Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Just war and today's wars


Recommended Posts

NadaTeTurbe
Posted

To me the most sickening thing was Nagasaki - that they could go and drop a second bomb when they knew what the first one had done. And that the bombardiers and ground staff wrote jeering 'hello' messages on that second bomb before it was loaded onto the plane, even though they knew what it was going to do. It makes me wonder what it takes to become so sick at soul and violent.

The demonization of the ennemy was terrible during the Pacific war (in both camp). in 1944, for exemple, the magazine Life published a picture of a young, pretty woman, watching a japanese skull that her fiancée sent to her : http://time.com/3880997/young-woman-with-jap-skull-portrait-of-a-grisly-wwii-memento/ 
The american mutilation of japanese dead was terrible : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_mutilation_of_Japanese_war_dead 

SaintOfVirtue
Posted (edited)

Had we continued fighting in an ethical fashion, regardless of how many more would have died, they would have died in a way which was truly honorable. 

But let's ask ourselves today if Fr.'s thinking is correct.  We could nuke ISIS right now. Would that be the best moral option for us to take? What if other countries supported our decision and the data supported the hypothesis that it would save more lives in the long run? Would we stil be justified in nuking them knowing innocent civilians would also die? Hopefully anyone with a moral compass would agree it would not be the right decision to take such actions regardless of if "all" other options have failed.  We are morally obligated to continue fighting the good fight and to give our lives for this good fight instead of fighting a bad fight and securing temporary happiness in exchange for eternal ruin.  

I shouldn't be getting involved in this debate, but I believe what you are saying is twisted and delusional.

"Regardless of how many more would have died?"  Really? So if we stormed the island, lost men on the beaches, lost men in the cities, the fields, the caves, and mountains and then on top of that killed the entire population to win, it would have been "truly honorable".  That's sounds sicker and more twisted a moral philosophy than the bomb.  Does it make any difference in the end whether they died by infantryman or atomic bomb? No. the fact of the matter is that war is a gruesome and ugly thing and people who cannot come to terms with that say the sort of things you do.  Essentially: "More should have died to prevent this atrocity."  Give me a break. Then we'd be talking about the atrocity of how we exterminated an entire people when we could have broken their spirit to continue fighting with two bombs and forced a surrender.  Every time the bomb debate comes up I hear someone say exactly what you said, and while I find myself on the fence about whether the bomb was justified or not, I find it utterly disgusting to hear people say that it would have been morally right/desirable for more to die.  You defeat your own argument with your solution.

Edited by SaintOfVirtue
Nihil Obstat
Posted

The moral choice was between "A" and "not A". Not between A and B and C and D. The moral object of A is inherently evil, therefore A is morally forbidden.

Credo in Deum
Posted

I shouldn't be getting involved in this debate, but I believe what you are saying is twisted and delusional.
"Regardless of how many more would have died?"  Really? So if we stormed the island, lost men on the beaches, lost men in the cities, the fields, the caves, and mountains and then on top of that killed the entire population to win, it would have been "truly honorable".  That's sounds sicker and more twisted a moral philosophy than the bomb.  Does it make any difference in the end whether they died by infantryman or atomic bomb? No. the fact of the matter is that war is a gruesome and ugly thing and people who cannot come to terms with that say the sort of things you do.  Essentially: "More should have died to prevent this atrocity."  Give me a break. Then we'd be talking about the atrocity of how we exterminated an entire people when we could have broken their spirit to continue fighting with two bombs and forced a surrender.  Every time the bomb debate comes up I hear someone say exactly what you said, and while I find myself on the fence about whether the bomb was justified or not, I find it utterly disgusting to hear people say that it would have been morally right/desirable for more to die.  You defeat your own argument with your solution.

You make alot of assumptions and I'm sorry you cannot see the ethics behind having military men fighting each other vs wipping out both military and civilian indescriminantly via automic weapons.  Sorry but saying "war is gruesome and an ugly thing" does not take away our moral obligation to do what is morally right during times of war. You also jump to the odd conclusion that every Japanese citizen was ready to fight and die for the empire. This is a common tatic used to jusitfy the use of bombs and one born out of more delusion than my own.  You probably think we should nuke North Korea since all of its citizens love their brutal dictator and would need a show of power to sap them of their desire to die for their opressive government. ;) 

 

Posted

And in Just war you are allowed to use all means necessary to subdue the enemy. That's my understanding of just war doctrine. 

idk, if Tab is on here right now, but I still wanted to address this statement, because I don't think it has addressed yet.  Just war does not say you can use all force necessary. You are not allowed to directly attack civilians; civilian casualties are to be minimized; only as much force as necessary to defend is to be used. 

There are an equal number debates over whether fire-bombings were just, but maybe the nuclear bombs are more discussed because they were so dramatic and pointed to a very clear shift in warfare.  I think you could make a good argument, though, that the mentality to hit civilians was well in place through the firebombings and not a new strategy. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

 

idk, if Tab is on here right now, but I still wanted to address this statement, because I don't think it has addressed yet.  Just war does not say you can use all force necessary. You are not allowed to directly attack civilians; civilian casualties are to be minimized; only as much force as necessary to defend is to be used. 

There are an equal number debates over whether fire-bombings were just, but maybe the nuclear bombs are more discussed because they were so dramatic and pointed to a very clear shift in warfare.  I think you could make a good argument, though, that the mentality to hit civilians was well in place through the firebombings and not a new strategy. 

Yes, I think the fire bombings of Japan and Germany were every bit as evil, and morally speaking identical to the nuclear bombs. When I am being more careful I always try to refer to both at once. :)

Posted

l

A British sniper from the elite SAS saved an 8-year-old boy and his father from an Islamic State executioner by shooting the executioner in the head last month.

The SAS sniper team was reportedly tipped off to the execution in the Syrian desert by an Iraqi spy. When they arrived, they found that several Shia Muslims had already been beheaded by their captors. The IS (commonly referred to as ISIS) executioner, flanked on both sides by armed companions, was preparing to kill a young boy and his father next when the SAS team deployed its .50-caliber silenced sniper rifle.

“The ISIS thug who was about to decapitate the father was shot in the head and collapsed,” an unnamed source told the Daily Star. “Everyone just stared in confusion.”

“The sniper then dispatched the two henchmen with single shots–three kills with three bullets.”

The young boy and his father were last spotted heading to the Turkish border as the Syrian town they were evacuating celebrated the killing of the IS fighters.

WAS THE BRITISH SNIPER JUSTIFIED?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

 

 

WAS THE BRITISH SNIPER JUSTIFIED?

Probably yes. But if instead he incinerated ten Syrian towns, men women and children, to intimidate the executioner into surrendering, then no probably not. If instead the British military kidnapped the executioner's entire family, and tortured them until he surrendered, then no probably not. See the pattern here?

Posted

One of the things I have read was that the reason Hiroshima was chosen was because it was never previously bombed, and therefore it was the best chance to study the effects of the bomb without other data "tainting" it.  To me, that is what is chilling.   

It was likely because they were racist too. They waited until the end and then decided to drop a bomb on Japan. Why not Germany and when Hitler was alive? It's not like they didn't know about all the atrocities and deaths going on. Did they ever bomb or destroy any of those train lines taking Jews to their deaths? What about those gas chambers installations? Nope..

Japanese people aren't white and they aren't Christian. So it seems they were disposable to 'end it'. There was also an aspect of retribution to it too after the Japanese bombing of Pearl Harbor. But at least the Japanese only bombed a military target!

I see the same attitude now against those in lands who are systematically dehumanized and given over to bombing campaigns, some done in reprisals or in fear. The problem now is the 'targets' aren't nations, but terrorist cell groups operating across countries where they can take advantage of a poor western track record, national instability, a history of abusive regimes and civil wars. They can't be easily dealt with as it's more subtle and insidious. Militarism and violence simply fuels its growth. Wrong tools for this problem, on the whole anyway, as the evidence shows it doesn't work. Efforts to create stability, access to resources, education, safety and diplomacy should be the first avenues in this day and age. But that doesn't win political ratings when things are seen to go bad at home with voters. Leaders tend to play to the gallery, so it seems, and that always requires resorting to force and other bad options.:sad2:

 

I used to be in the just war theory camp but became a pacifist when I started working in humanitarian aid and I met people who had suffered through war. Listening to them, and gathering data on what they had experienced, I began to feel that talking about a just war is like talking about a rosy hypothetical la-la land that can never really exist, because even wars that look just in principle are not just in the way they are carried out. In addition to setting certain preconditions for war, just war theory also requires that wars be waged in a certain way - and I have yet to come across a single war that didn't also involve war crimes. Hitler's regime was murderous and needed to be stopped, but despite that, what the Allied bombers did to Dresden was unconscionable - the end doesn't justify the means in Catholic thought. This makes war a very thorny issue in Christian thinking and you're not obliged to support it.

Yes, totally. They killed loads of civilians, partly as reprisals, to destroy a cultural hub and German morale. The allies said they did it to destroy factory production, communciation and travel hubs. However, they left key industrial bases on the edges of the city because they did indiscriminate bombing in the town centre instead. If anything, they slowed down and made it harder for the Russians to capture the city. About 30,000 lost their lives as a result of that bombing. War always has more of a devasting impact on civilians, mostly women and children. What capturing forces did to women, including young girls and boys, is also well documented. Completely barbaric.

 

SaintOfVirtue
Posted

The moral choice was between "A" and "not A". Not between A and B and C and D. The moral object of A is inherently evil, therefore A is morally forbidden.

The choice "not A" was implied by Credo in Deum per the statement "Had we continued fighting in an ethical fashion."  I'm not arguing for or against the bomb here I'm saying that the choice "not A" is not an iota morally better than "A" (Also, irony is 'fighting in an ethical fashion')

 

You make alot of assumptions and I'm sorry you cannot see the ethics behind having military men fighting each other vs wipping out both military and civilian indescriminantly via automic weapons.  Sorry but saying "war is gruesome and an ugly thing" does not take away our moral obligation to do what is morally right during times of war. You also jump to the odd conclusion that every Japanese citizen was ready to fight and die for the empire. This is a common tatic used to jusitfy the use of bombs and one born out of more delusion than my own.  You probably think we should nuke North Korea since all of its citizens love their brutal dictator and would need a show of power to sap them of their desire to die for their opressive government. ;) 

 

I fail to see how a course of action which would have caused more to die can be considered "morally right" is the life of the civilian worth more than the soldier?  From your statements I think your answer would be yes, but don't let me assume; what is your answer?  Further I am not speaking of every individual Japanese person, but that the majority would have stood and fought invading American soldiers and the same end would have been met but at a greater cost to both sides.  Did you know the Japanese army was so upset with the emperor for announcing a surrender that a thousand of them attacked the Imperial Palace (August 14th, 1945)?  Lastly you too have made assumptions: I do not support nuking North Korea.  A war with North Korea would be terribly a terribly sad ordeal because its people are so ignorant as to not be culpable for their actions.

Nihil Obstat
Posted (edited)

Nonsense. You cannot equate the actual positive choice for evil with a choice not to commit evil, and you cannot equate the choice not to commit evil with an active choice for a different evil. That is absolutely incoherent and the sign of a deeply skewed moral outlook.

Edited by Nihil Obstat
Credo in Deum
Posted

I fail to see how a course of action which would have caused more to die can be considered "morally right" is the life of the civilian worth more than the soldier?  From your statements I think your answer would be yes, but don't let me assume; what is your answer?  Further I am not speaking of every individual Japanese person, but that the majority would have stood and fought invading American soldiers and the same end would have been met but at a greater cost to both sides.  Did you know the Japanese army was so upset with the emperor for announcing a surrender that a thousand of them attacked the Imperial Palace (August 14th, 1945)?  Lastly you too have made assumptions: I do not support nuking North Korea.  A war with North Korea would be terribly a terribly sad ordeal because its people are so ignorant as to not be culpable for their actions.

No one knows if more would have died vs the amount of people who did die during the bomb and the fallout, and frankly it doesn't matter.  Regardless of how many would have died, what matters morally is how they did die.  It's not about a civilian being worth more than a solider.  It has everything to do with the boundaries that exist which separate the soldier from the civilian.  One is a combatant and the other is not.  One has distinguished themselves to be a threat, the other has not and thus should be treated as a non-combatant until they have proven themselves to be a combatant. Treating every civilian as a soldier, including those who have absolutely no possible way of fighting (babies, the elderly), is morally detestable and evil.  Also yes, I did know the army stormed the palace.  So what? 

Posted

It was likely because they were racist too. They waited until the end and then decided to drop a bomb on Japan. Why not Germany and when Hitler was alive? It's not like they didn't know about all the atrocities and deaths going on. Did they ever bomb or destroy any of those train lines taking Jews to their deaths? What about those gas chambers installations? Nope..

Japanese people aren't white and they aren't Christian. So it seems they were disposable to 'end it'. There was also an aspect of retribution to it too after the Japanese bombing of Pearl Harbor. But at least the Japanese only bombed a military target!

 

It's possible that the reason the A-bomb was not used on Germany was that it was not ready until after the war in Europe was over (the first A-bomb test was in July). 

However, one friend of mine (who is now a priest) wondered if anti-Catholicism had a part in it, as Nagasaki was a center of Catholicism in Japan, and the bomb detonated above the Catholic cathedral.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

idk, if Tab is on here right now, but I still wanted to address this statement, because I don't think it has addressed yet.  Just war does not say you can use all force necessary. You are not allowed to directly attack civilians; civilian casualties are to be minimized; only as much force as necessary to defend is to be used. 

There are an equal number debates over whether fire-bombings were just, but maybe the nuclear bombs are more discussed because they were so dramatic and pointed to a very clear shift in warfare.  I think you could make a good argument, though, that the mentality to hit civilians was well in place through the firebombings and not a new strategy. 

It is not nescisary to kill civilians, therefore undue force. It is difficult to not have innocent casualties in war though, although yes of course these are to be avoided at all costs. But how many innocent civilians are there if many civilians are supporting the 3rd reich and its desire to take over europe? How do you tell who is innocent and who is not, many civilians of an enemy nation actually support the enemy, that's why they remain in the nation and have not fled. And the ones that remain obviously are taking a risk and already prepared to die at the hands of either waring parties.

Just popped in quickly. Back to my fast. God bless you all. All my comments are just alternative, i don't intend to be argumentative.

Edited by Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
extra

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...