of defining "love" towards other people? What is the Catholic way of defining it?  I had thought that it was "Doing whatever is best for the other person" but I am not sure if that is correct.

3) The trickier question for me is - how do we define "love" in relation to God?  What does it mean to love God?  I don't think we can say "To love God is to do whatever is best for God". That doesn't really make sense - it is not as though our actions benefit or harm God.

The best definition that I can think of when it comes to God is - "To love God is to follow His commandments."  Jesus does say "If you love me follow my commandments."  But I dunno. I think that we obey out of love - but obedience is something other than love. So - what does "Love God" mean to people here? Is it a mushy feeling? Is it a feeling of gratitude? Is it a strong commitment to follow Him?

Credo in Deum
Posted

I've always liked this one: "Love is a mutual self-giving which ends in self-recovery." --Ven. Fulton J Sheen  

 

veritasluxmea
Posted

All the title makes me think of is this scene.  

Maybe like dancing it's something you have to do to get. 

Posted (edited)

As a Catholic to "Love God" to me means listening to what the Church ask of me and following Her teachings. And it's tough and in my 33 years here on Earth I've failed 99% of the time. I'm the first to admit that isn't acceptable. Going to Mass every week and on Holy Days isn't easy or all Catholics would do it. Humbling yourself to Confess the same sin over and over to a Priest isn't easy or all Catholics would do it. Being single and admitting even masturbation is a mortal sin that will send you to hell is not easy to accept. Yet in my opinion to love God is to accept the difficult teaching and try to follow them even if it seems impossible. To love God as a Catholic to me is to love everyone I encounter with the love of Christ. To help the poor and give them food and drink. Again I've failed most of the time and if you were on the outside looking in at my life played back you would conclude without question I deserve hell. Well most of you of would. It's only with God's love and grace shown to me that I even attempt to try to love Him. If God fills you in with the truth then it's impossible to love Him without denying yourself and taking up your cross. Again I'm the first to say I walk on thin ice because some days I give in before I even start and I walk without the cross. But life is empty without taking your cross up and the anxiety and 6th sense of knowing God's wrath and judgment awaits you if you give in and don't take up the Cross is enough to get me to come to my senses and attempt to walk with Him. Also always remembering that it's His love for me that saves me at the end of the day. My love is jaded and shallow and although God deserves my love if everything falls on me I don't stand a chance. My righteous acts and love are like filthy rags. But I still offer it up to Him and pray to always be with Him. And to love Him with the true meaning of the word.

Edited by Guest
Posted

Seriously. Define it please.

A few questions for the Greek readers among you.

1)  From what I understand there are 3 words that are translated in the Bible as "love".  When Jesus says "Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and with all your strength.’ The second is this: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself" - could someone here explain to me what words for "love" are used there - and what they mean?

Let's see if I can remember this: eros (the root word for 'erotic') = sexual love; philos (the root of 'Philadelphia') = brotherly love; and agape (the root of apparently nothing in English) = selfless love. I doubt that "eros" is the word used in the Biblical passages. 

2)  When I think of the word "love" in relation to a person - I typically define it as "Doing whatever is best for the other person." What is your own personal way of defining "love" towards other people? What is the Catholic way of defining it?  I had thought that it was "Doing whatever is best for the other person" but I am not sure if that is correct.

Somewhere in one of Paul's letters, he defines love as you do above, but I've always heard it as "wanting" what's best for the other person. For instance, a parent can want what is best for her adult child, but the adult child still has to make her own choices and do for herself what she considers best. But I might be splitting hairs. 

3) The trickier question for me is - how do we define "love" in relation to God?  What does it mean to love God?  I don't think we can say "To love God is to do whatever is best for God". That doesn't really make sense - it is not as though our actions benefit or harm God.

The best definition that I can think of when it comes to God is - "To love God is to follow His commandments."  Jesus does say "If you love me follow my commandments."  But I dunno. I think that we obey out of love - but obedience is something other than love. So - what does "Love God" mean to people here? Is it a mushy feeling? Is it a feeling of gratitude? Is it a strong commitment to follow Him?

Excellent question. I've wondered the same thing myself. Like you, the only definition I've been able to come up with is following God's commandments. But I've never read Aquinas - if anyone has a clear definition, it would be The Big Guy. 

 

julianneoflongbeach
Posted

God is love and is the source of love. To love God is to acknowledge Him for exactly who He is, to seek to please Him for exactly who He is, and to attempt to never grieve Him for exactly who He is. Everyone's heart is capable of this.

Posted

God is love

Beat me to it. ;) 

HopefulHeart
Posted

Here is St. Paul's description of the attributes of love. This may be a good passage to pray with as you consider the nature of love: 

4 Love is patient and kind; love is not jealous or boastful; 5 it is not arrogant or rude. Love does not insist on its own way; it is not irritable or resentful; 6 it does not rejoice at wrong, but rejoices in the right. 7 Love bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things. 8 Love never ends.... (1 Corinthians 13:4-8)

St. Thomas Aquinas agrees with Aristotle's statement that "to love is to wish good to someone." (http://www.newadvent.org/summa/2026.htm#article4)

dominicansoul
Posted

Love demands sacrifice.  Love Itself is Sacrificial.

What does this mean?  Well, the Church delves deep into this, but I can easily explain what Love is not.  We are constantly bombarded with secular definitions of "love."  But love defined outside of God is not love.  We were all born with sin, born with a tendency towards sin, and we all bear the weight of our sinfulness.  Accepting sinful lifestyles (or participating in sinful lifestyles)  is NOT love, regardless of how loud society barks that message.    If we truly love God (Who is Love Himself,) we would deny our very selves for LOVE of HIM, just as He died for love of us.  Now is it easy to Love?  No.  There's a reason why they say "Love hurts."  This is where the sacrifice comes in.  If you love someone, you will want what is best for that person, you will want that person to be with God for all eternity, and you will do everything you can to lead that person towards God.  This is difficult.  This will hurt.  This is never popular.

This is also why Jesus Himself said the road to Hell is wide open like a 10 lane toll-free highway through Dallas, but the road to Heaven is narrow and filled with obstacles, and very few find it.  Very few people know how to truly love...because somewhere in the midst of our lives we have forgotten to sacrifice ourselves for each other.  And we cannot love without the sacrifice...

Posted

Yay, Greek! I'm going to limit myself to that, because I think everyone else has great answers. When Jesus gives these two commandments, he uses agape. A really famous occurrence of changing between the different words for love comes in John 21. Jesus asks Peter "Peter do you agape me?" (for those of you who know greek, I'm obviously butchering the conjugation, meh). Peter responds "Lord you know I phileo you." This repeats 2x, then the last time Jesus asks "Peter, do you phileo me? At which point Peter "becomes grieved." Anyway, a beautiful reading made more beautiful by understanding the Greek. It's amazing in how it shows Jesus lowering himself to our level. 

Posted

Yay, Greek! I'm going to limit myself to that, because I think everyone else has great answers. When Jesus gives these two commandments, he uses agape. A really famous occurrence of changing between the different words for love comes in John 21. Jesus asks Peter "Peter do you agape me?" (for those of you who know greek, I'm obviously butchering the conjugation, meh). Peter responds "Lord you know I phileo you." This repeats 2x, then the last time Jesus asks "Peter, do you phileo me? At which point Peter "becomes grieved." Anyway, a beautiful reading made more beautiful by understanding the Greek. It's amazing in how it shows Jesus lowering himself to our level. 

Wait, so the third time, does Peter say, "Lord, you know I agape you"?

Posted (edited)

all you need is love

love is all you need

if I have to define,it (for me) I would say it's the feeling I get in my chest/heart when I embrace my spouse :love:

Edited by little2add
Posted

Wait, so the third time, does Peter say, "Lord, you know I agape you"?

No, still phileo.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

I recomend reading reading 'Deus Caritas Est' written by pope benedict XVI. It is a supprisingly simple read and easy to understand. I think the titile means 'On Christian love', it is all about what the church teaches as to what love is. Of course we all have our own interpretations and experiences as to what 'love is' but this encyclical by the pope is a great source of illumination upon the question as to 'what is christian love?' It's not a huge book either, only like 30-50 pages, very easy to read and you just type 'deus caritas est' in the search engine at vatican.va and you can read it for free. :) I don't know whether encyclicals are infallible documents but i think a great source from our beloved Popes to help us better understand faith, hope and love.

Edited by Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Nihil Obstat
Posted

Baby don't hurt me

Don't hurt me

No more

Spem in alium
Posted

Yay, Greek! I'm going to limit myself to that, because I think everyone else has great answers. When Jesus gives these two commandments, he uses agape. A really famous occurrence of changing between the different words for love comes in John 21. Jesus asks Peter "Peter do you agape me?" (for those of you who know greek, I'm obviously butchering the conjugation, meh). Peter responds "Lord you know I phileo you." This repeats 2x, then the last time Jesus asks "Peter, do you phileo me? At which point Peter "becomes grieved." Anyway, a beautiful reading made more beautiful by understanding the Greek. It's amazing in how it shows Jesus lowering himself to our level. 

This is so incredibly beautiful! I agree, it definitely shows Jesus lowering himself to meet us. But I think it also shows Peter's deep humanity. To me, that's the essence of what love is - vulnerability, willingly making ourselves vulnerable, lowering ourselves, for the sake of the other. We cannot truly love without giving some part of ourselves to the other, without seeing someone for who they truly are - their good and bad qualities - and still choosing to give ourselves to them. Jesus' above encounter with Peter is a great example, because even though Jesus knew who Peter was, and what he had done, he still chose to love. Jesus gives himself completely in a love that has and will never be equalled.

God is love and is the source of love. To love God is to acknowledge Him for exactly who He is, to seek to please Him for exactly who He is, and to attempt to never grieve Him for exactly who He is. Everyone's heart is capable of this.

I very much like this definition. 

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

I personally think God is far above our understanding or reason and since God is love than so is love. Without the intervention of God himself it is not possible for man to love God or anyone else whatever love is. I kind of just had a bit of a moment with God about this and how it is not possible for me to imagine what is after death except that what i believe is that i will be in complete union with God, of course if i believe in and submit to the truth to the best of my knowledge and understanding of what is the truth,which is a growing thing until the day i die or the 2nd coming, whichever comes 1st. And since the Truth is God and God is Love, well pachow, what an infinite indivisible mystery is the most holy trinity though we are revealed bits and pieces of this mystery that is love over time communally and personally through faith and reason but i dare say it is not possible to know completely the mystery of God for neither the angels nor the son know the day that has been appointed by the father where all will be revealed, for this we must wait peacefully,bridle our passion for this momment and try to not get excited for this, which each day draws ever closer than the previous.  Though of course we are to enter into this mystery seeking what is love in prayer,meditation, holy scripture, sacred tradition and the most holy sacraments.

Edited by Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
HopefulHeart
Posted

This is love:

ICyoVdam.jpg

Posted (edited)

I was reading recently the pagan philosopher Plotinus and he talks about the love itself as a separate person that comes into existence. I think this is true, even on a human level isn't love, to be in love, essentially to have a common person that you both imagine being...and to fall out of love is to stop trying to create this other person together. I thought this was interesting too vis a vis the Trinity, because the son is the love of the father begotten as another person, and in turn the love of the father and son is another person...the Holy Spirit.

Edited by Era Might
Nihil Obstat
Posted

I was reading recently the pagan philosopher Plotinus and he talks about the love itself as a separate person that comes into existence. I think this is true, even on a human level isn't love, to be in love, essentially to have a common person that you both imagine being...and to fall out of love is to stop trying to create this other person together. I thought this was interesting too vis a vis the Trinity, because the son is the love of the father begotten as another person, and in turn the love of the father and son is another person...the Holy Spirit.

Not a mutually created person, but a mutually sought Person.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...